The Copyright infringement issue of Igor's code is clear, unambiguous, gross and cynical - General

Artyom Trishkin 2015.10.13 11:01 #111

Andrey F. Zelinsky:

why the 4th forum? -- he's here now -- both in marketplace and freelance.

Here's an example of his code in the codebase https://www.mql5.com/ru/code/9835

Kim wrote in all his functions:

But if you look at the "doer" code, Kim's copyright is rubbed out there.

Where are the human rights speakers here?

That's where the copyright is really being violated.

The functions in that template were taken directly from Igor. The only thing he did was to change the name and remove Igor's copyright in the header. At the same time, instead of Igor's copyright I blatantly inserted my own:

string Autor=" Автор функции для шаблона : www.expforex.at.ua";

A clear misappropriation of someone else's merits and a violation of Igor's authorship by substituting his own.

Errors, bugs, questions Useful features from KimIV Gone is the Bookkeeper

Andrey F. Zelinsky 2015.10.13 11:10 #112

Artyom Trishkin:

The functions in that template were taken cleanly from Igor. I only changed the name and removed Igor's copyright in the header. Igor's copyright is replaced by his own:

Unambiguous misappropriation of someone else's credit and infringement of Igor's authorship by substituting authorship for oneself.

I wonder why IC does not remove his code from the codebase?

Because the copyright infringement is obvious and easy to check. Kim's code is in the public domain.

Why aren't issues of such copyright infringement raised?

Here are the Terms of Use https://www.mql5.com/ru/about/terms:

3.9. You agree not to reproduce, copy, sell, trade or resell the content of www.mql5.com. The only exception is if a separate agreement with MQL5 Ltd allows otherwise. If you make copies of any Content, all copyright and other proprietary notices contained in the original materials must be retained on such copies. You may not modify the Content or publicly display, reproduce or distribute it. The mql5.com website is owned by MQL5 Ltd. MQL5 Ltd websites are protected by international copyright laws. Any unauthorized use of MQL5 Ltd Websites may violate copyright, trademark and other laws.

Clear, unambiguous, deliberate, gross and cynical infringement -- and with impunity.

The fastest economic calendar. Is there any rules Code Base licences

Artyom Trishkin 2015.10.13 11:14 #113

Igor's function SetOrder()

//+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
//|  Автор    : Ким Игорь В. aka KimIV,  http://www.kimiv.ru                   |
//+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
//|  Версия   : 13.03.2008                                                     |
//|  Описание : Установка ордера.                                              |
//+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
//|  Параметры:                                                                |
//|    sy - наименование инструмента   (NULL или "" - текущий символ)          |
//|    op - операция                                                           |
//|    ll - лот                                                                |
//|    pp - цена                                                               |
//|    sl - уровень стоп                                                       |
//|    tp - уровень тейк                                                       |
//|    mn - Magic Number                                                       |
//|    ex - Срок истечения                                                     |
//+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
void SetOrder(string sy, int op, double ll, double pp,
              double sl=0, double tp=0, int mn=0, datetime ex=0) {
  color    clOpen;
  datetime ot;
  double   pa, pb, mp;
  int      err, it, ticket, msl;
  string   lsComm=WindowExpertName()+" "+GetNameTF(Period());

