Nur Nutzer, die das Produkt gekauft oder gemietet haben, können Kommentare hinterlassen
19651965  
Andriy Sydoruk:

Interesting, but I deal with another big project at work and do not have time to test the product. For it takes 2-3 months. spend time on a live account (at least the demo). need to check a dozen brokers to find someone who has the lowest latency (this is very important) because when large delays it does not work. And it all takes a lot of time while I do it! I just physically can not operate this product in the account, if someone wanted to work, I would put all constructive suggestions as for what to do. One of the project is currently underway which directly operates in the real world and must finalize. It is equally promising and it is not a scalpel, my investor does not put a bet on the scalpel.

In other words, the product is, but you need to choose a broker configuration and wait for a while, and it is very hard work. It's too long for me. If you have the ability and desire to conduct this work and share the results, I will be thankful for that I can sell it cheap if you are interested. If you can choose the setting and the broker, where he will work correctly and will be a real result I have removed it from sale and we could work with him.I like to know more about big project 


Andriy Sydoruk  

Тест последнего месяца. (Test last month.)


Советы: (Advice:)
Если у вас не открываются позиции попробуйте уменьшать параметры (до тех пор пока не заработает): (If you do not open a position, try to reduce the settings (until will not work):)
  • ReOptimization - - >> вплоть до PERIOD_M1 (until PERIOD_M1)
  • CountTick - - >> вплоть до 100 тиков (until 100 tiks)

Если на вашем счете слишком часто срабатывает стоп-лосс, тогда необходимо изменять параметры: (If your account is too often triggered stop-loss, then you need to change the settings:)

  • TP - - >> увеличивать до 1500 (increased to 1500)
  • SL  - - >> увеличивать до 1500 (increased to 1500)
  • MinProfAdd -- >> уменьшать до  0.0001 но не = 0 (decreased to 0.0001 but not = 0)
CountSteck Лучше установить = 9 (CountStack better set = 9)

В общем соблюдать следующие диапазоны: (In general, observe the following ranges:)

 

У многих пользователей нет понимания работы основных полей эксперта, поэтому возникают недоразумения. Прошу при проблемах обращаться в личной переписке я пытаюсь объяснить проблемные места.

(Many users do not understand the main expert field, so there are misunderstandings. Please contact in case of problems in personal correspondence I try to explain the problem areas.) 


Icham Aidibe  

Hmmm, that EA is the perfect example on why I do not sell EA. So, I took it to ensure the forex part of my bizi and I noticed some discordances.

First, brokers aren't the same, you won't use the same sets as the author if you're on a different broker.

Segundo, once you made your own optimization, example below with EURUSD / M1 for January 2016 'til today with 100% quality historical data :


Okay, the author Andrey isn't a scammer. It's tempting, it's promising, let's give it a test in real or even demo account. And I did, with the same set, during January 'til today.

Guess what ? The results clearly aren't the same. It's a bot, it's iron, did it turn vain onto fire or onto water ? But anyway I let it run there, it may sync back soon, who knows ?

That's to say to not blame the coder, he did a great job.


melnovilla  
I have my optimized setup, good result on back test, but keep losing money on real account, what a stupid EA!!!
19651965  
How many people  try it already ?
How many % like it 
What's the final verdict  please 
To buy or no or what  is best alternative 
Regards 
Fahadcleopatra@gmail.com 
19651965  
Nickkman:

Hello! This is day 2 since I bought the robot: I bought it yesterday (feb 1, 2016 at 11:00 a.m.), today is feb 2, 2016 2:04 p.m. the robot did not move at all. However I got a nice surprise today: a very quick response from the author indicating proper parameters for optimization. So I stopped the robot a few minutes ago, in order to follow the instructions given by the author and perform an optimization. So today I am starting to run the optimizations as kindly indicated by the author. About the parameters that I will be utilizing in the today's optimization, these are the following:

Settings -

Date: Last Year (Jan 1, 2016 - Jan 28,2016). Execution: Random Delay, All Ticks. Optimization: Slow complete algorithm.

CoreFPS Input Values -

TP (I do not change this, value = 14), SL (I do not change this, value = 15), ReOptimization (I do not change this, value = 4 hours), CountTick (Start = 5000, Step = 1000, End = 50000)

So there are 46 iterations until the optimization tests are done. I will continue to post daily on my progress. I would like to thank the author for providing a very fast response, so that is a good point to notice.

Another point for everyone to consider (a little about my story with this EA): I saw this EA since last year and downloaded the DEMO since around October 2015, and have been performing tests on different brokers almost daily. And yes it is true that it doesn't work on every broker (on backtesting at least, and remember I was using DEMO back then), I usually try to be very careful with these things, and my opinion (after I put very close attention to what was happening) is that is perhaps because some brokers offer a spread too wide (expensive) or the latency was too slow: So when I managed to get into a broker with super low latency and relatively small spread, it started to work better on the back testing at least (it was all DEMO). For the broker I am currently using I did perform tests for every year for the last 30 years, It took me about 2 months of solid work to convince me on buying this EA, but still I wasn't sure on this for a very simple reason: I never found any good comment of someone actually making money on this. Hopefully in a few more days I will be very happy saying good things on this EA, but that is still something to see until the results are real. In the meanwhile I contribute with a daily comment to the MQL5 community. Wish me luck everyone!

