Yalnızca ürünü satın alan veya kiralayan kullanıcılar yorum yazabilir
Richard Caughell  

I noticed running backtest on this indicator, S/D zones that get broken, disappear. I find this interesting considering when price breaks these areas it gives the trader to things to look at and learn what it is that caused the break in the first place.


Looking at a few different aspects to look at to determine why the channel broke

1: Patterns

2: Fibo levels

3: Candlestick Patterns

4: Volume

5: different divergence/convergence on indicators

6: The most important IMO, the trader can look to learn when price bounces off these areas and continues you trend and how it correlates with HTFs


Looks like it has potential, with some adjustments





Richard Caughell  
Sergey Efimenko:
I advice you to use this indicator with Currency Power Meter Linear to look at currency force when breaking any level or bouncing from it.
Ya but if the S/D area disappears you wouldnt be able to determine if its bouncing off prior S/D area and continuing trend. Ya you can have a currency strength indication but would that help you show key price areas, even thou they have disappeared already ?
Sergey Efimenko  
Richard Caughell:
Ya but if the S/D area disappears you wouldnt be able to determine if its bouncing off prior S/D area and continuing trend. Ya you can have a currency strength indication but would that help you show key price areas, even thou they have disappeared already ?
S/D areas is very relative things, so you can see the area where the price will come trougth it without any resistance... this indicator shows only the last S/D areas calculated on indicators in review, but not all of it is strengh, the strengh depends of timeframe. So to see more strength areas look at higher timeframe.
Richard Caughell  
Sergey Efimenko:
S/D areas is very relative things, so you can see the area where the price will come trougth it without any resistance... this indicator shows only the last S/D areas calculated on indicators in review, but not all of it is strengh, the strengh depends of timeframe. So to see more strength areas look at higher timeframe.

ya but if they disappear how can you determine the strength or weakness ? How can you learn where these ares were prior ?


Im a big S/D trader and find areas get extended all the time. And the more price comes into these areas breaking it or reversing they more they become tellin into price action. Im personally looking for soemthing that doesnt disappear and allows the zone areas to get extended even after price breaks to help show bounces off, consolidation, accumulation, and everything I listed above.


Yes I can draw all this stuff, but I find your S/D indicator has potential with some tweaks.

Sergey Efimenko  
Richard Caughell:

ya but if they disappear how can you determine the strength or weakness ? How can you learn where these ares were prior ?


Im a big S/D trader and find areas get extended all the time. And the more price comes into these areas breaking it or reversing they more they become tellin into price action. Im personally looking for soemthing that doesnt disappear and allows the zone areas to get extended even after price breaks to help show bounces off, consolidation, accumulation, and everything I listed above.


Yes I can draw all this stuff, but I find your S/D indicator has potential with some tweaks.

I understand you from the first comment, i will think how to release several breaks before the level will be disabled, but now i have not enough time, may be in a few months.
xSAMMAELx  

Здравствуйте.  А можно ли в данный индикатор добавить функцию "показывать историю" или что то подобное?

В таком случае мы бы смогли увидеть, к примеру, не такую картину

Dosyalar:
EURUSDH4_1.png  53 kb
Sergey Efimenko  
xSAMMAELx:
а такую
Здравствуйте, реализовать такое возможно, но не просто, предыдущие комментарии как раз о такой возможности. Через некоторое время постараюсь реализовать такую возможность с указанием количества пересечений, после которого уровень становится неактуальным, но дело это довольно трудоёмкое...
xSAMMAELx  

Спасибо за быстрый отклик. Я конечно имел ввиду немного другое (не на столько масштабное)) т.е. просто, чтобы пробитый уровень не исчезал после первого пробоя, но и не продолжал рисоваться.

Пример по той же картинке. Уровень 1 был пробит (один раз) и его рисовка прекратилась. Когда цена вновь начала свой подъем, мы бы уже визуально видели ближайший целевой уровень (отметил пунктиром). А спустя время (по фракталу) появился новый уровень 2, как бы подтверждая наше предположение.

Dosyalar:
EURUSDH4_2.png  54 kb
Sergey Efimenko  
xSAMMAELx:

Спасибо за быстрый отклик. Я конечно имел ввиду немного другое (не на столько масштабное)) т.е. просто, чтобы пробитый уровень не исчезал после первого пробоя, но и не продолжал рисоваться.

Пример по той же картинке. Уровень 1 был пробит (один раз) и его рисовка прекратилась. Когда цена вновь начала свой подъем, мы бы уже визуально видели ближайший целевой уровень (отметил пунктиром). А спустя время (по фракталу) появился новый уровень 2, как бы подтверждая наше предположение.

Всегда пожалуйста, но для программной реализации это не имеет большой разницы, что одно пересечение, что несколько, а на создание приемлемого алгоритма нужно время, а его всегда недостаточно :)
elite luis  

Dear Author, please see pic, I want to ask which alert to set when engulfing candle close outside the zone? 

is such a feature option available to send alert when candle englufing close outside the zone if not please add in next update ok? It is a very important feature so we save alot of waiting time see above please add ok?

elite luis  
elite luis #:

Dear Author, please see pic, I want to ask which alert to set when engulfing candle close outside the zone? 

is such a feature option available to send alert when candle englufing close outside the zone if not please add in next update ok? It is a very important feature so we save alot of waiting time see above please add ok?

because Author often you know the candle stay inside the zone for long time got to wait super long also, by sending us alert when candle close outside zone (no need to be engulfing candle also as long candle close outside the zone send us alert) will help us save a lot of time, looking forward Thanks alot :)

Sergey Efimenko  
elite luis #:

because Author often you know the candle stay inside the zone for long time got to wait super long also, by sending us alert when candle close outside zone (no need to be engulfing candle also as long candle close outside the zone send us alert) will help us save a lot of time, looking forward Thanks alot :)

This has already been done in the indicator. Enable the necessary types of alerts and set the BreakAlert and BreakOnClose parameters to the true value.

Yalnızca ürünü satın alan veya kiralayan kullanıcılar yorum yazabilir