Solo gli utenti che hanno acquistato o noleggiato il prodotto possono lasciare commenti
Max  
hello does not work, panel does not show after applying to a chart, so i assume ea also not work
Max  
Max:
hello does not work, panel does not show after applying to a chart, so i assume ea also not work

Hi, actually I think my MT4 installation got corrupted, and some things from Market stopped working. This is a really great tool, haven't tested it yet, will be using for trailing stops. Thank you.

Max  

loaded up, working perfectly, looks good but havnt tested yet

one thing would add bar close/bar touch option for only close at new candle

HarveyA  
Just for clarity is the magic number the number of pips buffer from the MA?
Max  
nah not working correctly at all
Luca Spinello  
HarveyA #:
Just for clarity is the magic number the number of pips buffer from the MA?

No, the Magic Number is a filter parameter to trail stops only for positions with specific magic number. A magic number is the id assigned to trades opened by other expert advisors. If you do not use Supertrend Trailing Stop in conjunction with other EAs, you don't need to pay attention to this input parameter.

Luca Spinello  
Max #:
nah not working correctly at all

What exactly isn't working? Did you Enable Trailing after attaching the expert advisor to the chart?

Max  
Luca Spinello #:

What exactly isn't working? Did you Enable Trailing after attaching the expert advisor to the chart?

Yes i enabled trailing. I am using my own settings for Supertrend, not default. I put the indicator on the chart to check, but it did not stop where the indicator line was. 

Max  

I read your reply to my review. I did not imagine it was not using virtual stoplosses. I do work with break even as well, so that would interfere with this, unless you added either a break-even function or everything was virtual stoploss, ie close at market as the EA monitors the price and indicator cross. I have not come across another ST SL EA or one that manages all orders across all pairs, so I am really interested to use your EA! It would be great if you choose Supertrend or Bars back (donchian type) for the EA too.

Is there a problem with cycles and CPU resources if using virtual sl / at market close? Would be interested to pay for such a utility. Thank you, sorry if my review is incorrect. If you could explain my misunderstanding, I will test again and change the review.

Max  

It seems like other people are saying similar things to me. You do not seem to listen.

if you could reply quickly, not after 5 months, maybe we could make some progress on this?!

You seem to make some things which seem very useful but do not work as intuitively logical as expected. That seems rather strange.

What is your aim on here??

Max  

Dear Luca, 

I must apologise if I came across as rude.

I have tried this again and I believe it IS working correctly. One just has to make sure that there is an initial stoploss (ISL) in place already, as the EA only adjusts the stoploss already in place.


I was actually looking for something lightweight and inexpensive that would work across multiple pairs and orders, and as so well produced as this, but which I could use in more complex situations with virtual/hidden SLs and BEs. However, if one is adaptable, as maybe I should be more so, it may be a better way of operating anyway and thus serve me much better than I imagined. Especially as I use it further.


~~The problems arose with me, because of the way Metaquotes handles the Market and Free items within the Marketplace, and not the fault of the developer. Although I was further confused because the products are also offered on Luca's website, and I believe they are different versions, since now I am actually using a version that I downloaded from his website. I wish the products were organised to be the same across MQL and his private website, or a clearer explanation of different versions workings.


I do appreciate he has offered without charge and may be taken up working on other things, whilst MQL makes changes to various aspects quite regularly!

Luca Spinello  
Max #:

Dear Luca, 

I must apologise if I came across as rude.

I have tried this again and I believe it IS working correctly. One just has to make sure that there is an initial stoploss (ISL) in place already, as the EA only adjusts the stoploss already in place.


I was actually looking for something lightweight and inexpensive that would work across multiple pairs and orders, and as so well produced as this, but which I could use in more complex situations with virtual/hidden SLs and BEs. However, if one is adaptable, as maybe I should be more so, it may be a better way of operating anyway and thus serve me much better than I imagined. Especially as I use it further.


~~The problems arose with me, because of the way Metaquotes handles the Market and Free items within the Marketplace, and not the fault of the developer. Although I was further confused because the products are also offered on Luca's website, and I believe they are different versions, since now I am actually using a version that I downloaded from his website. I wish the products were organised to be the same across MQL and his private website, or a clearer explanation of different versions workings.


I do appreciate he has offered without charge and may be taken up working on other things, whilst MQL makes changes to various aspects quite regularly!

Sorry for not updating the products regularly or responding to comments more often. I try to do it as often as possible.

The EA doesn't need an initial SL to work. It might not be updating SL when the current MODE_STOPLEVEL doesn't allow it to. There is also a bug due to which the EA doesn't normalize the SL price by TICK_SIZE, resulting in an invalid SL values for indices and similar instruments. But this shouldn't be an issue in normal Forex pairs.

Lieven Luc O Vandecasteele  

Hi Luca,

First of all : GREAT TOOL!

But the EA would even be more greater :-) if you could add 2 more choices regarding the trailing function :


-  Only start trailing when the trade is in profit

-  Only start trailing when the supertrend is over break-even


Anyway I'm very satisfied with the EA!    Much appreciated!

Benjamin Dagget  

I rarely make comments, but I have to say I have found that everything that Luca has made is outstanding. 

Krzysztof Tadeusz Kanacki  
A very nice helper. There is one important thing missing, trigger level. There should be an option to set the level from which we start trailing. In this form, without a trigger, there are frequent close/exit with a small loss. Regards
Khulani  
May we please get an MT5 version.
renjvb2  
very nice tool and works great but there is one problem. the SL gets updated on the supertrend line from the active candle. This is repainted as the candle hasnt closed yet. This caused my trade to close prematurely without price reaching for the supertrend line. I think the SL should be updated based on the ST line from the previous candle. 
Luca Spinello  
renjvb2 #:
very nice tool and works great but there is one problem. the SL gets updated on the supertrend line from the active candle. This is repainted as the candle hasnt closed yet. This caused my trade to close prematurely without price reaching for the supertrend line. I think the SL should be updated based on the ST line from the previous candle. 

You can change this line from:

int SuperTrendShift=0;

to:

int SuperTrendShift=1;

in the source code and re-compile.

8enlightenor Lumiere  

Where are instructions on how to use, and apply to a trade? 

Thank you

Solo gli utenti che hanno acquistato o noleggiato il prodotto possono lasciare commenti