Dear Nickkman
Thanks for comment
is it working  good now
Or any good alternative  to suggest 
Fahadcleopatra@gmail.com 

melnovilla  
i took it out this piece of junk, every time it executes trades, its losing money, it just a waste of money, NOT RECOMMEND TO BUY THIS JUNK!!!
marker  
У кого-нибудь есть отчет по работе данного робота с реального  счета? Или тут только тестерные картинки и демосчета?)
marker  
Roman Znamensky:
Результаты есть у кого?
Вот и мне интересно, гг)
mengmanzbh88  
Can be used in a real account? If I buy,  can I see the source code? What is trading strategy?
melnovilla  
DO NOT BUY THIS STUPID EA, JUST KEEP YOU LOSING MONEY! 
Andriy Sydoruk  

Good day. I ask all customers comply with all instructions and recommendations in order to avoid those spammers who are only here to write stupid comments. Expert - a machine that you want to control if the driver is incompetent and illiterate car and go and this will work.

Any questions please write in private correspondence. 

melnovilla  
IT IS REALLY STUPID EA, SCAM AS GOOD ONLY ON BACK TESTING, BUT NOT REALLY PROFITING ON REAL ACCOUNT INSTEAD LOSING IT!!! DO NOT BUY THIS STUPID EA!!!
melnovilla  
NOT REALLY SPAMMER STUPID, STUPID EA, DO NOT BUY!!!
[Gelöscht]  
I am testing the EA, looking for the best configuration that fits to my broker.

One suggestion to the author: in future versions if possible, could include a time control for the EA work.
For example:
- Start time (begins to open positions)
- End time (closed to open new positions)
- Time to close all open positions

Greetings.
Reshende  
Is there a signal for this EA? Thanks.
Nickkman  

Hello everyone I'm back, its Feb 16 2016, so that is 16 days after I bought the robot. This is what happened so far:

I tried to make it run for the first days. With no results, the EA did not make any motion (buy or sell). Then I was contacted by the author with some instructions for optimization. And I did some optimizations (each took 12 hours), but then when running the backtest with the new parameters it showed a systematic decrement in account balance(in backtest): in other words, blows the account even in the simulation (this was from feb 7 and later). So I did not put the EA to work anymore after the first week.

I was very dissapointed and also I was thinking on how to present to the MQL community this case: total failure. Which I am documenting. Now, I am starting the FULL OPTIMIZATION as requested by the author, this is the last resort, of course I do not have any idea how long is going to take since the are several Quadrillions of passes for the optimization to finish, and that means we cannot use the complete optimization, but the only viable solution is to utilize the genetic algorithm optimization, which is a heuristic method to approximate a maximum or minimum value of something measurable: In this case the maximum end-balance of the testing period. Since I know exactly how the Genetic Algorithm works (I utilize it in my real job), I am sure there is no way of knowing how much time is going to take to find a solution. But since the test period for each pass is 6 weeks, (jan 1,2016 - feb 16,2016) I will give it 30% of it's own time to find a solution. That means that I will allow 2 weeks MAXIMUM for optimization to work. Why 2 weeks? well lets assume it works (which I strongly doubt it at this point) I will run the CoreFPS for the next 2 weeks until a new optimization has to be done. Which is 50% of the time. And continue in the same fashion if it finds a solution. If not, well... I'll let you know. If you're thinking on burning your money coff coff buying this robot, well... think twice. I will post the results for everyone to see, maximum 2 weeks from now.

How do I feel? like shit... But let's wait and see the results, maybe I will be the first person posting some actual positive results on this EA. The FINAL FULL OPTIMIZATION just started a few minutes ago.

Nickkman  
Nickkman: Ok there is not a quadrillon passes, but more than 10,000

Hello everyone I'm back, its Feb 16 2016, so that is 16 days after I bought the robot. This is what happened so far:

I tried to make it run for the first days. With no results, the EA did not make any motion (buy or sell). Then I was contacted by the author with some instructions for optimization. And I did some optimizations (each took 12 hours), but then when running the backtest with the new parameters it showed a systematic decrement in account balance(in backtest): in other words, blows the account even in the simulation (this was from feb 7 and later). So I did not put the EA to work anymore after the first week.

I was very dissapointed and also I was thinking on how to present to the MQL community this case: total failure. Which I am documenting. Now, I am starting the FULL OPTIMIZATION as requested by the author, this is the last resort, of course I do not have any idea how long is going to take since the are several (>10,000) passes for the optimization to finish, and that means we cannot use the complete optimization, but the only viable solution is to utilize the genetic algorithm optimization, which is a heuristic method to approximate a maximum or minimum value of something measurable: In this case the maximum end-balance of the testing period. Since I know exactly how the Genetic Algorithm works (I utilize it in my real job), I am sure there is no way of knowing how much time is going to take to find a solution. But since the test period for each pass is 6 weeks, (jan 1,2016 - feb 16,2016) I will give it 30% of it's own time to find a solution. That means that I will allow 2 weeks MAXIMUM for optimization to work. Why 2 weeks? well lets assume it works (which I strongly doubt it at this point) I will run the CoreFPS for the next 2 weeks until a new optimization has to be done. Which is 50% of the time. And continue in the same fashion if it finds a solution. If not, well... I'll let you know. If you're thinking on burning your money coff coff buying this robot, well... think twice. I will post the results for everyone to see, maximum 2 weeks from now.

How do I feel? like shit... But let's wait and see the results, maybe I will be the first person posting some actual positive results on this EA. The FINAL FULL OPTIMIZATION just started a few minutes ago.

Nur Nutzer, die das Produkt gekauft oder gemietet haben, können Kommentare hinterlassen