Tick chart (proposals) - page 7

 
Renat Akhtyamov:

Also true.

Where do you get the teak ones?

That's what I'm saying! You don't have to suffer with nonsense (purely theoretical), you have to do practical things...
 
Serqey Nikitin:

Don't twist the facts!!!

The point of my reply to your pictures was that to post hourly charts in a thread about tick quotes is to be "GREATLY SUPPOSED"...

It's about looking in ticks for further price direction.

 
Renat Akhtyamov:

Why is that?

They're doing all right.

I didn't say it wasn 't fine. History is stored as minutes in OHLC format. This format is not supposed to store ticks.

File with minute bars should have format: Date Open High Low Close Tick Volume Spread. For example:

2016.06.27    00:01:00    1.10024    1.10136    1.10024    1.10070    18    54000000    44
2016.06.27    00:02:00    1.10070    1.10165    1.10070    1.10165    32    55575000    46
2016.06.27    00:03:00    1.10166    1.10166    1.10136    1.10163    13    13000000    46
2016.06.27    00:04:00    1.10163    1.10204    1.10155    1.10160    23    51000000    41

https://www.metaquotes.net/ru/metatrader5/news/5028

Renat Akhtyamov:

And your profile is a complete finish as an agent.

All the threads you have created are aimed at criticising the MT platform.

So I'm an agent.

There will be thank you threads too, but later...

MetaTrader 5 build 1640: создание и тестирование собственных финансовых инструментов
MetaTrader 5 build 1640: создание и тестирование собственных финансовых инструментов
  • 2017.07.21
  • MetaQuotes Software Corp.
  • www.metaquotes.net
Добавлена возможность создавать собственные финансовые инструменты. Теперь вы можете создать любой инструмент, задать для него всевозможные настройки, импортировать в него свои ценовые данные и просматривать по нему графики. Создание пользовательского символа Откройте окно управления символами через контекстное меню "Обзора рынка" и нажмите...
 
Vitaly Muzichenko:

It's about looking in the ticks for further price direction.

No, you're wrong...

Strategies on ticks are roughly similar to high-frequency trading with the idea of making a profit on the order of 1-3 pips... But in DC conditions this is utopia, not worthy of attention.

 
Serqey Nikitin:

No, you're wrong...

Strategies on ticks are roughly like high-frequency trading with the idea of making 1-3 pips profit... But in DC conditions this is utopia, not worthy of attention.

About ticks:"Twosteps to the left, twosteps to the right,one step forward and two steps back".


 
SemenTalonov:

I didn't say it wasn't normal. History is stored as minutes in OHLC format. That format was not supposed to store ticks.

File with minute bars must have format: Date Time Open High Low Close Tick Volume Spread. For example:

2016.06.27    00:01:00    1.10024    1.10136    1.10024    1.10070    18    54000000    44
2016.06.27    00:02:00    1.10070    1.10165    1.10070    1.10165    32    55575000    46
2016.06.27    00:03:00    1.10166    1.10166    1.10136    1.10163    13    13000000    46
2016.06.27    00:04:00    1.10163    1.10204    1.10155    1.10160    23    51000000    41

https://www.metaquotes.net/ru/metatrader5/news/5028

So I'm an agent.

There will be thank you threads too, but later...

and you downloaded the tick archive with MT, isn't it clear that the only thing left is to replace the original source, i.e. the minute bars with ticks?

 
Serqey Nikitin:

Don't twist the facts!!!

The point of my reply to your pictures was that to post hourly charts in a thread about tick quotes is to be "GREATLY SUPPOSED"...

Why ? Doesn't the daily price movement consist of tick values ? What difference does it make how many there are ? If the difference were substantial, and if it were at least some appreciable percentage of the daily rate, then it would be noticeable. But it's just microscopic. Take the EUR and JPY charts, they are significantly different charts, and you can see it EVERYWHERE on any timeframe. And one liquid symbol - whether on ticks or dailies - is about the same everywhere, otherwise, as has been said here correctly - arbitrage would very quickly start to profit.

 
Georgiy Merts:

Why? Isn't the daily price movement made up of tick values? What difference does it make how many there are? If the difference were substantial, and if it were at least some appreciable percentage of the daily rate, then it would be noticeable. But it's just microscopic. Take the EUR and JPY charts, they are significantly different charts, and you can see it EVERYWHERE on any timeframe. And one liquid symbol - whether on ticks or dailies - is about the same everywhere, otherwise, as has been said here correctly - arbitrage would very quickly start to profit.

Hera, you're out of the loop and have not seen pictures I've posted in this thread.

There the differences go up to 34 points 4-digit

 
Renat Akhtyamov:

Hera, you are not on topic at all and have not looked at the pictures I have posted in this thread

There the differences go up to 34 points of 4 digits

How often are there such differences? These are the real differences. But I haven't seen much difference. But I was mainly comparing different brokerage companies. I did not look at the MICEX.

 
Renat Akhtyamov:

Hera, you are not on the subject and have not seen the pictures I have posted in this thread

There the differences go up to 34 pips 4-digit

This is an example of the most liquid pair in the world, which is traded everywhere.

Reason: