EA with nested Indicators

仕事が完了した

実行時間19 時間
依頼者からのフィードバック
I was really happy with the result I got from Nguyen Nga. He is highly recommended 10/10 points to him!
開発者からのフィードバック
Nice customer, Thank you.

指定

MetaTrader 5, Version: 5.00 build 1375, 15 Jul 2016

Hello, I have one Expert Advisor (EA) which loads 2 indicators. Indicator 1 is a moving average (IND_MA / top indicator) and Indicator 2 is a custom indicator (IND_CUSTOM / bottom indicator) which reads the information from the moving average indicator on every tick and output the values of IND_MA rounded to the third digit after the floating point, producing what you can see on the following image:

The EA needs the IND_CUSTOM for it's own functionality. So that's a requirement for it. It outputs the following on the Toolbox / Experts window:


My problem is that the EA works OK on the terminal but on the Strategy Tester (ST) the IND_CUSTOM doesn't get any value. as you can see on the following image:

I need the IND_CUSTOM gets the values on the ST, so I can do backtesting.

Below you have the code of the IND_CUSTOM and the EA. Please, try it on the terminal first to see how it works, then try it on the ST.

// File: ProblemIndicator.mq5

#property indicator_separate_window
#property indicator_buffers                             1
#property indicator_plots                               1
#property indicator_type1                               DRAW_LINE
#property indicator_color1                              clrBlue
#property indicator_style1                              STYLE_SOLID
#property indicator_width1                              1

input int handle_base;                                  // Handle of the base indicator
input int handle_base_buffer;                   // Buffer index of the base indicator

double buffer[];
double data_base[];

int OnInit() {

        be_aware_of_indicators_available();     // needed here at the beginning

        if (!is_valid_indicator_handle(handle_base)) {
                printf("The handle of the base indicator: %d, is invalid", handle_base);
                return -1;
        }

        ArraySetAsSeries(buffer, true);
        ArraySetAsSeries(data_base, true);

        IndicatorSetInteger(INDICATOR_DIGITS, _Digits + 1);

        PlotIndexSetInteger(0, PLOT_DRAW_BEGIN, 0);
        SetIndexBuffer(0, buffer, INDICATOR_DATA);

        return 0;
}

int OnCalculate(const int rates_total,          // number of bars in history at the current tick
                                const int prev_calculated,      // number of bars calculated at previous call
                                const int begin, const double &price[]
        ) {
        int count = rates_total - prev_calculated;
        CopyBuffer(handle_base, handle_base_buffer, 0, count, data_base);

        for (int i = count - 1; i >= 0; i--)
                buffer[i] = MathRoundDecimals(data_base[i], 3);

        return rates_total;
}

void get_chart_indicators_handle(int &handles[]) {
        ArrayResize(handles, 0);
        int total = (int) ChartGetInteger(0, CHART_WINDOWS_TOTAL);
        for (int w = 0; w < total; w++) {
                for (int i = 0; i < ChartIndicatorsTotal(0, w); i++) {
                        string name = ChartIndicatorName(0, w, i);
                        ArrayResize(handles, ArraySize(handles) + 1);
                        handles[ArraySize(handles) - 1] = ChartIndicatorGet(0, w, name);
                }
        }
}

void be_aware_of_indicators_available() {
        int handles[];
        get_chart_indicators_handle(handles);
}

bool is_valid_indicator_handle(int handle) {
        ENUM_INDICATOR type;
        MqlParam parameters[];
        int result = IndicatorParameters(handle, type, parameters);
        if (MQL_TESTER && GetLastError() == ERR_FUNCTION_NOT_ALLOWED) // on ST "IndicatorParameters" is not allowed
                return true;
        else
                return (result != -1);
}

double MathRoundDecimals(double num, int decimals) {
        return MathRound(num * MathPow(10, decimals)) / MathPow(10, decimals);
}
// File: ProblemEA.mq5

int handle_1, handle_2;

int OnInit() {

        ChartSetInteger(0, CHART_SCALE, 3);
        ChartSetInteger(0, CHART_MODE, CHART_CANDLES);

        int i = 0;

        MqlParam params_1[4];
        params_1[0].type = TYPE_INT;
        params_1[0].integer_value = 20;
        params_1[1].type = TYPE_INT;
        params_1[1].integer_value = 0;
        params_1[2].type = TYPE_INT;
        params_1[2].integer_value = MODE_SMA;
        params_1[3].type = TYPE_INT;
        params_1[3].integer_value = PRICE_CLOSE;
        handle_1 = IndicatorCreate(_Symbol, PERIOD_CURRENT, IND_MA, ArraySize(params_1), params_1);
        ChartIndicatorAdd(0, i, handle_1);

