Why do some perfect-looking trades fail in forex?

New comment
 
I’ve been running into this a lot lately.

Sometimes I see a setup that looks really clean, everything lines up, but the trade just doesn’t go anywhere or fails quickly.

At first I thought it was just bad entries, but now I’m starting to think it might be something bigger, like the overall market not supporting the move.

Do you think this comes down to market conditions, the pair itself, or something else?

Would be really helpful to hear how you deal with this, especially if you’ve found a way to avoid these kinds of trades.
 
Charly Diaz:
I’ve been running into this a lot lately.

Sometimes I see a setup that looks really clean, everything lines up, but the trade just doesn’t go anywhere or fails quickly.

At first I thought it was just bad entries, but now I’m starting to think it might be something bigger, like the overall market not supporting the move.

Do you think this comes down to market conditions, the pair itself, or something else?

Would be really helpful to hear how you deal with this, especially if you’ve found a way to avoid these kinds of trades.

The best that you can hope for is to identify a statistically significant pattern that repeats itself occasionally within the instrument that you're trading. This can be accomplished by visually backtesting technical indicators (and manually taking notes) or backtesting auto-tradng EA's. Hint: Stick with OHLC historic data.

If you're trading news, you need to develop a way to statistically analyze the historic impact of each news event─so that it becomes testable.

 

First of all you should be sure that your strategy has some backtest/forwardtest data that shows you that it is profitable, positive expctancy etc. 

If it is, you should of course look at possible mistakes you've made (unless you're using an EA that trades for you).

If all the above are checked and in place, yes, it could be that the recent market conditions are not the best overall.

I'm having an hard time on NQ too recently: very choppy price action, some clean setups, like textbook setups, get stopped, but then price goes to the target I anticipated, which is even a worse feeling lol

So yeah, make sure all the previous things I said are in check, if they are, recent market conditions do not help at all, there's a lot of uncertainty and things do not look good overall anyway, so maybe just dail back a bit until things get better, maybe use a smaller risk, be more skeptical with setups, or just take a pause altogether.

 

Sometimes, a big corporation announces a huge investment; sometimes a trigger-happy weapon owner fires the weapon; sometimes somebody buys all the oil available on the market, no matter the price; sometimes some big economy changes interest rates or tariffs; sometimes ...

For additional fun, sometimes prices go one way, and next time at the same event, they go the other way.

Your trade setup is as good as your risk management is.
Every trade can go wrong for any number of reasons you can't predict.

If you can, then you have the potential to become the richest man ever.

 
Ryan L Johnson #:

The best that you can hope for is to identify a statistically significant pattern that repeats itself occasionally within the instrument that you're trading. This can be accomplished by visually backtesting technical indicators (and manually taking notes) or backtesting auto-tradng EA's. Hint: Stick with OHLC historic data.

If you're trading news, you need to develop a way to statistically analyze the historic impact of each news event─so that it becomes testable.

Yeah that makes sense, especially about confirming the strategy first.

What I’ve been noticing though is even when the strategy is solid, performance still changes a lot depending on the market conditions.

Like some periods everything works, and other times the same setups just don’t follow through at all.

Starting to think it’s less about the setup itself and more about whether the market is actually supportive of it.

Have you noticed that too in your testing?

New comment