  if (sy=="" || sy=="0") sy=Symbol();
  msl=MarketInfo(sy, MODE_STOPLEVEL);
  if (op==OP_BUYLIMIT || op==OP_BUYSTOP) clOpen=clOpenBuy; else clOpen=clOpenSell;
  if (ex>0 && ex<TimeCurrent()) ex=0;
  for (it=1; it<=NumberOfTry; it++) {
    if (!IsTesting() && (!IsExpertEnabled() || IsStopped())) {
      Print("SetOrder(): Остановка работы функции");
      break;
    }
    while (!IsTradeAllowed()) Sleep(5000);
    RefreshRates();
    ot=TimeCurrent();
    ticket=OrderSend(sy, op, ll, pp, Slippage, sl, tp, lsComm, mn, ex, clOpen);
    if (ticket>0) {
      if (UseSound) PlaySound(NameFileSound); break;
    } else {
      err=GetLastError();
      if (err==128 || err==142 || err==143) {
        Sleep(1000*66);
        if (ExistOrders(sy, op, mn, ot)) {
          if (UseSound) PlaySound(NameFileSound); break;
        }
        Print("Error(",err,") set order: ",ErrorDescription(err),", try ",it);
        continue;
      }
      mp=MarketInfo(sy, MODE_POINT);
      pa=MarketInfo(sy, MODE_ASK);
      pb=MarketInfo(sy, MODE_BID);
      // Неправильные стопы
      if (err==130) {
        switch (op) {
          case OP_BUYLIMIT:
            if (pp>pa-msl*mp) pp=pa-msl*mp;
            if (sl>pp-(msl+1)*mp) sl=pp-(msl+1)*mp;
            if (tp>0 && tp<pp+(msl+1)*mp) tp=pp+(msl+1)*mp;
            break;
          case OP_BUYSTOP:
            if (pp<pa+(msl+1)*mp) pp=pa+(msl+1)*mp;
            if (sl>pp-(msl+1)*mp) sl=pp-(msl+1)*mp;
            if (tp>0 && tp<pp+(msl+1)*mp) tp=pp+(msl+1)*mp;
            break;
          case OP_SELLLIMIT:
            if (pp<pb+msl*mp) pp=pb+msl*mp;
            if (sl>0 && sl<pp+(msl+1)*mp) sl=pp+(msl+1)*mp;
            if (tp>pp-(msl+1)*mp) tp=pp-(msl+1)*mp;
            break;
          case OP_SELLSTOP:
            if (pp>pb-msl*mp) pp=pb-msl*mp;
            if (sl>0 && sl<pp+(msl+1)*mp) sl=pp+(msl+1)*mp;
            if (tp>pp-(msl+1)*mp) tp=pp-(msl+1)*mp;
            break;
        }
        Print("SetOrder(): Скорректированы ценовые уровни");
      }
      Print("Error(",err,") set order: ",ErrorDescription(err),", try ",it);
      Print("Ask=",pa,"  Bid=",pb,"  sy=",sy,"  ll=",ll,"  op=",GetNameOP(op),
            "  pp=",pp,"  sl=",sl,"  tp=",tp,"  mn=",mn);
      if (pa==0 && pb==0) Message("SetOrder(): Проверьте в обзоре рынка наличие символа "+sy);
      // Блокировка работы советника
      if (err==2 || err==64 || err==65 || err==133) {
        gbDisabled=True; break;
      }
      // Длительная пауза
      if (err==4 || err==131 || err==132) {
        Sleep(1000*300); break;
      }
      // Слишком частые запросы (8) или слишком много запросов (141)
      if (err==8 || err==141) Sleep(1000*100);
      if (err==139 || err==140 || err==148) break;
      // Ожидание освобождения подсистемы торговли
      if (err==146) while (IsTradeContextBusy()) Sleep(1000*11);
      // Обнуление даты истечения
      if (err==147) {
        ex=0; continue;
      }
      if (err!=135 && err!=138) Sleep(1000*7.7);
    }
  }
}
//+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+

The function of a gentleman appropriating someone else's things:

//+------------------------------------------------------------------+
//|              Установка отложенного ордера                        |
//+------------------------------------------------------------------+
//+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
//|  Параметры:                                                                |
//|    sy - наименование инструмента   (NULL или "" - текущий символ)          |
//|    op - операция                                                           |
//|    ll - лот                                                                |
//|    pp - цена                                                               |
//|    sl - уровень стоп                                                       |
//|    tp - уровень тейк                                                       |
//|    mn - Magic Number                                                       |
//|    ex - Срок истечения                                                     |
//+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
int SetOrder(string sy,int op,double ll,double pp,
             double sl=0,double tp=0,int mn=0,datetime ex=0,string lsComm="")
  {
   color    clOpen;
   datetime ot;
   double   pa,pb,mp;
   int      err,it,ticket,msl;
   string Autor=" Автор функции для шаблона : www.expforex.at.ua";

   if(sy=="" || sy=="0") sy=Symbol();
   msl=MarketInfo(sy,MODE_STOPLEVEL);
   if(ex>0 && ex<TimeCurrent()) ex=0;
   for(it=1; it<=5; it++)
     {
      if(!IsTesting() && (!IsExpertEnabled() || IsStopped()))
        {
         Print("SetOrder(): Остановка работы функции");
         break;
        }
      while(!IsTradeAllowed()) Sleep(5000);
      RefreshRates();
      ot=TimeCurrent();
      if(!MarketWatch)ticket=OrderSend(sy,op,ll,NormalizeDouble(pp,MarketInfo(sy,MODE_DIGITS)),Slippage,NormalizeDouble(sl,MarketInfo(sy,MODE_DIGITS)),NormalizeDouble(tp,MarketInfo(sy,MODE_DIGITS)),lsComm,mn,ex,clOpen);
      if(MarketWatch)

