I am looking for a good vsa indicator. Everyone knows that brokers manipulate easily tick volumes, does your indicator relies on tick volume or candle volume? (I mean, it captures the reals ticks received by MT5 and doesn't use the tickvolume feed from the broker)

regards,

PT 

Hi pedrotorres,

I appreciate your interest in my VSA. MT5 version of my VSA supports both volume sources. You can choose tick or real volume. 

In case of any other questions, do not hesitate to contact me.  

Best Regards,

Michal Jurnik 

Добрый день!

Что-то триал не ставится на график.

Hi Vladimir,

In case you are looking for trial version, you can download demo of any our products for free. Just click on the "Free Demo" button.

In other case, please place comment in English.

Best Regards,
Michal 

Hello, but in Russian there?

Hi Michal, I bought your indicator, do you have sample code for iCustom interface  ?  It will ease anyone job that wants to integrate your tool to our EA.

Hi fiestafalcon, 

Here is the example. Please notice, that the each param has its position by indicator property. 

What are your buffers and possible buffer values ? Can I enumarate buffers from U to HB , do i need to expect true or false ? Your buffer values are updated only at open price right ?

For exp , is it correct ?

enum VsaIndexEnum

{

   VSA_U = 1,

   VSA_RU,

   VSA_PU,

   VSA_PRU,

   VSA_ND,

   VSA_NS,

   VSA_PBC,

   VSA_PSC,

   VSA_CAS,

   VSA_CAB,

   VSA_RS,

   VSA_S,

   VSA_2RS,

   VSA_2S,

   VSA_TR,

   VSA_BR,

   VSA_RER,

   VSA_REF,

   VSA_SVS,

   VSA_SVB,

   VSA_TD,

   VSA_TS,

   VSA_FPB,

   VSA_FPS,

   VSA_ERM,

   VSA_EFM,

   VSA_HS,

   VSA_HB

};

There is only one buffer that indicates what type of VSA patterns is at current bar.

The list is here:

Hi Michal, I integrated it to my EA, and it's working. However there is major issue, looks you didn't seperate the visual drawing functionality as option while filling the buffer, frankly speaking it's a bad and poor degign. Once i disable all drawing options , buffer is always empty !!! Pls consider  filling bueffer even drawing is not enabled. Otherwise your indicator is resource hungary during EA optimization, no one does have such big time, looking forward to get new release pls !

Hi fiestafalcon, 

Thank you for you feedback. We really appreciate it. 

Unfortunately, we will not change our PipTick VSA as you requested. The main reason is that the purpose of the indicator is to show VSA patterns. The indicator works perfectly fine. Therefore there is no doubt that the design is correct. 

On the other hand, we are going to consider our naming convention because the "show" word indicates visual drawing, instead of calculation. 

Hi Michal, Your indicator don not support cloud optimization,  I faced same issue with another MT5 indicator and the seller was able to fix it.

Could you pls check the case with MT support team , and release a new fixed versioon ? 

Hi Michal,

Could you advice a way to speed up this indciator for icustome call. It takes really much time, do not allow me to optimize it.

I will be greatly appriced if you can help. Looking forward to hearing form you.

Thx

Hello Fiestafalcon,

We tested our indicator and there is no doubt that it works fine. There are 2 steps:

1. Initial step - Once the indicators starts, it takes approximately 350ms to calculates and draws the all bar back. It depends on how many bars the MT has loaded
2. Continuous step - It takes 30ms to calculates and calculates current bar

Hello Michal,

This product is quite fine for manual trading, however it is not fast enough for automated trading, especially if you try to do optimization it is nightmare to finish a short set of optimizations.

Definitly it needs to speed up for automated trading and optimizations. 

For solutions options.

1. I will happy to try reduce "Bars_Ago to calculate and draw only defined bars ago". There is no such buffer in the indicator. Will you be releasing new one  to do this ?

2. Best and right to do is, put an option to draw it or not to draw it. For automated trading and optimization we dont need drawing. Looks you ignored it. It will be best if you can do it.

Looking forward to hear soon.

Hello Michal, Any comment ?

Hello Michal, are you checking this page ? Pls do follow up.