        MqlParam params_2[3];
        params_2[0].type = TYPE_STRING;
        params_2[0].string_value = "ProblemIndicator";
        params_2[1].type = TYPE_INT;
        params_2[1].integer_value = handle_1;
        params_2[2].type = TYPE_INT;
        params_2[2].integer_value = 0; // buffer index to use
        handle_2 = IndicatorCreate(_Symbol, PERIOD_CURRENT, IND_CUSTOM, ArraySize(params_2), params_2);
        ChartIndicatorAdd(0, ++i, handle_2);

        return (INIT_SUCCEEDED);
}

void OnTick() {
        double last_1 = get_last_indicator_value(handle_1);
        double last_2 = get_last_indicator_value(handle_2);
        printf("values: %f %f", last_1, last_2);
}

double get_last_indicator_value(int handle) { // just first buffer
        double values[1];
        int result = CopyBuffer(handle, 0, TimeCurrent(), 1, values);
        return values[0];
}

Any question, please let me know.

Regards, Cyberglassed.


応答済み

1
開発者 1
評価
(253)
プロジェクト
358
49%
仲裁
24
25% / 50%
期限切れ
80
22%
2
開発者 2
評価
(28)
プロジェクト
36
17%
仲裁
5
20% / 40%
期限切れ
17
47%
パブリッシュした人: 5 codes
3
開発者 3
評価
(1)
プロジェクト
1
0%
仲裁
1
0% / 100%
期限切れ
0
類似した注文
I need an MQL5 indicator that identifies reversals without repainting or placing signals with an offset. The goal is to minimize lag and reduce whipsaw trades. Desired results are similar to the attached image. Requirements: - No repainting - No signal offset - Emphasis on reducing lag - MQL5 compatible - Clear, concise code If you have the expertise to create a reliable, high-performance indicator, let's discuss
I’m looking for an experienced MQL5 developer to build TWO MT5 custom indicators that detect multi-condition M30 trade setups and send Telegram alerts before trade execution . This project requires strict close-based logic , multi-indicator buffer processing , and non-repainting behavior . HIGH-LEVEL REQUIREMENTS Indicators must evaluate signals from M30 only All conditions are checked only after candle close Logic
Tôi muốn EA siêu lợi nhuận, giá cả không thành vấn đề, chỉ cần bạn có thể chứng minh được, và gửi tôi bản demo để tôi kiểm tra bạn hãy chứng minh bản thân mình trước. EA cần backtest 1 năm hoạt động ổn định
I have an issue with my ninja script and i would like you to help me straighten things I wanted to create an indicator and i have the source code already but i am getting compiling errors on my NinjaTrader And i tried fixing the error it still same I sent 3 images here for you to understand the errors and i would like to ask if you can help me fix it so i can go ahead and compile my source code. Thanks
Good day, I would like to build an automated trading system for Ninjatrader using 2 MACD, a Supertrend, and a moving average indicator. I want the option to adjust the indicator settings, the ability to trade at three different times, and the option to receive alerts. I want to get an idea of what that will cost me. It will enter trades on all blue take one contract out at a fixed point, move the stop to break even
MT5 30 - 50 USD
I'm looking for an experienced MQL5 developer to help with backtesting, optimization, and VPS setup for a prop firm EA on XAUUSD (Gold). Scope of work - Backtest and optimize using high-quality tick data from Dukascopy or Polygon (2020–2025) - Perform Monte Carlo and Walk-Forward testing to optimize parameters like ATR multipliers and risk % - VPS installation and configuration for continuous MT5 operation - Apply
Good day, I would like to build an automated trading system for Ninjatrader using 2 MACD, a Supertrend, and a moving average indicator. I want the option to adjust the indicator settings, the ability to trade at three different times, and the option to receive alerts. I want to get an idea of what that will cost me. It will enter trades on all blue take one contract out at a fixed point, move the stop to break even
I have an indicator i need automated i use it manually and it plots arrows. Can you automate it for my Ninjatrader8? Do you need to see file? Expert Ninjatrader Developer can Bid for this project
I am seeking a highly experienced MT4/MT5 developer to analyze my trade history and replicate the trading strategy into a new Expert Advisor. The developer must have proven experience in strategy reverse-engineering, trade data analysis, and EA development across various trading methodologies. Strong familiarity with EURUSD trading behavior and chart analysis is essential. Please keep on mind we don't have physical
This EA is created by someone else but can not solve the issue around false trades. I have put this in CHATGPT to have better performance. Normally you can check this and implement the changes chatgpt is offering. https://chatgpt.com/share/694a9127-1940-8001-9b22-f125f741a780 please let me know if you can not see this chatgpt

プロジェクト情報

予算
15 - 100 USD
締め切り
最低 1 最高 5 日