        {
         ticket=OrderSend(sy,op,ll,NormalizeDouble(pp,MarketInfo(sy,MODE_DIGITS)),Slippage,0,0,lsComm,mn,ex,clOpen);
         if(SBT(ticket)) ModifyOrder(-1,sl,tp);
        }

      if(ticket>0)
        {

         return(ticket);
         break;
           } else {
         err=GetLastError();
         if(err==128 || err==142 || err==143)
           {
            Sleep(1000*66);

            continue;
           }
         mp=MarketInfo(sy, MODE_POINT);
         pa=MarketInfo(sy, MODE_ASK);
         pb=MarketInfo(sy, MODE_BID);
         if(pa==0 && pb==0) Comment("SetOrder(): Проверьте в обзоре рынка наличие символа "+sy);
         // Неправильные стопы
         if(err==130)
           {
            switch(op)
              {
               case OP_BUYLIMIT:
                  if(pp>pa-msl*mp) pp=pa-msl*mp;
                  if(sl>pp-(msl+1)*mp) sl=pp-(msl+1)*mp;
                  if(tp>0 && tp<pp+(msl+1)*mp) tp=pp+(msl+1)*mp;
                  break;
               case OP_BUYSTOP:
                  if(pp<pa+(msl+1)*mp) pp=pa+(msl+1)*mp;
                  if(sl>pp-(msl+1)*mp) sl=pp-(msl+1)*mp;
                  if(tp>0 && tp<pp+(msl+1)*mp) tp=pp+(msl+1)*mp;
                  break;
               case OP_SELLLIMIT:
                  if(pp<pb+msl*mp) pp=pb+msl*mp;
                  if(sl>0 && sl<pp+(msl+1)*mp) sl=pp+(msl+1)*mp;
                  if(tp>pp-(msl+1)*mp) tp=pp-(msl+1)*mp;
                  break;
               case OP_SELLSTOP:
                  if(pp>pb-msl*mp) pp=pb-msl*mp;
                  if(sl>0 && sl<pp+(msl+1)*mp) sl=pp+(msl+1)*mp;
                  if(tp>pp-(msl+1)*mp) tp=pp-(msl+1)*mp;
                  break;
              }
            Print("SetOrder(): Скорректированы ценовые уровни"+sy+"--op-"+op+"--ll-"+ll+"--pp-"+pp+"---"+Slippage+"--sl-"+sl+"--tp-"+tp+"---"+lsComm+"---"+mn+"---"+ex+"---"+clOpen);
           }
         // Блокировка работы советника
         if(err==2 || err==64 || err==65 || err==133)
           {
            break;
           }
         // Длительная пауза
         if(err==4 || err==131 || err==132)
           {
            Sleep(1000*300); break;
           }
         // Слишком частые запросы (8) или слишком много запросов (141)
         if(err==8 || err==141) Sleep(1000*100);
         if(err==139 || err==140 || err==148) break;
         // Ожидание освобождения подсистемы торговли
         if(err==146) while(IsTradeContextBusy()) Sleep(1000*11);
         // Обнуление даты истечения
         if(err==147)
           {
            ex=0; continue;
           }
         if(err!=135 && err!=138) Sleep(1000*7.7);
        }
     }
  }
//+------------------------------------------------------------------+

And tell me he didn't assign it because he changed a couple of lines...

I can provide as many examples of misappropriation of Igor's work as I want.

Andrey F. Zelinsky 2015.10.13 11:18 #114

Artyom Trishkin:

Igor's function SetOrder()

The function of the misappropriator:

And tell me he didn't assign it because he changed a couple of lines...

Well, you're wrong -- in Kim's it says "set order" -- and in hisit says "set pending order" -- do you feel the difference?

