FORTS: OnTradeTransaction() return codes

New comment
 

Dear developers!

When trading, there are situations when you need to urgently

Stop working of an Expert Advisor (cyclic placing of orders, cross-dealing, etc.)

Right now, the return codes of the trade server function OnTradeTransaction() look like this

(the picture shows return codes for a limit order that failed to trigger due to the absence of the required price )

Question:

Do you plan to return codes other than 10008?

If so, in what foreseeable future?

 
Did I ask too difficult a question?
 
Probably nobody's business...
 
Alexander Bereznyak:
Probably not wanted by anyone...
Perhaps... Unnecessary for the "leaker" writers.
 
Михаил:

Dear developers!

When trading, there are situations when you need to urgently

Stop working of an Expert Advisor (cyclic placing of orders, cross-dealing, etc.)

Right now, the return codes of the trade server function OnTradeTransaction() look like this

(the picture shows return codes for a limit order that failed to trigger due to the absence of the required price)

Question:

Do you plan to return codes other than 10008?

If so, in what foreseeable future?

All codes are returned, what code do you need if an order has been placed other than 10008 or 10009?

The codes are returned when an order is placed. After the server accepts or rejects and returns a Redcode, the server reports to the terminal what it does with the order but not in Redcode, but in the variableMqlTradeTransactiontrans.

The order triggering price was not received from the server so should the server send you anything?

Describe the event for your case when the server should send a report.

 
Nikolay Demko:

All codes are returned, what code do you need if an order has been placed other than 10008 or 10009?

The codes are returned when the order is placed, after the server accepted or rejected and returned a Redcode, the server reports to the terminal what it does with the order, but not in Redcode, but in the variableMqlTradeTransactiontrans.

The order triggering price was not received from the server so should the server send you anything?

Describe the event in your case when the server should send you a report.

You are probably not reading or watching carefully.

The order was deleted ( ORDER_STATE_CANCELED )... For what reason?

There should be a return code (I wasn't the one who deleted it).

 
Михаил:

You are probably not reading or looking carefully...

The order has been deleted ( ORDER_STATE_CANCELED )... For what reason?

There should be a return code (I wasn't the one who deleted it).

ENUM_ORDER_STATE

ORDER_STATE_CANCELED

The order was cancelled by the client

SZY The timings show that the person could not remove this order, and the machine too. But the server responded in this way, so the question is not to MQ but to CD Broker, why they have such a server set up.

You have to understand that MQ delivers a platform to the broker, and the broker's programmers are already sitting there and adjust it to the conditions of their exchange. What they put in the settings, the server will do.

 
Nikolay Demko:

ENUM_ORDER_STATE

ORDER_STATE_CANCELED

The order has been removed by the client.

Once again, I did NOT delete it.

That's why we need a return code to make it clear what happened to the order.

 
Михаил:
Once again, I did NOT delete it.

In the CD to the Broker.

Would it make you feel better if instead of ORDER_STATE_CANCELED you got a code that means "the order has been withdrawn by the client"?

The point is that there is a discrepancy between the server's message and your view of the situation, and only the broker can clarify this issue.

 
What does the broker say? Or have you not bothered to ask in a fortnight?
 
Nikolay Demko:

В СД к Брокеру.

Вам будет легче если вместо ORDER_STATE_CANCELED вам придёт код означающий что "ордер снят клиентом"?

Суть в разногласии сообщения сервера и вашим видением ситуации, а этот вопрос может прояснить лишь брокер. 

Nikolay Demko:

In the CD to the Broker.

Would it make you feel better if instead of ORDER_STATE_CANCELED you got a code that means "the order has been withdrawn by the client"?

The point is that there is a discrepancy between the server's message and your view of the situation, and only the broker can clarify this question.

You and I are speaking "in different languages".

The order, can be deleted as a result of the cross transaction,

and the ORDER_STATE_CANCELED comes with a return code "0".

This has nothing to do with the broker.

1234567891011
New comment
Reason: