invalid book transaction - page 3 12345678 New comment fxsaber 2018.07.19 00:05 #21 prostotrader: Where is the guarantee that after"invalid book transaction" the quotes in the betting machine are correct?I can repeat the previous message again. prostotrader 2018.07.19 00:19 #22 fxsaber: I can repeat the previous message one more time.Off to bed... Aleksey Vyazmikin 2018.07.19 01:54 #23 prostotrader: Doesn't start working again after an error. Apparently OnBookEvent stops working and ... hiccup. That's what I'm asking. How can I check if the data in the glass is "broken"? Added by Just last month 1274"invalid book transaction" errors(see attachment)The most clumsy variant - if the glass does not move for X seconds, then restart the Expert Advisor (or terminal if you want it to work). prostotrader 2018.07.19 13:21 #24 fxsaber: Compare bid/ask from SymbolInfoTick with bid/ask of the tumbler. Because of the misalignment, this must not be done head-on.Cool! The basic data has to be double-checked! Nothing can be higher! prostotrader 2018.07.19 13:22 #25 Aleksey Vyazmikin: The most clumsy option is to restart the Expert Advisor (or the terminal, if you want it to come to life) if the market doesn't move for X seconds.Have you never traded illiquid futures? The market may not "move" for hours there. Aleksey Vyazmikin 2018.07.19 13:29 #26 prostotrader: Haven't you ever traded illiquid futures? The market may not "move" for hours there.Just recently I bought Si-9.19 by accident (I pressed buy on the glue) - I couldn't sell it for two days, but I closed in the black :) Nah, trading low-liquid is too much stress for me. I cannot trade low-liquid, it is too much stress for me. I'd rather reopen the terminal than lose all chances to control the situation. You still haven't answered what helps - restarting the EA/reopening the terminal/disconnecting to another broker's server? The task of searching Controling EA from another Questions from Beginners MQL5 prostotrader 2018.07.19 13:35 #27 Aleksey Vyazmikin: Just recently bought Si-9.19 by accident (clicked buy on the glue) - couldn't sell for two days, but closed on the upside :) Nah, trading low liquidity is too much stress for me. I cannot trade low-liquid, it is too much stress for me. I'd rather reopen the terminal than lose all chances to control the situation. You still haven't answered what helps - restarting the EA/reopening the terminal/disconnecting to another broker's server?Robots (Expert Advisors) are written not to sit behind a computer all the time. The robot should work for YEARS without any errors, much less THE TERMINAL'S WINE! Aleksey Vyazmikin 2018.07.19 13:50 #28 prostotrader: Robots (advisors; experts) are written so that you don't have to sit at your computer all the time. The robot should work for YEARS without any errors, much less a TERMINAL fault!Not constructive :) I'm not saying that the fact you describe is normal. I am interested, in order to understand how you can minimize the risks of such a phenomenon. Dmitriy Skub 2018.07.19 17:13 #29 Doesn't reconnecting to another server help? In theory, it might... prostotrader 2018.07.19 18:11 #30 Dmitriy Skub: Doesn't reconnecting to another server help? In theory, it might...No, restarting the terminal helps :( 2018.07.19 17:23:25.188 Books invalid book transaction [CL-8.18,sell,68.56000,0] 2018.07.19 17:43:30.051 Books invalid book transaction [BR-6.19,sell,74.78000,0] 2018.07.19 17:43:31.739 Books invalid book item[BR-2.19,buy,70.51000,-1] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.161 Books invalid book transaction [MXI-9.18,buy,2277.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.162 Books invalid book item[GOLD-9.18,buy,1222.70000,-3] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.162 Books invalid book item[MIX-9.18,sell,228450.00000,-1] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.163 Books invalid book transaction [VTBR-9.18,buy,4807.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.164 Books invalid book transaction [SBRF-3.19,sell,23519.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.169 Books invalid book transaction [BR-1.19,sell,75.98000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.243 Books invalid book transaction [Si-3.19,buy,63301.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.373 Books invalid book transaction [MIX-3.19,sell,247375.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.393 Books invalid book transaction [SBRF-12.18,sell,21815.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.428 Books invalid book transaction [MIX-12.18,buy,216500.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.428 Books invalid book transaction [GAZR-12.18,sell,14269.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.471 Books invalid book transaction [Si-12.18,buy,64202.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.554 Books invalid book transaction [UCHF-12.18,buy,0.96320,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.602 Books invalid book transaction [LKOH-12.18,buy,39278.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.618 Books invalid book transaction [GAZR-9.18,buy,13894.00000,4][buys: 21, sells: 20, depth: 20] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.618 Books invalid book transaction [GAZR-3.19,buy,13620.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.618 Books invalid book transaction [RTS-3.19,sell,119490.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.618 Books invalid book transaction [ROSN-12.18,sell,43229.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.618 Books invalid book transaction [ROSN-3.19,buy,36921.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.644 Books invalid book transaction [Si-12.19,buy,64560.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.644 Books invalid book transaction [Si-3.20,buy,63746.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.683 Books invalid book transaction [PLD-12.18,buy,813.60000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.724 Books invalid book transaction [SBRF-9.18,sell,21039.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:03.917 Books invalid book transaction [SBPR-12.18,buy,17686.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:04.149 Books invalid book transaction [TRNF-12.18,buy,153248.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:04.170 Books invalid book transaction [BR-12.18,buy,71.54000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:04.351 Books invalid book transaction [BR-5.19,buy,71.31000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:04.947 Books invalid book transaction [GOLD-6.19,buy,1196.70000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:05.017 Books invalid book transaction [UCAD-12.18,buy,1.28960,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:05.870 Books invalid book transaction [Eu-3.19,buy,76310.