CISD Honest Stats
- Indicatori
-
Dobril Karakanchev
★★★ THE GOLD HEIST: watch Giza Gold EA trade in public, every trade ★★★
https://thegoldheist.com/?src=bio - Versione: 1.1
Did the delivery really change? This indicator finds the ICT Change in State of Delivery (CISD) - a candle that closes beyond the open of the series of candles that took the liquidity - draws the series, the CISD line and the swept level, and checks on your own chart what price did after every CISD.
CISD Honest Stats marks every CISD with an arrow and an alert, shows which ones came with displacement, and draws the levels where the next CISD would form. A table counts how often price then went its way, compared with random candles. Free, part of the Honest Stats series.
MT4 version | FVG (free) | Silver Bullet (free) | Killzones (free) | Premium / Discount (free) | Order Blocks (free) | Market Structure (free) | Liquidity Levels (free) | SMT (free) | Inversion FVG (free) | Gold ADR meter (free) | Power of Three (free) | Breaker + Unicorn (free)
What it found on our test charts
- Gold, 15-minute chart, 99,999 candles since August 2022: 1,210 bullish and 1,193 bearish CISDs. The bearish CISDs went 1 x ATR(14) their way before 1 ATR against them in 51.8% of cases, against 47.5% from random candles in the same direction (1,164 signals) - a difference bigger than luck alone could produce. The CISDs with displacement passed the same test
- On all 10 test charts (gold from M5 to H4, EURUSD, GBPUSD, S&P 500, Nasdaq, Bitcoin) price came back to the CISD line after 89% to 92% of the CISDs - the line is where a pullback tends to come to
- The ICT rule that liquidity is taken first earns its place: in 24 of 30 comparisons on those charts, CISDs that came after a sweep scored better against random candles than the same CISDs without one. That is why the sweep rule is on by default
Every symbol and timeframe behaves differently, and your broker's history gives your own numbers: the table counts them on your chart.
What a CISD is
- Bullish CISD: a series of down-close candles delivers price lower and takes the sell-side liquidity under a swing low. Then a candle closes above the open of that series - the delivery has changed from selling to buying
- Bearish CISD: the mirror image - a series of up-close candles takes the buy-side liquidity above a swing high, then a candle closes below the open of that series
- The CISD line is the open of the first candle of the series. It is drawn from the series to the candle that closed through it
- A swing high or low needs 4 candles on each side by default (1 to 20)
- The CISD must come within 10 candles of the end of the series (1 to 500), so old series do not give late signals
Displacement
- A CISD whose candle body is at least 1.0 x ATR(14) is a displacement CISD: a strong, decisive close
- Drawn with a yellow arrow, has its own column in the table, and can have its own alert
What you see on the chart
- The delivery series as a shaded box
- The CISD line with a label, and an arrow on the candle that closed through it
- The liquidity that was taken: a dotted line at the swept swing
- The levels that would make the next CISD, as dashed lines, while a series is waiting
The panel
- The level that would make the next bullish or bearish CISD, and its distance in ATR
- Whether a series has taken liquidity yet
- The last CISD, bullish or bearish, with or without displacement, and how many candles ago it was
Alerts
- Every CISD (on by default), or only CISDs with displacement
- Popup, sound, push to the MetaTrader app on your phone, e-mail
The honest stats table
The table uses every closed candle loaded on the chart, in three columns: bullish, bearish and displacement CISDs.
- CISD signals: how many the chart's history gave
- Then price went 1.0 ATR its way first: from the CISD candle's close, did price move 1 x ATR(14) in the CISD's direction before it moved 1 x ATR against it (within 50 candles)?
- From a random candle, same direction: the same question from three random earlier candles per signal - the base rate of the market
- Difference: signal minus random, in percentage points
- Under the table: how often price came back to the CISD line
When the difference is bigger than luck alone could produce (95% range), it turns green and a green line under the table says so.
Why the random candles matter
Markets drift, so "price went up after a bullish CISD" can simply be the trend of that period. Random candles in the same direction show that base rate, so you see what the CISD adds on top of it.
Test it on your own chart
Every market, timeframe and setting behaves differently. Change the swing size, switch the sweep rule off and on, ask for longer series or more displacement, change the symbol, and the table answers at once - real numbers instead of guesswork.
How to use it
- Any timeframe; M5 to H4 give the clearest picture
- Any symbol: forex, gold, indices, crypto
- More history on the chart gives more reliable numbers (Tools > Options > Charts > Max bars in chart)
- Hover over a box, a line or an arrow to see its prices
- Works well next to the other Honest Stats indicators, for example Liquidity Levels and Market Structure
Limitations
- A swing is confirmed only when the candles after it have closed, and a CISD only when its candle closes. The table uses only what was known at each candle's close - nothing is repainted
- The test uses candle highs and lows. Inside one candle the order of moves is unknown, so a candle that reaches both distances is left out
- Past behaviour does not guarantee future behaviour. This is a drawing and measuring tool, not a trading signal
Inputs
- CISD rules: liquidity sweep required (on), swing size 4, smallest series 1 candle, candles the CISD may come after the series 10, displacement 1.0 ATR(14)
- Drawing: last 500 candles, series boxes, swept liquidity, waiting levels, colours
- Alerts: every CISD, displacement only; popup, sound, push, e-mail
- Honest test: distance 1.0 ATR(14), candles to decide 50
- Panel and table on/off, corners, font size
Support: if something doesn't work as expected, send me a private message first. I answer every message and fix problems quickly.
If it helped you, a short review in the Reviews tab helps other traders find it and tells me what to improve.
