Triangular EA Limited vMT5
ダウンロードされたデモ:
662
パブリッシュ済み:
1 2月 2021
現在のバージョン:
1.0
Didn't find a suitable robot?
Order your own one
on Freelance
フリーランスにアクセス
Order your own one
on Freelance
取引の機会を逃しています。
- 無料取引アプリ
- 8千を超えるシグナルをコピー
- 金融ニュースで金融マーケットを探索
I rented this EA for a few months.
Looks good, I really like this way of arbitrage but never had any succes with it in the past.
Could you tell me what to look for in a broker or can you suggest a borker?
Thanks in advance, PM is fine if you suggest a broker!
I rented this EA for a few months.
Looks good, I really like this way of arbitrage but never had any succes with it in the past.
Could you tell me what to look for in a broker or can you suggest a borker?
Thanks in advance, PM is fine if you suggest a broker!
I have tested different brokers, even the recommended broker activtrades.
I have selected all pairs to show up in the market watch.
Backtest works on all tested brokers, but no trades on demo or real money accounts.
And when the price from the market watch is used, the EA does not need days to find an entry, as the seller claims!
I have set "Entry Pricing Discrepancy (Points)" to a very low level at "5" points. That should make the EA open many trades on every day, in a very short time period.
Yes at "5 points" it does only losing trades, but it opens many trades during the day on backtesting, but on demo or real account NOT A SINGLE ONE in the same period with the same "5" points setup.
So one thing is clear to me, this EA will never work on foward tests! This thing is made for backtesting only!
And the seller will blame you, for not having set up the EA correctly!
!!!The only time when this EA opens trades on demo or real money accounts is, when you delete one of the pairs from the market watch.
But then the EA opens only two trades, of the three needed ones. And the seller will tell you, see, the EA trades!!!
This EA is a waste of time and money, because it is made to work on backtesting ONLY!
I have tested different brokers, even the recommended broker activtrades.
I have selected all pairs to show up in the market watch.
Backtest works on all tested brokers, but no trades on demo or real money accounts.
And when the price from the market watch is used, the EA does not need days to find an entry, as the seller claims!
I have set "Entry Pricing Discrepancy (Points)" to a very low level at "5" points. That should make the EA open many trades on every day, in a very short time period.
Yes at "5 points" it does only losing trades, but it opens many trades during the day on backtesting, but on demo or real account NOT A SINGLE ONE in the same period with the same "5" points setup.
So one thing is clear to me, this EA will never work on foward tests! This thing is made for backtesting only!
And the seller will blame you, for not having set up the EA correctly!
!!!The only time when this EA opens trades on demo or real money accounts is, when you delete one of the pairs from the market watch.
But then the EA opens only two trades, of the three needed ones. And the seller will tell you, see, the EA trades!!!
Arbitrage EAs has different results on tester, demo and real trading.
Because of this reason we recommend to follow test procedure described on product page.
you make a wrong operation. 5 is very very small value for real trading. This is very good on backtest but you must consider slippages on read trading. recommended to use higher values.
Also number of trades on backtest and real trades are different. We recommend to trade on demo account with free version before using EA paid versions.
This EA is a waste of time and money, because it is made to work on backtesting ONLY!
I have tested different brokers, even the recommended broker activtrades.
I have selected all pairs to show up in the market watch.
Backtest works on all tested brokers, but no trades on demo or real money accounts.
And when the price from the market watch is used, the EA does not need days to find an entry, as the seller claims!
I have set "Entry Pricing Discrepancy (Points)" to a very low level at "5" points. That should make the EA open many trades on every day, in a very short time period.
Yes at "5 points" it does only losing trades, but it opens many trades during the day on backtesting, but on demo or real account NOT A SINGLE ONE in the same period with the same "5" points setup.
So one thing is clear to me, this EA will never work on foward tests! This thing is made for backtesting only!
And the seller will blame you, for not having set up the EA correctly!
!!!The only time when this EA opens trades on demo or real money accounts is, when you delete one of the pairs from the market watch.
But then the EA opens only two trades, of the three needed ones. And the seller will tell you, see, the EA trades!!!
Arbitrage EAs has different results on tester, demo and real trading.
Because of this reason we recommend to follow test procedure described on product page.
you make a wrong operation. 5 is very very small value for real trading. This is very good on backtest but you must consider slippages on read trading. recommended to use higher values.
Also number of trades on backtest and real trades are different. We recommend to trade on demo account with free version before using EA paid versions.
Arbitrage EAs has different results on tester, demo and real trading.
Because of this reason we recommend to follow test procedure described on product page.
you make a wrong operation. 5 is very very small value for real trading. This is very good on backtest but you must consider slippages on read trading. recommended to use higher values.
Also number of trades on backtest and real trades are different. We recommend to trade on demo account with free version before using EA paid versions.
Hello Kyra,
I have to apologize to you.My compalint was a bit rude und you answered it with such a professionality, that I was really flattened.
On Friday night, before market close, the EA opened trades on ActivTrades, so I will also delete my negative feedback here.
Nevertheless this broker is useless, because it only offers 1:30 leverage accounts for private traders.
So the EA does open trades, but it is still annoying, that the EA can not be used with all brokers.
Maybe, you should also enter a manual slippage setup, where the buyer of the EA can decide for himself, what slippage he is ready to risk.
Hello Kyra,
I have to apologize to you.My compalint was a bit rude und you answered it with such a professionality, that I was really flattened.
On Friday night, before market close, the EA opened trades on ActivTrades, so I will also delete my negative feedback here.