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:06.299 Books invalid book transaction [Si-6.19,sell,67714.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:24.028 Books invalid book transaction [UJPY-12.18,buy,108.25000,0] 2018.07.19 19:05:24.107 Books invalid book item[ED-9.18,sell,1.16620,-17] 2018.07.19 19:06:13.891 Books invalid book transaction [GAZR-9.18,sell,13907.00000,18][buys: 20, sells: 21, depth: 20] 2018.07.19 19:06:13.891 Books invalid book transaction [MIX-9.18,sell,228250.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:13.891 Books invalid book transaction [MXI-9.18,sell,2283.15000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:13.892 Books invalid book transaction [RTS-12.18,sell,111990.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:13.892 Books invalid book transaction [GOLD-9.18,buy,1222.40000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:13.894 Books invalid book transaction [SBPR-9.18,sell,17958.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:14.312 Books invalid book transaction [BR-9.18,buy,72.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:14.340 Books invalid book transaction [GOLD-12.18,sell,1243.90000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:14.870 Books invalid book item[SBRF-9.18,sell,21009.00000,-4] 2018.07.19 19:06:15.264 Books invalid book transaction [CL-8.18,buy,68.01000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:18.200 Books invalid book transaction [BR-3.19,sell,73.45000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:18.474 Books invalid book transaction [ED-12.18,buy,1.17360,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:20.009 Books invalid book transaction [RTS-3.19,sell,113140.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:24.281 Books invalid book transaction [Eu-12.18,sell,75920.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:27.711 Books invalid book transaction [Si-12.18,buy,64608.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:27.795 Books invalid book transaction [SBRF-12.18,sell,21484.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:28.261 Books invalid book item[ED-9.18,buy,1.16560,-233] 2018.07.19 19:06:36.833 Books invalid book transaction [UJPY-9.18,buy,110.73000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:39.432 Books invalid book transaction [BR-2.19,sell,75.08000,0] 2018.07.19 19:06:43.291 Books invalid book transaction [BR-11.18,buy,72.29000,0] 2018.07.19 19:07:08.263 Books invalid book transaction [BR-10.18,sell,72.65000,0] 2018.07.19 19:07:10.624 Books invalid book transaction [BR-4.19,sell,77.52000,0] 2018.07.19 19:07:26.115 Books invalid book transaction [PLT-9.18,buy,805.70000,0] 2018.07.19 19:07:26.494 Books invalid book transaction [MIX-3.19,sell,238725.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:07:32.084 Books invalid book transaction [MIX-12.18,buy,226800.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:07:35.789 Books invalid book transaction [RTS-6.19,buy,111760.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:07:36.896 Books invalid book transaction [RTS-12.19,sell,113070.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:07:47.705 Books invalid book transaction [BR-12.18,sell,73.91000,0] 2018.07.19 19:07:50.304 Books invalid book transaction [RTS-9.19,sell,112370.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:08:06.762 Books invalid book transaction [SBRF-6.19,buy,20816.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:08:17.008 Books invalid book transaction [RTS-3.20,buy,111100.00000,0] 2018.07.19 19:09:02.512 Books invalid book transaction [MXI-6.19,buy,2173.80000,0] 2018.07.19 19:09:22.861 Books invalid book transaction [UCHF-9.18,sell,0.99690,0] 12345678 New comment
Where is the guarantee that after"invalid book transaction" the quotes in the betting machine are correct?
I can repeat the previous message again.
I can repeat the previous message one more time.
Off to bed...
Doesn't start working again after an error. Apparently OnBookEvent stops working and ... hiccup.
That's what I'm asking. How can I check if the data in the glass is "broken"?
Added by
Just last month 1274"invalid book transaction" errors(see attachment)
The most clumsy variant - if the glass does not move for X seconds, then restart the Expert Advisor (or terminal if you want it to work).
Compare bid/ask from SymbolInfoTick with bid/ask of the tumbler. Because of the misalignment, this must not be done head-on.
Cool! The basic data has to be double-checked!
Nothing can be higher!
The most clumsy option is to restart the Expert Advisor (or the terminal, if you want it to come to life) if the market doesn't move for X seconds.
Have you never traded illiquid futures?
The market may not "move" for hours there.
Haven't you ever traded illiquid futures?
The market may not "move" for hours there.
Just recently I bought Si-9.19 by accident (I pressed buy on the glue) - I couldn't sell it for two days, but I closed in the black :)
Nah, trading low-liquid is too much stress for me. I cannot trade low-liquid, it is too much stress for me.
I'd rather reopen the terminal than lose all chances to control the situation.
You still haven't answered what helps - restarting the EA/reopening the terminal/disconnecting to another broker's server?
Just recently bought Si-9.19 by accident (clicked buy on the glue) - couldn't sell for two days, but closed on the upside :)
Nah, trading low liquidity is too much stress for me. I cannot trade low-liquid, it is too much stress for me.
I'd rather reopen the terminal than lose all chances to control the situation.
You still haven't answered what helps - restarting the EA/reopening the terminal/disconnecting to another broker's server?
Robots (Expert Advisors) are written not to sit behind a computer all the time.
The robot should work for YEARS without any errors, much less THE TERMINAL'S WINE!
Robots (advisors; experts) are written so that you don't have to sit at your computer all the time.
The robot should work for YEARS without any errors, much less a TERMINAL fault!
Not constructive :)
I'm not saying that the fact you describe is normal.
I am interested, in order to understand how you can minimize the risks of such a phenomenon.
Doesn't reconnecting to another server help? In theory, it might...
No, restarting the terminal helps :(