The concept of an ideal indicator - page 2

 

Insider information can be obtained by analysing other financial instruments

or volumes of your instrument...

 
BMG писал (а) >>

Insider information can be obtained by analysing other financial instruments

or volumes of your instrument...

I wonder how this could be implemented ?

 
D500_Rised писал (а) >>

I wonder how this can be implemented?

The important thing is that all indicators that use the price are deliberately late (one of them is fashionable in discussions about price).

Of the available information we have only volumes (not in pure form of course) and other financial instruments,

on which the event will manifest itself earlier than on yours.

And how does a submarine circumnavigate the ground in an underwater position and surface with an error of a few tens of miles?

It goes by counting (the coordinates of each next point are calculated from a known direction and path).

North direction is stored by gyroscopes, time is stored by chronometers, but the path is calculated analytically

by its second derivative, acceleration, which modern instruments can measure very precisely.

 
BMG писал (а) >>

It is important that all indicators that use the price are deliberately late (the trendy price DK in the discussions is one of them).

Of the available information, only volumes (not in pure form of course) and other financial instruments remain,

on which the event will manifest itself earlier than on yours.

And how does a submarine circumnavigate the ground in an underwater position and surface with an error of a few tens of miles?

It goes by counting (the coordinates of each next point are calculated from a known direction and path).

North direction is stored by gyroscopes, time is stored by chronometers, but the path is calculated analytically

by its second derivative, the acceleration, which modern instruments can measure very precisely.

So you are the owner of that Market Gyro?

 
lotos4u писал (а) >>

So you are the owner of that Market Gyro?

I am a handsome sailor myself...

 
BMG писал (а) >>

It goes by counting (the coordinates of each next point are calculated from a known direction and path).

North direction is stored by gyroscopes, time is stored by chronometers, but the path is calculated analytically...

And sudden commands, formation of volcanic islands, encounters with the enemy are stored in gyroscopes and chronometers as well?

 
sayfuji писал (а) >>
Good evening, esteemed community. I'd like to bring up a topic dedicated to indicators in MT4. I don't use any of the standard set myself. The ones I use in real trading at this stage help me with varying success, the reason for that is my constant desire to experiment and passion for programming in mql4, which is not my profile. But it is not about that. The other day I had an idea, which cannot but rejoice. I tried to draw the ideal indicator in my brain and on my computer as well. Although, to be precise, the ideal indicator is utopia, and it should not be a single one. This requires a whole system, a trading system (which I think everyone has), a trading principle or something like that. But in this case we are not talking about an Expert Advisor. I am just curious what would be the ideal indicator, or combination of indicators. Perhaps this will give someone an idea in writing their own (I don't exclude that IBltfkmysq bylbrfnjh - 'nj bcnjhbz
The perfect indicator is history. And looking into the future doesn't lead to good things. Unless of course you are clairvoyant or have a time machine.
 
Sorry, I can't talk now - I'm charging batteries in my time machine. olejan, what exactly are you talking about? History is very interesting, of course, but you probably didn't read it carefully.
 

Take a gyroscope for example. Not from sailors, but from an aeroplane)).
It is needed to indicate horizon line in blind flight and during takeoff/landing.
For a long time our pilots used gyroscope which at roll more than 30 degrees lost horizon and did not restore.
Jets were already going, but the same device was still in use. How many guys got hit. And maybe even Gagarin. Caught in a cloud, allowed a roll of more than 30 degrees, and .... there was a lot going on... ehhh...
But no one will admit it. This is history (I hope).
There will always be those who want to become pilots.
If you use an indicator = blind trading - do not go too far, do not lose your head and your deposit.
What we use are caves.
And the question is posed correctly - only it can be clarified.
Approximately like this: - How do you choose an indicator among those that are available? (it would be good to compare it with the ideal indicator))))

 
Korey, a ray of light in a dark realm, no offence to the community. I am not asking anything from anyone. My suggestion is precisely to discuss the maximum possibilities of the indicators(!) at the given stage of evolution. And also an attempt to compare the available arsenal with a hypothetical ideal one. Exactly an indicator, no FA, no graphical constructions.