Discussion of article "Indicator for Point and Figure Charting" - page 2

 
Aktiniy:

Yes agree with the indicator has flaws. I did it only for manual trade, and did not think about the time of conversion.

Maybe if I have time, will publish its second version.

Thank you all for the comments. They help me in the following works do less flaws. 

Perhaps this is a better view for p&f(indicator is wrong and incorrect,but in a good view)

this chart is in MT4,with "cute_PointAndFigure" indicator......fleshes show date.

pls change shape of APFD like this. 

 

 

??????

?????? 

???????

??????? 

 
pejman-m:

??????

?????? 

???????

??????? 

You have to write in English on this forum please.
 
angevoyageur:
You have to write in English on this forum please.

i know this,

but this question marks mean why doesn't dear "aktiniy" answer our questions ??!!! 

 
no one answer ?!
 
pejman-m:
no one answer ?!
This is a translated article. The author is Russian, you can try to contact him directly, but not sure he understand English.
 

thx,

 but Aktiniy understand english,,,,because he reply 1 time in this topic.

 

Yes agree with the indicator has flaws. I did it only for manual trade, and did not think about the time of conversion.

Maybe if I have time, will publish its second version.

Thank you all for the comments. They help me in the following works do less flaws. 


 
pejman-m:

thx,

 but Aktiniy understand english,,,,because he reply 1 time in this topic.

 

Yes agree with the indicator has flaws. I did it only for manual trade, and did not think about the time of conversion.

Maybe if I have time, will publish its second version.

Thank you all for the comments. They help me in the following works do less flaws. 


So, he replied to all you further questions.
 

Dear angevoyageur,

do you know other p&f indicators for MT5 (of course free!!) ??

in MT4,i have few indicators for p&f,and 2 of them are better and work correctly: Cute_PnF_v1.3_for_4digits(or 5digits)  and  FXI_Point&Figure-Adv  ,,,but i don't find any correct indicator for MT5.

 
pejman-m:

do you know other p&f indicators for MT5 (of course free!!) ??

https://www.mql5.com/en/code/954

https://www.mql5.com/en/articles/368