Nevertheless this broker is useless, because it only offers 1:30 leverage accounts for private traders.
So the EA does open trades, but it is still annoying, that the EA can not be used with all brokers.
Maybe, you should also enter a manual slippage setup, where the buyer of the EA can decide for himself, what slippage he is ready to risk.
This is nature of arbitrage EAs. They are sensitive to slippages and can not trade on large slippages.
Slippage of brokers is not a constant value and the only way to detect average slippage is trading for a period of some days.
Lower slippages are more better. The value of acceptable slippage depend to your settings. If you enter larger value for "Entry Pricing Discrepancy" you can accept larger slippages but this will reduce number of trades.
As the result, the best way is to follow procedure on product page to find the best broker or best settings.
Only need a table chart to open all trading pairs?Can it be used with other EAs?
Can it be used with other EAs?
Yes, attach EA to only one chart.
Yes, of course. Can be used with other EAs.
Hi.
I'm using limited edition.
Good back testing results with broker.
Bad demo testing results. The ea does not succeed in all 3 symbols per transaction.
Only succeeds with two and this result in a loss.
Please advise me on setting change or a reference to explore other brokers.
Thank you
Hi.
I'm using limited edition.
Good back testing results with broker.
Bad demo testing results. The ea does not succeed in all 3 symbols per transaction.
Only succeeds with two and this result in a loss.
Please advise me on setting change or a reference to explore other brokers.
Thank you
Hi,
We will not have all 3 trades profitable. The sum of 3 trades PnL must be profitable.
This is one step of testing. Wait for one another trade on the account. If closed with loss again, two solutions :
1. Increase Entry Pricing Discrepancy and try again.
2. Your broker does not support arbitrage trading.
Tx
Also please advise on
2021.03.09 03:49:55.405 Triangular EA Limited vMT5 (EURUSD,M30) Placing Positions : Sell[GBPNZD] Volume [0.05] Price [1.94193]
2021.03.09 03:49:55.405 Triangular EA Limited vMT5 (EURUSD,M30) Placing Positions : Sell[NZDUSD] Volume [0.1] Price [77.741]
2021.03.09 03:49:55.405 Triangular EA Limited vMT5 (EURUSD,M30) Maybe an error of pos placing. 10021
2021.03.09 03:49:55.405 Triangular EA Limited vMT5 (EURUSD,M30) Error in CheckMoneyForTrade code=4002
NB.
The 5 digit quote transactions were successful and the 3 digits were not. It seems to be a bug in moneycheck for 3 digit quotes. Please advise if i can change a setting.
Please note in this comment as the previous with successful i do not mean there were no profit. I mean the transaction was not placed,
Tx.
Tx
Also please advise on
2021.03.09 03:49:55.405 Triangular EA Limited vMT5 (EURUSD,M30) Placing Positions : Sell[GBPNZD] Volume [0.05] Price [1.94193]
2021.03.09 03:49:55.405 Triangular EA Limited vMT5 (EURUSD,M30) Placing Positions : Sell[NZDUSD] Volume [0.1] Price [77.741]
2021.03.09 03:49:55.405 Triangular EA Limited vMT5 (EURUSD,M30) Maybe an error of pos placing. 10021
2021.03.09 03:49:55.405 Triangular EA Limited vMT5 (EURUSD,M30) Error in CheckMoneyForTrade code=4002
NB.
The 5 digit quote transactions were successful and the 3 digits were not. It seems to be a bug in moneycheck for 3 digit quotes. Please advise if i can change a setting.
Please note in this comment as the previous with successful i do not mean there were no profit. I mean the transaction was not placed,
Tx.
Use lower values for volume. 70% or lower.
Автор сделал интересный советник https://www.mql5.com/ru/market/product/60716 (полная версия) и этот как тест к нему, вот только слишком пониженный лот приводит к убыткам, я поставил на демо счет полную версию и арендовал этот, итого одновременно увидел что полная версия из-за повышенного лота сработала в плюс, а эта версия в минус! Сервер на обоих счетах один и тот же ICmarket
Я бы хотел возврат денег за эту аренду, так как по факту это плохой пример работы советника, который может приносить прибыль.
Прошу обратить на это внимание автора и принять меры - или увеличить лот в этой версии или удалить этот пример из маркета!
The author made an interesting advisor https://www.mql5.com/en/market/product/60716 (full version) and this one is like a test for it, but a lot too low leads to losses, I put the full version on a demo account and rented this one, in total, at the same time saw that the full version, due to the increased lot, worked in a plus, and this version in a minus! The server on both accounts is the same ICmarket
I would like a refund for this rent, as in fact this is a bad example of an advisor who can be profitable.
I ask you to draw the attention of the author to this and take action - either increase the lot in this version or delete this example from the market!
Please check your broker slippages. EA is sensitive to slippage of order executions. I know ICMarket has large slippages on arbitrage times.
Please check your broker slippages. EA is sensitive to slippage of order executions. I know ICMarket has large slippages on arbitrage times.
then explain why, both accounts have one slippage and one broker, they are both on the same server and one vps, look at the time on the skin shot, the time differs depending on the version of the advisor
NO. Slippage of both accounts are not same. First please check.
Tell me why the advisor does not sometimes close deals? I put the Limited version on Roboforex and IсMarket, deals were not closed on Roboforex, but they were closed on IсMarket after 26 seconds
The EA is sensitive to broker. If wrong operations happened on a broker, means you must use another broker.
The EA is sensitive to broker. If wrong operations happened on a broker, means you must use another broker.