Nur Nutzer, die das Produkt gekauft oder gemietet haben, können Kommentare hinterlassen
12
WiWaWi  
Is it correct that you do not consider all relevant fields in the history for the actual profit? Commission, swap, ... . Can you please calculate the actual resulting total profit as the Metatrader calculates in the history, otherwise significant deviations can occur.
LEE SAMSON  
WiWaWi:
Is it correct that you do not consider all relevant fields in the history for the actual profit? Commission, swap, ... . Can you please calculate the actual resulting total profit as the Metatrader calculates in the history, otherwise significant deviations can occur.

Hi, yes those are not taken into account. Will recode with the option to show nett figures rather than gross and update 👍

WiWaWi  

Hello,

it's been over two months now, nothing has happened, the profit will continue to be incorrectly displayed or determined.

I'm starting to regret the purchase.

 

LEE SAMSON  
WiWaWi:

Hello,

it's been over two months now, nothing has happened, the profit will continue to be incorrectly displayed or determined.

I'm starting to regret the purchase.

 

This was done many weeks ago. Please update your indicator.

WiWaWi  
LEE SAMSON:

This was done many weeks ago. Please update your indicator.

Which MT5 version are you talking about, which one should I update to? You have not reported an update here on MT5.
LEE SAMSON  
WiWaWi:
Which MT5 version are you talking about, which one should I update to? You have not reported an update here on MT5.

Sorry it was the MT4 version that was updated. The MT5 version was not done. Will get that into the work queue. Only sell a couple of MT5 products a month and tons of MT4 so assumed it was the MT4 version you were refereing to. Apologies for the confusion.

WiWaWi  
LEE SAMSON:

Sorry it was the MT4 version that was updated. The MT5 version was not done. Will get that into the work queue. Only sell a couple of MT5 products a month and tons of MT4 so assumed it was the MT4 version you were refereing to. Apologies for the confusion.

It's ok, but please understand, I can't use the MT5-dashboard like this.
WiWaWi  
How does it look, will there be a patch on MT5 this year so that this arithmetic error can be corrected? Nothing has happened since February, would like to take back my negative rating.
LEE SAMSON  
WiWaWi:

Here is a little help from me, which version is required here for the MT5, which has been fixed for the MT4:

https://www.mql5.com/de/market/product/58375?source=Site+Profile+Seller#!tab=updates

MT4: Version 1.10 2021.02.11

Adjustments to make the total profit figures include commissions and swaps rather than gross amounts.


Without that, the whole thing is no good!

Works fine as is, very little difference for 99% of traders but will tweak it though for you.

WiWaWi  

Almost all brokers have swap. Many brokers the swap increases sharply from 9:00 p.m. . With some currencies swap can be very high, then the results are falsified and shown as profit, even though the total is losses. Relevant for night scalper.

Commission is not always common.

I think that 99% do not notice this artithmetic error.  The majority rely on the correctness of the calculation and do not check it at all.

At MT4 you had already corrected that. You didn't do it for me there ;-) .

All the better if it is corrected that your programs work identically on MT4 and MT5.

I'm looking forward to trying out the update soon.
WiWaWi  

Version 2.0:

I have now updated, the profit remains wrong. Is there anything else that needs to be configured? Am I doing something wrong?


aaronpriest  
WiWaWi #:

Version 2.0:

I have now updated, the profit remains wrong. Is there anything else that needs to be configured? Am I doing something wrong?


A year later and this is still incorrect and not posting the correct price after commissions. Also, SYMBOL on the top right table needs to be changed to DATE to match the MT4 version. Please fix/update the MT5 version! :-) 

LEE SAMSON  
aaronpriest #:

A year later and this is still incorrect and not posting the correct price after commissions. Also, SYMBOL on the top right table needs to be changed to DATE to match the MT4 version. Please fix/update the MT5 version! :-) 

Was fixed on 25th May 2021. Check the whats new tab. All fine.

aaronpriest  
LEE SAMSON #:

Was fixed on 25th May 2021. Check the whats new tab. All fine.

Thanks for changing Symbol to Date. :-) 

As far as the profit being fixed May 25, 2021 and all fine, that was not my experience yesterday. I'll check again after I have new trades today or tomorrow though. Thanks again!

LEE SAMSON  
aaronpriest #:

Thanks for changing Symbol to Date. :-) 

As far as the profit being fixed May 25, 2021 and all fine, that was not my experience yesterday. I'll check again after I have new trades today or tomorrow though. Thanks again!

Works fine for me, was fixed last year as I said. 

aaronpriest  
LEE SAMSON #:

Works fine for me, was fixed last year as I said. 

Here is today for me on a new account. I'm actually -183.22 after commissions and swap, not +44.90.


aaronpriest  
aaronpriest #:

Here is today for me on a new account. I'm actually -183.22 after commissions and swap, not +44.90.


Although, if I go to my history tab like you did, then you are getting the number that MT5 is reporting as profit, which does NOT include commissions on MT5 for some reason. So maybe MT5 is to blame, but it's not showing what I'd like to see for true daily figures at any rate. Maybe this is what people are complaining about comparing it to MT4 (which does include commissions in their report). It's the total profit on the left summary column that we'd like tracked, not the right profit column.

LEE SAMSON  
aaronpriest #:

Although, if I go to my history tab like you did, then you are getting the number that MT5 is reporting as profit, which does NOT include commissions on MT5 for some reason. So maybe MT5 is to blame, but it's not showing what I'd like to see for true daily figures at any rate. Maybe this is what people are complaining about comparing it to MT4 (which does include commissions in their report). It's the total profit on the left summary column that we'd like tracked, not the right profit column.

Yes something odd there. The indicator reports as MT5 does. Seems an issues with MT5, probably why only around 5% of sales are on MT5. I'll put it on the developmnet list to look at this at some point but that is what we have to work with in the code unfortunately and what it reports.

aaronpriest  

Hi Lee, several of my MT5 accounts are showing open trades in Trade Manager Dashboard, but there are no open trades on the account. It started over the weekend. I thought it would resolve itself when the market opened back up, but it has not. I've closed charts, opened new ones, re-attached the EA, the problem remains. It's like a caching issue, but I can't find anything I should clear. Here's a screenshot:


I finally completely removed Trade Manager Dashboard and reinstalled it from the market place and attached it to a new chart, it then picked up two new "phantom" trades that don't exist, and the lines are squashed together:


Nur Nutzer, die das Produkt gekauft oder gemietet haben, können Kommentare hinterlassen
12