Tester: My First "Grail" - page 2

New comment
 
paszo:
And here my results on EURCHF from 2006.07.18 to 2007.07.18

It is different from your results. Do you have any idea why?

And another question where could you find 1M data from 1999? (On alpari both EURUSD and EURCHF are form 2004. 06)

alpari.co.uk создана недавно.
alpari-idc.ru создана давно, поэтому там история глубже.

Я не рекомендую Вам заниматься поисками технических различий в данных и условиях разных дилинговых центров. В статье речь идёт о принципиальных, качественных причинах, отличающих тестирование от реальной жизни.

alpari.co.uk It is created recently.
alpari-idc.ru it is created for a long time, therefore there the history is deeper.

I do not recommend you to be engaged in searches of technical distinctions in data and conditions different dealing the centers. In article it is a question of the basic, qualitative reasons distinguishing testing from a real life.

 
yes, this system is deppended on the data i tested it and some data gave me holy grail BUT some gave me black hold
 

Does anyone have this working for the current market?

If so, I"d love to know how you got it working

please send the Code to me at JMB9922@yahoo.com

thanks

 

...our programmer started visiting various Forex forums and finally came to know that trading with a bucket shop broker is like trying to make money in the casino. He was advised to open an account with an ECN broker where he learned that there is no conflict of interest and the broker doesn't care if our programmer makes money or not. Further our programmer was happy to know that his new ECN broker doesn't requote him at all and provides an excellent execution speed for his orders comparing to old bucked shop market maker...

 
If the result is so different from each other... forward test then.
 
lukasz74nj:

...our programmer started visiting various Forex forums and finally came to know that trading with a bucket shop broker is like trying to make money in the casino. He was advised to open an account with an ECN broker where he learned that there is no conflict of interest and the broker doesn't care if our programmer makes money or not. Further our programmer was happy to know that his new ECN broker doesn't requote him at all and provides an excellent execution speed for his orders comparing to old bucked shop market maker...

Agree. Some of them are not using MT4 at all though.
 

Hi guys!


This seems to work for me in majority of the cases, but...

int Peresechenie()
   {
   ret=0;                                                // That's the heart of the matter!:)
//============================================================================================
   if ((Pred<=Golub && Tek> Golub) ||
       (Pred< Golub && Tek>=Golub)  ) ret=1;             // Bottom-up intersection       
//--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   if ((Pred>=Golub && Tek< Golub) ||
       (Pred> Golub && Tek<=Golub)  ) ret=2;             // Top-down intersection
//============================================================================================
   return(ret);                                          // Return the intersection direction
   }

Did anybody have the experience on backtesting or real life trading that the two MAs approach each other to 1 pip distance and this script triggers action?


What could be the reason for that?


Any input is appreciated...


Thank you,


endi

 

what an excellent post! i lived through this holy grail moment for a while....am sure a "holy grail" exists and will be "discovered" one day but until then ill continue programming and looking for it. i think the answer lies in the first one you talked about :D

 

Good article, thanks for sharing

 
Thanks, this was a good read. Seems like I am not the only one with such a terrible and seemingly devastating experience.
123
New comment
Reason: