inaccurate mt4 history center data

 
in year 2019 i back tested a strategy on data i had in my mt4 terminal 
in year 2021 i tried to back test same strategy (with same indicator)  + same set of rules 
but i didn't have enough bars from year 2019 so i downloaded historical data from history center
but this time back testing results were different   
is it due to the reason : data i had in 2019 was  different from data i downloaded in 2021 from history center ?
can someone please tell that  downloaded data  can be little bit different from actual data ? 
 
TF used was M15 pair eurusd 
 
Warning


Brokers only keep a limited amount of bars in their history, you downloaded the rest from Metaquotes; there will be differences.

If the behavior is drastically different from what you had in 2019, maybe the EA was OverFitted to your Brokers's quotes. (especially if you optimized it a lot)