Solo gli utenti che hanno acquistato o noleggiato il prodotto possono lasciare commenti
huweiping  

Hello,

I just bought your EA & tested with the same period of data by optimization on 2023-05-09 and 2023-05-12, respectively. But the 2 sets of results looked so different, did not seem to be from the same EA. Please see attached results for more details. I noticed few updates have been released recently, not sure whether the different test results were caused by the different versions. Can you please investigate the potential root causes? Would you normally conduct some simple verification testing before releasing a new version?

I noticed your early feedback below. Can you please elaborate more on the point #1 about how the trade to be closed? Can you also include a larger mandatory stop to reduce the risk as indicated in the point #3?

1. When the algorithm determines that the direction is wrong, the trade is automatically closed instead of being stopped out via a stop-loss point.

2. The automatic trailing stop will only appear when the trade is profitable

3. If you feel the need, we can include a larger mandatory stop in a future version

Look forward to your response soon!

Thanks for your support!

Hu

Mexxie1  
I bought this bot since the backtest results were impressive however I'm still testing on demo and it's taken 1 trade in two days across 5 charts and my settings are to risk 3% per trade, currently in 10% drawdown on my account with 3% risk, how???
Kasper Hytonen  
Mexxie1 #:
I bought this bot since the backtest results were impressive however I'm still testing on demo and it's taken 1 trade in two days across 5 charts and my settings are to risk 3% per trade, currently in 10% drawdown on my account with 3% risk, how???

Mine is 20% dd with 0.01 risk. This is horrible

Robert Schmolinski  

And again -75$ in EURUSD! My other EAs was placing sell order but GPT buying. Then, after last update with the nice test function, the EA was closing all the open order after I was restarting the terminal. And any time when I change some settings, same again... test order. Now I switch it of. 

But in fact:

USDCAD: EA close the trade with -107$ but the price is still moving, now it would be around -200$ its more then 20% DD!

GBPUSD: EA close the trade with -153$ but the price is still moving, now it would be around -240$ its more then 25% DD!

EURUSD: EA close the trade with -27$ but the price is still moving, now it would be around -104$ its more then 10% DD!

And now check the DD in the backtest!

File:
USDCAD.jpg  494 kb
GBPUSD.jpg  484 kb
EURUSD.jpg  465 kb
bsandaruwan  

I bought this EA, but I think Something wrong with the risk calculation on this EA.

I tried this on a 10000-demo account with 0.01 Max risk, that’s means EA should close the trades when the loss reaches $100.

But EA closes some trades and reaches more than $4000 in loss.

We don’t have control to manage the Risk.

There is no clear explanation about it in the description.

I privately messaged the publisher and asked for more details.

But I didn’t get a reply.

Correct me if I’m wrong.

Sill I’m not going to add a review on this. But I will do based on the publisher’s feedback. Still, keep testing on live market 

Thank you.

Chen Jia Qi  
huweiping #:

Hello,

I just bought your EA & tested with the same period of data by optimization on 2023-05-09 and 2023-05-12, respectively. But the 2 sets of results looked so different, did not seem to be from the same EA. Please see attached results for more details. I noticed few updates have been released recently, not sure whether the different test results were caused by the different versions. Can you please investigate the potential root causes? Would you normally conduct some simple verification testing before releasing a new version?

I noticed your early feedback below. Can you please elaborate more on the point #1 about how the trade to be closed? Can you also include a larger mandatory stop to reduce the risk as indicated in the point #3?

1. When the algorithm determines that the direction is wrong, the trade is automatically closed instead of being stopped out via a stop-loss point.

2. The automatic trailing stop will only appear when the trade is profitable

3. If you feel the need, we can include a larger mandatory stop in a future version

Look forward to your response soon!

Thanks for your support!

Hu

Because many users do not adjust their lot size according to the actual situation, we have preset a relatively low Risk in the new version. While the profit has decreased, the safety has also increased a lot. You can adjust it yourself, but we do not recommend that you adjust it too high. From a recent picture, you can see our stop loss method.  
Chen Jia Qi  
davidfortin558 #:
hello, is there a set stop loss on all trades? I ask this because I recently purchased a gbt ea that had a 1000 pip stop loss, so basically no stop loss and was extremely risky. the trades we also not accurate and seemed like it was going based on daily support and resistance.
From this picture, we can see that if the stop loss value is set too low, it will stop loss frequently, and if it is set too high, it may stop loss at a high position. Our suggestion is to use fewer lot sizes and let the EA determine the stop loss itself, so as to overcome human fear. 1000+ Point is not uncommon in historical backtesting. We will add a preset for a larger stop loss in the next version to prevent black swan events.
Ji Xue Wang  
回测可以买地球,希望实盘能够买块地就行,哈哈哈......毕竟EA也不贵,探索一下。
Chen Jia Qi  
Ji Xue Wang #:
回测可以买地球,希望实盘能够买块地就行,哈哈哈......毕竟EA也不贵,探索一下。

回测只是能证明EA策略的有效性,毕竟Mt5的回测还是挺准确的。刚刚又有个差评有点气人了,EA  5月3号下了一单然后5月11号才结的单。他进入时候就跟ea的单就不一样了他还说结果跟回测不一样,这哪里可能一样。我5月5号才卖的EA.也是这波行情出了这么个奇葩的信号,但是下一单马上又追回了亏损。

Peter Levai  

Hello Chen Jia Qi


I would like to ask for your help.
If I optimize EA Take Profit (in points) Trailing Stop Level (in piints) parameters.
There is no difference in the results.
Why are these two parameters included if they do not affect the results?

