Is making easy money out of thin air on the forex market immoral? - page 2

 
Andrey Dik:

You don't have to produce a product, just pay taxes. if you don't pay taxes, you are a parasite no matter what you do.

Strange position :)

 
Aliaksandr Hryshyn:
Strange position :)

wow! what a reasoned response, it gives me goosebumps.))

 

I wonder what people who think trading is parasitic are doing here? Is it such stoic masochism? You realise you are bad people and doing the wrong thing, but persist in cultivating it in yourself?

[Deleted]  
webgopnik:

Talented)

 
Dmitry Fedoseev:

I wonder what the people who think trading is parasitic are doing here?

They are missionaries - bringing their enlightenment ideas to the masses).

 
webgopnik:
"Workers and toilers in the sweat of their brow, actually!

Yes, that reminds me ))


As a solution to the problem: trade and sweat. That's the moral...
 
Ihor Herasko:

Yeah, that reminds me )))


As a solution to the problem: trade and sweat. That's the moral...

yeah, bull's-eye!)))

 
Andrey Dik:

A fundamentally flawed judgement. Stealing is immoral, it is when material or immaterial values are borrowed without the owner's consent. But in the market everything is done by agreement of the parties: a broker (or other kind of intermediary) takes a commission and brings traders together, the traders' money is redistributed between themselves minus the commissions. Brokerage house owners go to the shops and spend the money on yachts and villas (stimulating civil and shipbuilding, etc.), the same is done by successful traders.

Also, brokers and traders pay taxes (where they don't, it's a regulatory problem in those countries).

Any legitimate movement of money in the economy is useful! As soon as the money starts to move, taxes start to be paid. Traders are like earthworms, you cannot see them and do not understand their usefulness, but without them the soil would turn to stone and all life on earth would stop, because plants cannot grow, herbivores would die and carnivores would follow.

Traders, traders, merchants are the life, prosperity of the economy! The more small and medium-sized businesses there are, the more stable and robust the economy is. The enlargement of big business and the extinction of small business leads to economic downturn and destabilization.

Therefore, to be a trader is an honorable thing, be proud to be a trader!

A fundamentally flawed judgement. Rentiers ruined France and we must remember that. It's just the least evil and the rest of the evil is greater. And when the stock exchange, with its 99% non-productive turnover climbs over 99 and taxes from non-productive and non-vital spheres exceed half, there is a crisis, so it must be remembered and understood. And so, yes, if everyone is an artist and a trader, there will be nothing to eat.

Commodity turnover is life, equality of commodity and money supply is life. But the distortions are always at the end of a crisis. And in either direction. And crisis is sometimes death for some people. And life is better than death a priori)))))

 
I search for "how the rentiers ruined France" and all I find is"how the First World Warruinedthe rentiers".
 
Aliaksandr Hryshyn:
Strange position :)

This is true for some countries, but such places are few and not even 10% of such countries, so the example is only partly correct)