Only users who purchased or rented the product can leave comments
ABCD  

The first chart shows a buy signal on GBPUSD that is currently about 200 pips down.

The second one shows the same GBPUSD chart reloaded and now that losing buy signal has disappeared.


1

   

2

Arturo Lopez Perez  
ABCD #:

The first chart shows a buy signal on GBPUSD that is currently about 200 pips down.

The second one shows the same GBPUSD chart reloaded and now that losing buy signal has disappeared. 


Hello ABCD. Kindly note that if you are using an MA Shift of 0 (zero) the moving average is calculated over time and it can repaint a bit. For auto trading, this is not an issue. For human trading it is. So, to avoid this problem you have two options. One, is to use a MA Shift of 1, so you would be using the moving average of the last bar. Two, use a moving average of "Open Prices" with a MA shift of zero. The open price is known at bar zero. The deviation from the MA adapts to the shift used. I'll probably change the default value of MA Shift to avoid this situation. Thanks.

ABCD  
Arturo Lopez Perez #:

Hello ABCD. Kindly note that if you are using an MA Shift of 0 (zero) the moving average is calculated over time and it can repaint a bit. For auto trading, this is not an issue. For human trading it is. So, to avoid this problem you have two options. One, is to use a MA Shift of 1, so you would be using the moving average of the last bar. Two, use a moving average of "Open Prices" with a MA shift of zero. The open price is known at bar zero. The deviation from the MA adapts to the shift used. I'll probably change the default value of MA Shift to avoid this situation. Thanks.


It's that repainting that causes the indicator to show such high win rates. Once you implement either of your solutions, the number of trades and win rate drops dramatically, with several currency pairs being unprofitable.

As you are an experienced coder, I would think that you knew that but you still attached charts showing such high win rates on the Overview page of this indicator.

Arturo Lopez Perez  
ABCD #:


It's that repainting that causes the indicator to show such high win rates. Once you implement either of your solutions, the number of trades and win rate drops dramatically, with several currency pairs being unprofitable.

As you are an experienced coder, I would think that you knew that but you still attached charts showing such high win rates on the Overview page of this indicator.

I am happy to change the description images with different settings if it makes you feel better. The profit factor remains very good. Do you need help finding MA settings?
Arturo Lopez Perez  
ABCD #:


It's that repainting that causes the indicator to show such high win rates. Once you implement either of your solutions, the number of trades and win rate drops dramatically, with several currency pairs being unprofitable.

As you are an experienced coder, I would think that you knew that but you still attached charts showing such high win rates on the Overview page of this indicator.

Please try a 3-TYPICAL PRICE Linear Weighed MA on Shift 1. It won't rebuild the MA over time and profit factor remains over 10. Most moving averages create fantastic results.

Only users who purchased or rented the product can leave comments