I think version 2.36 was the best so far.

File:
Chen Jia Qi  
Peter Levai #:

Hello Chen Jia Qi


I would like to ask for your help.
If I optimize EA Take Profit (in points) Trailing Stop Level (in piints) parameters.
There is no difference in the results.
Why are these two parameters included if they do not affect the results?

I think version 2.36 was the best so far.

Because too many people caused serious losses by optimizing randomly, we locked it. After this period of time, we found that most people actually don’t know how to use it. It’s better for us to optimize it. Even many experienced people don’t know that overfitting is not a good thing.
Chen Jia Qi  
bsandaruwan #:

I bought this EA, but I think Something wrong with the risk calculation on this EA.

I tried this on a 10000-demo account with 0.01 Max risk, that’s means EA should close the trades when the loss reaches $100.

But EA closes some trades and reaches more than $4000 in loss.

We don’t have control to manage the Risk.

There is no clear explanation about it in the description.

I privately messaged the publisher and asked for more details.

But I didn’t get a reply.

Correct me if I’m wrong.

Sill I’m not going to add a review on this. But I will do based on the publisher’s feedback. Still, keep testing on live market 

Thank you.

Thank you for your rationality. Thanks again. Recently, too many people have purchased it. We are a bit overwhelmed. So we restricted the number of users through the price. The reply may have errors and omissions, sorry. Regarding what you said, we still need more information, such as how many hands he has for each order, your understanding of this risk is wrong, I will give you our calculation formula, you need to determine your leverage number, maybe we will automatically calculate the leverage number in the next version. Our Risk calculation formula is: with a remaining balance of 1000 US dollars at a leverage of 1:100, Risk 0.01 corresponds to an order size of 0.01 lots. The default is 0.03. If your leverage is 1:500 then it is 0.03*5=0.15 lots

Chen Jia Qi  
Robert Schmolinski #:

And again -75$ in EURUSD! My other EAs was placing sell order but GPT buying. Then, after last update with the nice test function, the EA was closing all the open order after I was restarting the terminal. And any time when I change some settings, same again... test order. Now I switch it of. 

But in fact:

USDCAD: EA close the trade with -107$ but the price is still moving, now it would be around -200$ its more then 20% DD!

GBPUSD: EA close the trade with -153$ but the price is still moving, now it would be around -240$ its more then 25% DD!

EURUSD: EA close the trade with -27$ but the price is still moving, now it would be around -104$ its more then 10% DD!

And now check the DD in the backtest!

If you see this information, please immediately correct your time period to 15 minutes, which is the time period we use for training data.

You can see that it is profitable on M15. 

Chen Jia Qi  
Kasper Hytonen #:

Mine is 20% dd with 0.01 risk. This is horrible

(ACCOUNT_MARGIN_FREE) * MaximumRisk / margin / leverage * 100 This is the formula to be upgraded. The previous formula did not calculate the leverage of the account. We calculated it based on our test account of 1:100. So when your leverage is 1:1000, risk 0.01 is actually 0.1 risk. 
Chen Jia Qi  
Mexxie1 #:
I bought this bot since the backtest results were impressive however I'm still testing on demo and it's taken 1 trade in two days across 5 charts and my settings are to risk 3% per trade, currently in 10% drawdown on my account with 3% risk, how???
我买了这个机器人,因为回测结果令人印象深刻,但我仍然在测试演示,它采取了1贸易在两天内跨越5图表和我的设置是风险3%每笔交易,目前在10%的缩编我的帐户与3%的风险,如何???

(ACCOUNT_MARGIN_FREE) * MaximumRisk / margin / leverage * 100 This is the formula to be upgraded. The previous formula did not calculate the leverage of the account. We calculated it based on our test account of 1:100. So when your leverage is 1:1000, risk 0.01 is actually 0.1 risk. 

All of these have been resolved in the new upgrade, please pay attention to the upgrade preparation to launch 2.39

Evgenii Aksenov  

Hello  Chen Jia Qi

Why you don't have a real or demo account where we can see the same deals which we get in reverse test?

If your EA is honest and you have nothing to hide, you need to publish a real time Signal.


Chen Jia Qi  
Evgenii Aksenov #:

Hello  Chen Jia Qi

Why you don't have a real or demo account where we can see the same deals which we get in reverse test?

If your EA is honest and you have nothing to hide, you need to publish a real time Signal.


I have only been on the shelf for less than 10 days. Look at my update frequency. In order to provide you with a stable and useful EA, I have been working late into the night for a few days. Still, one by one, give me bad reviews and let me explain for a long time.  First of all, I have to have time. 


edsonvazpingo  
cool new update! One suggestion would be to place a panel with basic information on operations. I have good expectations!
ZERO9898.Tom KC Wang  

Just checked on the VPS....same pair(same magic) EURUSD opened 27 orders.....I have doublechecked there's no same EURUSD chart worked on GPTAutoTrade !


oldgao  
已购买,不停开单是怎么回事?
Solo gli utenti che hanno acquistato o noleggiato il prodotto possono lasciare commenti