Why put this in an EA: Bars<100 ?

New comment
samusmus1
448
samusmus1  
why do people use this protection in their EA? I mean, if you make your MT4 window smaller, you WANT the EA to continue trading, right? But with this protection, the EA will stop working and won't open any orders. I think it's useless, because if you don't want to trade, just turn off the EA. Or does this have another useful function?

if(Bars<100)
     {
      Print("bars less than 100");
      return(0);
     }

Marco vd Heijden
Moderator
13420
Marco vd Heijden  

Bars

Returns the number of bars count in the history for a specified symbol and period.

So this has got nothing to do with the number of bars on the chart and so it will not be affected by you changing the chart dimensions.

Maybe you are referring to:

VisibleBars

Gets total number of visible chart bars.

In any case if you are running an EA that uses for example a Moving Average of 100, then in order to calculate the value of this moving average, at least 100 bars have to be present, or the function will give a false reading.

If there are less then 100 bars in history, the correct value can not be calculated and if you are not using this filter it can result in unwanted or false entries.

Trying to wite a Is there a way What is the difference
William Roeder
24250
William Roeder  
samusmus1: why do people use this protection in their EA?
They are following what some moron did 15 years ago and don't know any better. They aren't a complete idiot, some parts are missing.
Carl Schreiber
Moderator
11447
Carl Schreiber  
In case of a symbol change, timeframe change, account change or terminal (re-) start it could be that the EA, indicator or script starts working while the quotes and other stuff (e.g. tickvalue) hasn't been available yet. OnInit() has already been passed and some of your values could have been set incorrectly!
Pips vs Points in Open and Close arrays Access violation write to
Alain Verleyen
41028
Alain Verleyen  
Carl Schreiber:
In case of a symbol change, timeframe change, account change or terminal (re-) start it could be that the EA, indicator or script starts working while the quotes and other stuff (e.g. tickvalue) hasn't been available yet. OnInit() has already been passed and some of your values could have been set incorrectly!
I don't see how what you wrote is related to the topic ?
Carl Schreiber
Moderator
11447
Carl Schreiber  
Alain Verleyen:
I don't see how what you wrote is related to the topic ?

The question was: "Why..."

Bars>100 is a protection against this kind of problem I described.

I check as well MarketInfo(Symbol(),MODE_TICKVALUE)) in start() or OnTick() or OnCalculate() ..

It is the reason and the answer of "Why ..."

CCI indicator Strange division problem Firebird EA
Alain Verleyen
41028
Alain Verleyen  
Carl Schreiber:

The question was: "Why..."

Bars>100 is a protection against this kind of problem I described.

I check as well MarketInfo(Symbol(),MODE_TICKVALUE)) in start() or OnTick() or OnCalculate() ..

It is the reason and the answer of "Why ..."

Sure, I know it's your answer ;-)

But what I don't see is how "Bars  < 100" is a protection against "the quotes and other stuff (e.g. tickvalue) hasn't been available yet" ? I mean, if it's one, it's not a good one in my opinion.

Anyway, probably not important.

how can i get Run code on stop MetaTrader 4 Client Terminal
New comment