How to test an EA

New comment
 
I was inquiring how to test the validity of mql5 EA with AI 
Kindly help me 😭 
 
Faith Wairimu Kariuki:
I was inquiring how to test the validity of mql5 EA with AI 
Kindly help me 😭 

What do you mean by testing and validating your EA?

Backtest reliable?

Forward test match to backtest?

Live result are real or not?

what?

If you want to test and make sure to buy an EA:

Run your own backtest using tick data with at least 3 years of history. If the curve looks too perfect, its likely curve fitted and won't work live (But it need more test and details).

Then forward test it on a demo for 1 to 3 months and compare the results to the backtest.

Win rate, drawdown, and trade frequency should be similar. Big differences are a red flag.

For live results, never trust screenshots. Ask for a verified Myfxbook or FXBlue or same live signals in MQL5 and check the full history including losing trades.

Also watch for dangerous strategies like Martingale or no stop loss. If lot sizes grow after losses or the SL column is empty, stay away.

To analysing your data with an AI agent, Since you only have the EA file and description, export the trade history as CSV from MT5, paste it into your AI system, and ask it to compare the real results against the developer's claims.

That's the most practical way to validate without reading the code.

 

Sara gave good points. AI can help analyse the results, but it cant magically tell if an EA is good just from the name or sales page.

best way is still simple testing. run your own backtest with real tick data, then forward test on demo for a few weeks or months. compare the drawdown, trade frequency, lot sizes and losing streaks. if live/demo acts nothing like the backtest, thats a warning.

also dont only look at profit. check if it uses martingale, no stop loss, huge floating drawdown, or keeps adding trades when price goes against it. those can look good for a while then fail badly.

AI is useful after you export the trade history because it can help find patterns, risk problems, and whether the sellers claims match the actual data.

 
check no ridiculous lot sizes max dd is massive consistant 1% risk etc
 
Faith Wairimu Kariuki:
I was inquiring how to test the validity of mql5 EA with AI 
Kindly help me 😭 

Did you get leads on this ?? would really want to know how to

 
Open it in the strategy tester. Ctrl + R will open the strategy tester window. Select "every tick based on real ticks" for the testing model, look in the Journal to see if it could download real ticks from the broker for the selected period. Run it live on a demo account for a while.
 
system will verify to bactesting your ea before using random sampling, you can read comment why, and what happened and you can fix it and validation again 
 
Try market orders on Stop Loss and Take Profit, hold positions for more than 1 minute, and set the Stop Loss to at least 10× the spread. 😊
 
Open it in the Strategy Tester first, but don’t stop at the final profit number. Use every tick based on real ticks, then check the Journal for spread, tick download, and any execution warnings. After that, forward-test on a demo account long enough to see how the EA behaves in live conditions, especially around spread widening and session changes. That gives you a much better read on robustness than a single backtest.
 

Just a reminder... The OP's issue is:

Faith Wairimu Kariuki:
I was inquiring how to test the validity of mql5 EA with AI...

The only relevant replies that I see are Post #1 and Post #2.

New comment