You are missing trading opportunities:
- Free trading apps
- Over 8,000 signals for copying
- Economic news for exploring financial markets
Registration
Log in
You agree to website policy and terms of use
If you do not have an account, please register
I agree that it is promising and interesting. But you are wrong about the fact that it is impossible to logically understand "why a neural network made exactly such a decision". The logic of decision making can and must be programmed (this is how it is done in normal algorithms).
I do not agree. A neural network is a mini-brain. Only a human has a few hundred thousand neurons, while a neural network has a few units or tens. How can a brain be logically predicted? It is a kind of "prediction prediction". You can't control a neural network's decision making. That's what a neural network is..... You can only make or not make that decision. But that's another topic.....
That it is promising and interesting I agree with that. But you are wrong about the fact that it is impossible to logically understand "why a neural network made exactly such a decision". Decision logic can and must be programmed (this is how it is done in normal algorithms).
I do not agree. A neural network is a mini-brain. Only a human has a few hundred thousand neurons, while a neural network has a few units or tens. How can a brain be logically predicted? It is a kind of "prediction prediction". You can't control a neural network's decision making. That's what a neural network is..... You can only make or not make that decision. But that's another topic.....
So the NS is essentially a black box. In the sense of making a decision. It is impossible to logically understand why a neural network made that particular decision. That's why it's a neural network.
You seem to make some alien miracle out of NS. There is a quite developed mathematical apparatus, and in general it is known what NS does in the input space. And knowing it we may understand why the net took this or that decision. And the comparison with a brain... It is not only a question of network capacity (the number of neurons) but the brain is more complicated. That is what numerous recent studies indicate. It is by no means a black box, otherwise how would you work with it? Then it would remind Strugatsky's "Picnic by the Side of the Road" - a lot of things not clear how they are made, not clear how they work, it is not clear what they were originally designed for and from some learned to extract benefit. And I agree about perspective, it is there, thanks to the fact that this apparatus is still underdeveloped, which means that more than one small miracle can still happen.
Well, I don't really give a damn - count it as you like. And I didn't say how, but why.... Write a "missile guidance system" in MQL - I'll be happy for you.....
And knowing this you can understand why the network made a particular decision.
If it's clear why the neural network made that decision, then use that knowledge - you don't need a neural network to trade......
Well, neural networks also need to work, not lazy..... Or are you one of those people who are looking for a grail and want to go to an island for a holiday and a neural network will work?
I am one of those who likes to rack their brains and who is not looking for a grail. Forex is just a hobby for me. I'm not a trader, I'm a programmer and I'm just mastering a new area, where I have the opportunity to apply my knowledge.
NeuroShell2 is a great program, but in order to apply it to the market you need to add a binding to MT4. This, of course, is not difficult, but it is time-consuming... In Neuroschell Day Trader all studies and hypothesis tests can be done in 2-3 days. And you can check everything in real time in visual testing mode - a unique feature! You can create any NS and test it immediately. ...
NeuroShell2 is a great program, but in order to apply it to the market you need to add a binding to MT4. This, of course, is not difficult, but it is time-consuming... In Neuroschell Day Trader all studies and hypothesis tests can be done in 2-3 days. And you can check everything in real time in visual testing mode - a unique feature! You can create any NS and immediately check it.
NSDT has no Kohonen, but there are other classifiers in the Adaptive Net Indicators addon. Although it is possible to connect NeuroShell2 net directly to MT4 or NSDT.
How do you plan to use Kohonen's network for trading? It's not three classes, but much more. You should think of some algorithm to parse the classes.