Real market profile (at least from MT4) - page 4

New comment
 
sanyooooook:

Why?
Because for the price to move, someone has to sell and someone has to buy, and only those who are able to guess in time whether they should go for the buyers or sellers side will win. If the indicator "the mood of the crowd" will be a bar chart, it means that the time component will be lost and it will be impossible to identify the 3% of traders who are winning.
 
Sanyok, in the profile paradigm the question arises - how much order volume is needed to make it right?
 
IgorM:
Because in order for the price to move, someone has to sell and someone has to buy, and only those who can guess in time whether the buyers or sellers side should be taken now win. If the indicator "the mood of the crowd" will be a histogram, it means that time component will be lost and it will be unreal to determine the notorious 3% of traders who win.

According to my calculations, this percentage tends to zero over time.
 
sergeev:

Sanyok, in the profile paradigm, the question arises - how much order volume is needed to make it right?

i.e. how many trades would you need to be enough to consider using this tool?
 
sergeev:

Sanyok, in the profile paradigm the question arises - how much order volume is needed to make it right?

The point is not who is right and who is wrong, the point is who is right and where. )
 
Oanda, for example, has all these levels of pending orders freely available (also for intraday). It is unlikely that more clients than in Oanda will participate in this project
 
sanyooooook:

By my calculations, that percentage tends to zero over time.
I do too, but that's the main problem with trading - identifying in time that the TS has stopped working and watching from the sidelines
 
Avals:
oanda, for example, has all these levels of pending orders. It is unlikely that more clients than in Oanda will participate in this project

Exactly, so you can trade with this information?
 
sergeev:

that is, how many traders would be enough for you to consider using this tool?

and if that's what you meant, the more the better.

After all, there is a price book on the fund, and it is not a bad place to lose deposits.

 
sanyooooook:

After all, there is a price tier on the fund, and it's not a bad place to lose deposits.

So it's not about the market?

Sasha, the traders' profile is not a cure-all. It won't do anything. Do you even use the oanda yourself? How can it be improved?

1234567891011
New comment