Artyom Trishkin 2015.10.13 11:22 #115

Andrey F. Zelinsky:
No, well, you're wrong -- Kim's says "set order" -- and hissays "set pending order" -- do you feel the difference? Don't you notice the invaluable contribution to Kim's code?

Oh, man... Bummer...

Andrey F. Zelinsky 2015.10.13 11:23 #116

By the way, Kim's code doesn't just have the copyright removed, it has an addition of his own authorship:

string Autor=" Автор функции для шаблона : www.expforex.at.ua";

If you look at his code in the codebase, the override of Kim's authorship to his own authorship is present in every Kim function.

For example https://www.mql5.com/ru/code/9835 .

Copywriting in the advisor Any rookie question, so Code Base licences

Mykola Demko 2015.10.13 11:29 #117

Question for a quiz: what is copyright?

1

//|                  Copyright 2015, Urain |

2

#property copyright "Copyright 2015, Urain"

The first or the second? Or both?

Artyom Trishkin 2015.10.13 11:31 #118

Andrey F. Zelinsky:

By the way, Kim's code doesn't just have the copyright removed, it has an addition of his own authorship:

If you look at his code in the codebase, the override of Kim's authorship to his own authorship is present in every Kim function.

For example https://www.mql5.com/ru/code/9835 .

Well, that's what I said. Igor even has his authorship in every function in all of his libraries. Even in those libraries, which are not in the public domain, but for commercial use.

Vladimir Pastushak 2015.10.13 11:31 #119

That's one of the fundamental points - you don't know the cuisine, but you're trying to become a chef straight away

What makes you think I don't know? I don't take part in freelance services but sometimes I do write code to order. This is an example of an unconsidered accusation)))

I haven't, but I can't know for sure. I've seen codes from good friends of mine passed off as theirs, changing the header in the source code, and leaving the rest of the code "as is". It was even discussed in our forum. On the fourth forum, one person on the fourth forum misrepresented Igor Kim's code as his own. Insolently and unceremoniously. Source code. This is despicable, vile and low.

That's one of the fundamental points - you don't know the cuisine, but you're trying to become a chef.

Don't think I'm for decompiles - no, I'm definitely against it. But you have to look at the circumstances. Either you think anyone who offers you code is a thief, or you think before you accuse.

No, I can't. But you can't prove that a customer makes money by breaking someone else's code either. Or has the presumption of innocence been abolished? So you'd better prove guilt first.

Otherwise I will show you code that looks like decompiled - you will become a thief because you saw this code.

I'm against any kind of decompiling in any form, once again I'm surprised at the number of programmers who don't shy away from getting their asses dirty for a penny.

What is there to prove? The fact is on the face of decompiling in the studio, and not knowing the rules does not exempt from liability.

ZigZags Shepherds [Archive!] Any rookie question, Proposal to the administration

Artyom Trishkin 2015.10.13 11:34 #120

Nikolay Demko:

Question for a quiz: What is copyright?

1

2

The first or the second? Or both?

What do you think?

For example, authorship?

//+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
//|  Автор    : Ким Игорь В. aka KimIV,  http://www.kimiv.ru                   |
//+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
//|  Версия   : 12.03.2008                                                     |
//|  Описание : Возвращает флаг существования ордеров.                         |
//+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
//|  Параметры:                                                                |
//|    sy - наименование инструмента   (""   - любой символ,                   |
//|                                     NULL - текущий символ)                 |
//|    op - операция                   (-1   - любой ордер)                    |
//|    mn - MagicNumber                (-1   - любой магик)                    |
//|    ot - время открытия             ( 0   - любое время установки)          |
//+----------------------------------------------------------------------------+
bool ExistOrders(string sy="", int op=-1, int mn=-1, datetime ot=0) {
  int i, k=OrdersTotal(), ty;
 
  if (sy=="0") sy=Symbol();
  for (i=0; i<k; i++) {
    if (OrderSelect(i, SELECT_BY_POS, MODE_TRADES)) {
      ty=OrderType();
      if (ty>1 && ty<6) {
        if ((OrderSymbol()==sy || sy=="") && (op<0 || ty==op)) {
          if (mn<0 || OrderMagicNumber()==mn) {
            if (ot<=OrderOpenTime()) return(True);
          }
        }
      }
    }
  }
  return(False);
}

How can I tell if I have decompiled or not? - page 12