invalid book transaction - page 4

 
prostotrader:

No, restarting the terminal helps :(

And if you run two terminals on the same PC, do they both get this error at the same time?

 
Aleksey Vyazmikin:

If I run two terminals on the same PC, do they both get this error at the same time?

I already have 2 terminals on one PC, the errors are NOT occurring at the same time

 
prostotrader:

I already have 2 terminals on the same PC, the errors are NOT "popping up" in sync

That's very strange then, it looks like an external factor... Have you tried another PC, for the sake of the experiment? I can check on my own, so collect statistics on the frequency of these problems, maybe we can understand what affects it.

 

I also have this problem periodically (Just2Trade broker). It seems to be some kind of failure on the MT5 server, as Transaq's twin server terminals are fine at this time.

 
Sergey Lebedev:

I also have this problem periodically (Just2Trade broker). It seems to be some kind of failure on MT5 server, because in the terminals of the paired Transaq server at this time everything is normal.

If it were the server, the error would have occurred on all computers connected to this server at once, which, judging by the messages, does not happen.

Forum on trading, automated trading systems and trading strategies testing

invalid book transaction

prostotrader, 2018.07.19 19:12

I already have 2 terminals on the same PC, the errors are "popping up" NOT in sync


 
fxsaber:

I can repeat the previous message again.

There is no point. The event occurred, but the data transmission error did not cancel it. I am surprised that MQ has not yet fixed the error. It will be fixed very quickly. It will most likely be an event cancellation event :)

By the way, it's missing from the event alphabet.

 
prostotrader:

No, restarting the terminal helps :(

There was a similar thing with ticks too. When after clearing, error 4403 would start popping up for no reason. Developers have fixed it.

Write to them again/remind them that the error persists. Add the minimum required code to playback, make it clear that it is on low-liquid characters that the error occurs and remind, remind, remind about this bug...

 
Alexey Kozitsyn:

There was a similar thing with the ticks. When after clearing, error 4403 would start popping up for no reason. The developers fixed it.

Write to them again/remind them that the error persists. Add the minimum required code to reproduce, specify that it is on the low-liquid characters of the error and remind, remind, remind about this bug...

Everything you wrote is already done.

