Market validation: v1.30 passed, v1.41 reports no trades - how can I obtain diagnostic details?
Solving Automatic Validation Problems Arising During Product Submission in MQL5 Market - blog post
This error is specific for expert advisers only. The rule is: expert advisers must trade. If your robot should be used only on a specific symbol timeframe, then here is what MetaQuotes say: "Products can not apply restrictions. All limitations should be marked as recommendations in the product description." If your robot does not trade by design (a helper tool, for example), choose approriate category ("Utilities") in the product properties.
One of possible reasons for this error to come is when your code contains a checkup like this:
{
return ERROR_CODE;
}
Such conditions should be accompanied with IsTesting()/MQLInfoInteger(MQL_TESTER) call. The automatic tester is not connected to an account, and the tester is always considered as allowed to trade. Correct code should be:
{
return ERROR_CODE;
}
- 2017.08.07
- www.mql5.com
- solved step by step: How to resolve "no trading operations" validation failure?
- there are no trading operations - the forum thread
- there are no trading operations - https://www.mql5.com/ru/forum/509113 (in Russian but with some code to fix)
- more in search
- 2026.06.19
- www.mql5.com
Thank you, Sergey. Your suggestion about TERMINAL_TRADE_ALLOWED helped us reproduce the issue locally. With the terminal’s Algo Trading switch off, v1.41 placed no orders in our tester run. Under the same conditions, v1.42 opened a USDJPY position and added to it. We’ve uploaded v1.42 for Market validation.
Hello, I am the seller of product 202121. I need help obtaining enough information to reproduce an automatic Market validation result locally.
Version 1.30 passed automatic validation. Version 1.41 completed the four tests listed below, but failed with one reported error. The report dated 18 November 2026 contains:
Unlike several earlier failed versions, this latest report does not show a timeout or a missing tester report.
Both original versions execute trades in matched local Every tick tests with default EA inputs. However, I have not reproduced the official result, and I do not know whether the validation settings or available market history differ from my local tests.
The report does not show the historical test interval, initial deposit/currency, leverage, tick model, terminal build or full journal.
Is there a way for a seller to obtain these test conditions or a more detailed validation journal? If this requires support, could a moderator point me to the appropriate submission route? I have tried the contact page and support chatbot but have not found a suitable ticket option for this issue.
I am seeking a reproducible diagnosis, not an exemption from validation. Thank you.