Комментарии могут оставлять пользователи, купившие или арендовавшие продукт
Peejay Lal  
1. Your market watch panel showing the ADRs for multi-pair is excellent. I am sure you are a brilliant programmer.

I would suggest you to use your programming skills to make money from trading as well as from selling your skills focused on a good tested product. Just one product only.

Technical analysis doesn't work in case of FX because of its tendency to revert to the mean in V shapes so developing MT4 indicators to do technical analysis won't get you money. 

From my 15 years experience in fx trading I can tell you only price range exhaustion has worked for me well most of the times. It is a game played by the market makers to generate large transactions of brokerage fees. so we have to play along with them.

2. Your market panel is a good indicator for watching price range exhaustion.  

 My suggestions:

(a)  Visual alerts plus email/sound on the chart itself (reporting distance in pips from 10% 25%, 35% 50%, 65% 75% and 90% of the range completed of the ADR) will enhance the usefulness of the indicator.

(b) GMT offset is required

(c)  Open time (user should be able to select his own time - not necessary the open time of the day start -  to calculate distance of pips from the time marked by him as opening time). It acts as a reference point for individual user  to see if the price goes down from that point or goes up from that point. 

3. However there is a possibility of converting it into  a trading strategy indicator (NO need for EA)

If you want to make it a whole system indicator (see pic attachment https://www.mql5.com/en/charts/3483199/eurusd-m30-finfx-trading-oy )

 (a) then create a separate column for Currency Strength Indicator (many versions are there) Chart  values. 

One of them is: https://www.mql5.com/en/market/product/5394# (free)

Other versions I have used are:  #4x forex power (free) or Currencypowermeter (free) or 5Nitro (commercial http://megatrendfx.com/forex-probability-meter-fx-mt4/probability-meter-indicator-algorithm)

(b) add time stamp (date day and time) so that a log can be generated which will show which times of the day  pairs should be traded. It is like a circus where every pair is given time to perform well. Time stamp will help identify the times of peak/weak performances of the pairs. Not all pairs will be performing at one time. So hav to trade different pairs for small profit and make good total every day.

(c) add alerts showing the increase or decrease in the strength of the pairs selected by the user as a watch-list.

4. I am not looking for any discounts or even intend to buy any indicator from you. I was formerly a professor and love to pass  knowledge which can be put to use.

I share my knowledge without any fee or expectation of monetary benefit. 

5. If you develop this indicator I will show you the way to make money by real-trading and recording it in fxbook as well.

If you want more clarity you can always contact me here with cc to my email address: vj6191@gmail.com

 
Файлы:
Peejay Lal  
Dmitriy Skub:

Hi,

Thank you for your message. I need time for thinking))

And you pay attantion to my Average Daily Range indicator - https://www.mql5.com/ru/market/product/5840#

Main idea - price move the same range (about same) day to day.

Yes Average Daily Range is my bible for trading. I only follow this as a trading strategy for more than 10 years now. MT4 has very good free indicators developed for 

Average Daily Range. I use them extensively. ADRmb uses same function like yours.  I calculate weekly and monthly range (open-close) and use them as mean reversion points. For every 6-8 weeks the trading zone shifts. Going down, up and down.

If you can develop some candle indicator based on weekly, fortnightly (starting on 1st of every month and ending on 15th of every month and second candle starting on 16th of every month)  monthly and quarterly zone, marking open-close and high-low as shades of the candles then anyone can see how many times the same position is hit repeatedly. 

Dmitriy Skub  
optionhk:

Yes Average Daily Range is my bible for trading. I only follow this as a trading strategy for more than 10 years now. MT4 has very good free indicators developed for 

Average Daily Range. I use them extensively. ADRmb uses same function like yours.  I calculate weekly and monthly range (open-close) and use them as mean reversion points. For every 6-8 weeks the trading zone shifts. Going down, up and down.

If you can develop some candle indicator based on weekly, fortnightly (starting on 1st of every month and ending on 15th of every month and second candle starting on 16th of every month)  monthly and quarterly zone, marking open-close and high-low as shades of the candles then anyone can see how many times the same position is hit repeatedly. 

Ok. I.e. you recalculate ADR tow times a month, isn,t that? I undestand right?

In my ADR indicator (not in market) I recalculate ADR every day starting (at open day bar ). And autooptimize the best days number for meaning - used minimal deviation error for optimizing.

So, I have at every day opening - range (and half range) for price moving with dinamical up and down limits (see my charts - bold lines).

You use 1/4 zone, too? It's interesting fact.

Peejay Lal  

1. No. Average is calculated as per the standard indicators made for MT4 by at least 20 people. One of the indicators I use is ADRmb (attached) because it draws boundries.

All MT4 indicators use same formula for calculating ADR .180 days to 5 days range.

 2. If you can send me your two indicators Average Daily Indicator and Market Watch Panel , I can tell you if it's different from the ones already in the market and the ones I am using and compare on all pairs.

3. I will try to understand the methodology for your dynamic up and down limits and test them in real trading and find how effective it is than the present method of calculating averages. what is the basis of your optimising and which days you consider best days.

Are you telling me that Monday average will be compared with last few 52/36/18/9/5  Mondays.

Tuesday average will be compared with last few Tuesdays, etc. etc. or what?

If it's so, that this is worth exploring further the effectiveness of it.

4. Similarly do you have any formula/algorithm for calculating average for 1st trading day of the month, (that is average of 12 first trading day bars), the 2nd day of the month, etc. etc.

5. I will also explain you how I mark shifting trading zones based on weekly, fortnightly, monthly, quarterly averages so that we can estimate/predict what range can normally happen. The movements happen in random way but still there is a pattern to it. Attached is the picture of how the shifting is marked.

Normal trading zones last 4-5 weeks, then the 4-5 week zone shifts down or up (can't predict) , in random way. Abnormal short moves of big range like one which happened at the end of last year was to make currency options market active . Now spot fx is also hot as stock market has become stagnant.

Currency trading is controlled by 10 market makers. You already must have read about their manipulations. So we have to understand how they move and just try to catch a pattern to follow them, then we will make money by observing strict trading plan. 

Файлы:
Server Muradasilov  
Приветствую Дмитрий ,панель перестала работать .Скриншоты в личке 
Dmitriy Skub  
Server Muradasilov:
Приветствую Дмитрий ,панель перестала работать .Скриншоты в личке 
Ответил в ЛС. Посмотрите названия заданных в настройках символов и сравните с выбранными в маркетвотче.
Server Muradasilov  
Dmitriy Skub:
Ответил в ЛС. Посмотрите названия заданных в настройках символов и сравните с выбранными в маркетвотче.
Хорошо
antonio345  
День добрый. Таймфреймы можно задавать, или они фиксированные?
Dmitriy Skub  
antonio345:
День добрый. Таймфреймы можно задавать, или они фиксированные?

Добрый!

Задавать можно все, что описано в описании. В том числе ТФ.

Комментарии могут оставлять пользователи, купившие или арендовавшие продукт