is only technical analysis or fundamental analysis is enough for trading?

[burak UMITVAR]

do you thing 1 analysis is enough for trading ?

only technical can be enough to make money?

or only following news releases is enough ?

or how to combine them together ?

[Sergey Golubev]

analysis = technical + fundamental (daily).

Just my opinion (I am doing it every morning to decide about what I will trade and when)

[burak UMITVAR]

newdigital:

analysis = technical + fundamental (daily).

Just my opinion (I am doing it every morning to decide about what I will trade and when)

i think news releases tells you very important things , its just you have to read them carefully. thats where i have to improve myself more n more..

cheers

[Ronnie Mansolillo]

burakumitvar :

do you thing 1 analysis is enough for trading ?

only technical can be enough to make money?

or only following news releases is enough ?

or how to combine them together ?

Your question has always lit the debate in the financial world. I guess there isn't an answer. all winning strategies are ok.

I think it depends also on the personal strategies. I follow the primary trend and believe that fundamental analysis is represented on charts by the price line. Therefore I care to include only the technical parameters to make the right considerations.

[burak UMITVAR]

Rosiman:

Your question has always lit the debate in the financial world. I guess there isn't an answer. all winning strategies are ok.

I think it depends also on the personal strategies. I follow the primary trend and believe that fundamental analysis is represented on charts by the price line. Therefore I care to include only the technical parameters to make the right considerations.

yes , a good point

i respect that

thanks for your time

cheers

[Rodrigo Malacarne]

I believe technical analysis and fundamental analysis are the most "serious" approachs for investing in the markets.

However, I've seen other approachs too, but it's up to the user to use them.

See for instance this link. Would you use it?

[sylvain claverie]

newdigital:

analyse technique = + fondamentale (tous les jours).

Juste mon avis (je le fais tous les matins pour décider de ce que je vais commerce et quand)

totally agree with you

[burak UMITVAR]

Malacarne:

I believe technical analysis and fundamental analysis are the most "serious" approachs for investing in the markets.

However, I've seen other approachs too, but it's up to the user to use them.

See for instance this link. Would you use it?

wow.. thats a very interesting point of view..

thank you for sharing and for your time..

cheers..

[graziani]

to consistently trade successfully you need:

1) entry criteria
2) exit criteria and optionally you can also have target 
3) SL for position: both for single entry and for averaging techniques
4) money management to define lot sizes both for single entry and for averaging techniques
5) successful historical backtest for defined strategy, non-optimized but based on statistical calculations
6) SL for the strategy: define moment when the strategy is not working anymore compared to historical results

whether any of these criterias is defined fundamentally, technically, astrologically, news-based, by counting words in twitter messages or anything else, is completely irrelevant.

[Arturo Lopez Perez]

burakumitvar:

do you thing 1 analysis is enough for trading ?

only technical can be enough to make money?

or only following news releases is enough ?

or how to combine them together ?

I just look at charts. No fundamentals, no news, no stories, no four-leaf clovers or moon phases.

[Rodrigo Malacarne]

PzTrading:
I just look at charts. No fundamentals, no news, no stories, no four-leaf clovers or moon phases.

Investing according to moon phases seems to be an interesting approach, no? :-P