Hi Panagiotis,

Nice indicator! I have a few issues/questions:

I tried the email alerts but only get an email alert some of the times and sometimes it repeats every minute twice on a 5 minute bar.

On a 5 minute bar the chart has 8 or more signals but i only get alerted on one or two of them.

I am not sure but does the nd/ns signal appear right at the close of the signal candle or only after one or two candles/bars later? 

The screen alert also do not appear every time for me.

I hope you have a solution or can fix these issues, that would be great!

Thanks,

Mike

Dear Mike,

Problem fixed.

How the alert works: if current forming bar is 0 the alert comes on bar 2.

Let explain when you can get multiple alerts. Assume that you have setup the indi to work on 5min timeframe and the alert comes on bar 2, if you switch timeframe for example from 5min to 1H and then go back to 5min while the condition are still true for bar 2 on 5min the alert will be created again (you can check that from time that the bar has on the alert display -not the time that the alert was created).

I hope I was clear enough.

Regards,

Panagiotis

Dear Panagiotis,

Thank you, the multiple alerts seems to be fixed now. However I am still only getting the email alerts once or twice out all day when there were 8 or more on the chart throughout the day.

Can you make the signal appear at the close of the signal bar instead of 2 bars later? I was assuming that was the case from your description, it will make the indicator more useful. 

Best regards,

Mike

As far as your second point it cannot be done because it does to satisfy the definition of No Supply and No Demand. Since bar 0 is forming then bar 1 is compared against bar 2 so the signal is valid for bar2

There were more than 10 signals today, but I did not get any emails but i do get signals from other indicators.

I think you  are missing emails because you are switching timeframes. The indicators works on the timeframe you have declared or if it set to 0 will work on the current timeframe and it checks for signal on bar 2. It does  go back to display the signals on screen but it does not back to send emails for all history signals generated because it will send you a huge amount of email every time you switch timeframe. 

Try the following test :

1. Choose a timeframe for example 5 min 

2. Set the indi to timeframe to 0 or 5

3. record the time

4.  Leave your chart at the specific timeframe (do not switch timeframes)

5. After some time for example 2 -3 hrs count the signals on chart and the emails received (from the recorded time), they should be exactly the same.

I have tested it several times.

Let me know how it goes.

That is the exact test I do every day as I check after I wake up and come back from work. I will try it again as I leave my charts on anyway. As to my second question: I could be wrong but from my understanding  your definition says "The Volume within the candle formation has to be lower than the volume of the previous 2 candles.". Therefore the signal candle with the ND/NS can show the signal at the close of same candle if the previous 2 candles (not the next 2 candles) are measured to be higher than the signal bar, right?

Please clarify if signal candle with the ND/NS can show the signal right on the close.

Thanks,

Mike

Hi Panagiotis, 

Does this No demand No supply indicator repaint?

I've just bought it. 

Hi Mitchk,

First of all, I would like to thank you for purchasing my indicator. There is a manual available concerning the setup of the indicator (I can send it to you in a private message), eventhough from the video it's self explanatory. Concerning the strategy and how to trade with it, the only reason I have not created something it's because there is plenty of free material No Demand No Supply VSA methodology  in youtube. Several videos available from Pete Faders on he reads the charts whithout any indicator but using the No Demand No Supply theory https://www.youtube.com/@petefaders which explains his chart reading methodolgy incorporating No Demand No Supply with the indicator. This indicator was created to visualize much easier the No Demand No Supply candles. Pete's explanation https://youtu.be/1eTS9mpYwmU?si=EyKe5VuLeIwuRUfb.

Enjoy!