MetaTrader 5: error: invalid book transaction

Opened, Started: 2018.07.19 14:32, #2109819

Added by

NOT just on low liquid, but on all symbols

2018.07.20 09:48:11.691 Books   invalid book item[SBRF-9.18,sell,21100.00000,-3]
2018.07.20 09:53:21.238 Books   invalid book item[BR-9.18,buy,72.05000,-3]
2018.07.20 09:54:49.038 Books   invalid book item[ED-9.18,sell,1.17200,-5]
2018.07.20 09:54:50.856 Books   invalid book transaction [MIX-9.18,sell,228175.00000,0]
2018.07.20 09:59:55.546 Books   invalid book transaction [Si-12.18,buy,64515.00000,0]
2018.07.20 09:59:55.689 Books   invalid book item[SBRF-9.18,buy,21090.00000,-1]
2018.07.20 10:00:22.313 Books   invalid book transaction [SBPR-9.18,sell,18067.00000,0]
2018.07.20 10:00:22.687 Books   invalid book transaction [GAZR-9.18,buy,13879.00000,0][buys: 21, sells: 20, depth: 20]
2018.07.20 10:00:22.736 Books   invalid book transaction [SBRF-9.18,sell,21099.00000,0]
2018.07.20 10:00:22.815 Books   invalid book transaction [MXI-9.18,sell,2286.00000,0]
2018.07.20 10:03:21.994 Books   invalid book item[GOLD-9.18,buy,1230.20000,-69]
2018.07.20 10:30:39.946 Books   invalid book item[SBRF-9.18,sell,20843.00000,-5]
2018.07.20 12:07:17.539 Books   invalid book item[PLD-12.18,buy,865.33000,-24]
2018.07.20 12:46:53.835 Books   invalid book transaction [SBPR-9.18,sell,18231.00000,0]
2018.07.20 12:46:54.275 Books   invalid book item[GAZR-9.18,buy,13944.00000,-12]
2018.07.20 12:47:13.403 Books   invalid book transaction [SBPR-12.18,buy,18466.00000,0]
2018.07.20 13:03:35.887 Books   invalid book transaction [BR-4.19,buy,71.92000,0]
2018.07.20 13:16:16.982 Books   invalid book transaction [UCAD-12.18,sell,1.33880,0]
2018.07.20 13:25:28.186 Books   invalid book transaction [PLD-12.18,buy,858.40000,0]
2018.07.20 13:25:28.620 Books   invalid book transaction [Si-12.18,buy,64292.00000,0]
2018.07.20 13:25:29.936 Books   invalid book item[MXI-9.18,buy,2278.25000,-18]
2018.07.20 13:59:51.470 Books   invalid book transaction [Eu-3.19,buy,76264.00000,0]
2018.07.20 13:59:51.470 Books   invalid book transaction [Eu-6.19,buy,77136.00000,0]
2018.07.20 13:59:51.470 Books   invalid book transaction [MIX-6.19,buy,223600.00000,0]
2018.07.20 14:04:56.571 Books   invalid book transaction [SBRF-9.18,sell,21019.00000,0]
2018.07.20 14:04:57.358 Books   invalid book transaction [AFLT-9.18,sell,12331.00000,0]
2018.07.20 14:04:57.413 Books   invalid book transaction [SBPR-12.18,sell,18888.00000,0]
2018.07.20 14:04:57.430 Books   invalid book item[GAZR-9.18,buy,13870.00000,-1]
2018.07.20 14:04:57.471 Books   invalid book transaction [MXI-9.18,buy,2271.75000,15][buys: 21, sells: 20, depth: 20]
2018.07.20 14:04:57.705 Books   invalid book transaction [BR-10.18,sell,72.68000,0]
2018.07.20 14:05:01.045 Books   invalid book item[MIX-9.18,buy,227250.00000,-1]
2018.07.20 14:05:01.893 Books   invalid book transaction [SBRF-6.19,sell,22644.00000,0]
2018.07.20 14:05:33.018 Books   invalid book transaction [RTS-12.18,sell,112240.00000,0]
2018.07.20 14:05:47.015 Books   invalid book transaction [FEES-12.18,sell,17691.00000,0]
2018.07.20 14:06:54.782 Books   invalid book transaction [BR-6.19,buy,70.60000,0]
2018.07.20 16:30:58.176 Books   invalid book transaction [Si-12.18,sell,64590.00000,0]
2018.07.20 16:30:58.176 Books   invalid book transaction [MXI-9.18,sell,2259.80000,0]
2018.07.20 16:30:59.239 Books   invalid book transaction [ED-9.18,sell,1.17910,0]
2018.07.20 16:30:59.246 Books   invalid book transaction [Eu-12.18,sell,76230.00000,0]
2018.07.20 16:31:04.960 Books   invalid book transaction [ED-12.18,buy,1.18500,0]


 
prostotrader:

Everything you wrote has already been done.

MetaTrader 5: Error: invalid book transaction

Opened, Started: 2018.07.19 14:32, #2109819

Added by

NOT just on low liquid, but on all symbols

Have the developers responded to you? See how it was for me:

Alexey Kozitsyn 2018.05.15 13:47
Здравствуйте, удалось воспроизвести?
Alexey Kozitsyn 2018.05.22 12:36
Здравствуйте, удалось воспроизвести проблему? Она будет решена?
Alexey Kozitsyn 2018.06.08 17:13
Здравствуйте, есть ли продвижение по заявке?
Support Team 2018.06.19 18:38

Добрый день...

As you can see, it took a month before my application was noticed. This, of course, is not normal, but problems can be solved. That is, do not think that you write once and you will get a quick response. There are, unfortunately, a lot of problems in MT.

 
Alexey Kozitsyn:

Did the developers answer you? Look how it was for me:

As you can see, it took a month before my request was noticed. This is certainly not normal, but problems can be solved. That is, don't think that you write once and get a quick response. There are a lot of problems in MT, unfortunately.

I do not think ... :) I do!

Reason: