Suppose 100.0 - but I took it on a pullback, and specifically in the sell - why? have you ever thought? By the way, I build my TS by scalping - and here I took the full price - why?
2-3 недели - не среднесрок. Среднесрок - это месяцы. Да и не вижу я никакой вершины отката 17 марта на недельках - там движуха по тренду была. Вероятно, Вы с ММ промахнулись.
На среднесрочке откат в несколько фигур нужно уметь пережить, это да. Тем не менее, если б зашел в середине декабря и пережил бы небольшой откатик в три фигурки, то сейчас был бы в шоколаде. Если входить не большим лотом, как автор стейтмента, а маленьким, а пирамиду строить уже потом, то все было бы нормально: с этого времени фунт прошагал 12-13 фигур.
What then do you think is a "long term" strategy? years...?
I found this in Eric Nyman's Encyclopaedia of the Trader (7th ed.), 270 pp:
- short-term positions: up to three hours.
- medium-term: 3 hours to one day.
- long term: a trade that is open for more than one business day.
I don't feel like arguing about terms. Yes, the long term is years. Bought the eu in 2001 at 0.82 and sold it in mid-2008 at 1.6. That's good, 7,800 pips over 7 years. Not much by the standards of small speculators, but the guys who work on the long term don't go in at 0.1.
Mathemat писал(а)>> I don't feel like arguing about terms. Yes, the long term is years. Bought the eu in 2001 at 0.82 and sold in mid-2008 at 1.6. That's OK, 7800 points over 7 years. Not much by the standards of small speculators, but the guys who work on the long term don't go in at 0.1.
The mid-term is not for systematic traders. There will be not enough statistics (transactions) to reliably detect a pattern. There will be few independent instruments. There are hundreds of poorly correlated instruments on American stocks, and when testing medium term on a reasonable horizon (ten years) it's possible to find huge amount of statistics if we test it on some subset of available instruments.
Mathemat>>: Мне не хочется спорить о терминах. Да, долгосрок - это годы. Купил евру в 2001 по 0.82 и продал в середине 2008 по 1.6. Нормально, 7800 пунктов за 7 лет. Совсем негусто по меркам мелких спекулянтов, но ведь дядьки, работающие на долгосроке, чай не по 0.1 заходят.
The fact is that the fundamental factors, which are precisely what determines a long-term strategy, do not work that much. What are the rarest reports - changes in interest rates? Once every quarter, once every six months? Otherwise, what is there to build a strategy on?
среднесрочка это не для системщиков на форексе. Мало будет статистики (сделок) чтобы достоверно выявить закономерность. Мало независимых инструментов. Это на амер.стоках сотни слабо коррелированных инструментов и тестируя среднисрочку на вполне приемлимом горизонте (лет десять) можно найти огромное кол-во статистики если тестить по некоторому подмножеству доступных инструментов.
I agree, years are no longer speculation but investment! And no one invests in currencies, they invest in factories... in stocks.
I think I'll answer platitudinally - right now, the strategy should be based on the effect of repetition - August and it seems like there are no problems and everything seems OK :)
Mathemat писал(а)>> I don't feel like arguing about terms. Yes, the long term is years. Bought the eu in 2001 at 0.82 and sold in mid-2008 at 1.6. That's OK, 7800 points over 7 years. Not much by the standards of small speculators, but the guys who work on the long term don't go in at 0.1.
That's a myth. Or maybe you can tell me now when to enter 10 lots and in how many years to exit the market?
Allow the use of cookies to log in to the MQL5.com website.
Please enable the necessary setting in your browser, otherwise you will not be able to log in.
You are signed in. Two-factor authentication has been disabled. Set it up again and scan a new QR code, or continue with two-factor authentication disabled.
Пункты указывайте в 4Х знаках.
Suppose 100.0 - but I took it on a pullback, and specifically in the sell - why? have you ever thought? By the way, I build my TS by scalping - and here I took the full price - why?
2-3 недели - не среднесрок. Среднесрок - это месяцы. Да и не вижу я никакой вершины отката 17 марта на недельках - там движуха по тренду была. Вероятно, Вы с ММ промахнулись.
На среднесрочке откат в несколько фигур нужно уметь пережить, это да. Тем не менее, если б зашел в середине декабря и пережил бы небольшой откатик в три фигурки, то сейчас был бы в шоколаде. Если входить не большим лотом, как автор стейтмента, а маленьким, а пирамиду строить уже потом, то все было бы нормально: с этого времени фунт прошагал 12-13 фигур.
What then do you think is a "long term" strategy? years...?
I found this in Eric Nyman's Encyclopaedia of the Trader (7th ed.), 270 pp:
- short-term positions: up to three hours.
- medium-term: 3 hours to one day.
- long term: a trade that is open for more than one business day.
А что тогда по вашему "долгосрочная" стратегия? годы...?
he must have opened the charts from the end of last year and .... - that's where the "salt" would be :)
I do not want to argue, but these guys left the eu and went into metals, the yen, etc., and you should not look from 2001, but a little closer,
Now you can only pips up, but a pullback after a few days can be taken!
I don't feel like arguing about terms. Yes, the long term is years. Bought the eu in 2001 at 0.82 and sold in mid-2008 at 1.6. That's OK, 7800 points over 7 years. Not much by the standards of small speculators, but the guys who work on the long term don't go in at 0.1.
The mid-term is not for systematic traders. There will be not enough statistics (transactions) to reliably detect a pattern. There will be few independent instruments. There are hundreds of poorly correlated instruments on American stocks, and when testing medium term on a reasonable horizon (ten years) it's possible to find huge amount of statistics if we test it on some subset of available instruments.
Мне не хочется спорить о терминах. Да, долгосрок - это годы. Купил евру в 2001 по 0.82 и продал в середине 2008 по 1.6. Нормально, 7800 пунктов за 7 лет. Совсем негусто по меркам мелких спекулянтов, но ведь дядьки, работающие на долгосроке, чай не по 0.1 заходят.
The fact is that the fundamental factors, which are precisely what determines a long-term strategy, do not work that much. What are the rarest reports - changes in interest rates? Once every quarter, once every six months? Otherwise, what is there to build a strategy on?
среднесрочка это не для системщиков на форексе. Мало будет статистики (сделок) чтобы достоверно выявить закономерность. Мало независимых инструментов. Это на амер.стоках сотни слабо коррелированных инструментов и тестируя среднисрочку на вполне приемлимом горизонте (лет десять) можно найти огромное кол-во статистики если тестить по некоторому подмножеству доступных инструментов.
I agree, years are no longer speculation but investment! And no one invests in currencies, they invest in factories... in stocks.
А иначе тогда на чем уже строить статегию?
I think I'll answer platitudinally - right now, the strategy should be based on the effect of repetition - August and it seems like there are no problems and everything seems OK :)
I don't feel like arguing about terms. Yes, the long term is years. Bought the eu in 2001 at 0.82 and sold in mid-2008 at 1.6. That's OK, 7800 points over 7 years. Not much by the standards of small speculators, but the guys who work on the long term don't go in at 0.1.
That's a myth. Or maybe you can tell me now when to enter 10 lots and in how many years to exit the market?