How do you check if an EA actually has trading logic behind it?
With AI tools, it has become very easy to generate indicators and Expert Advisors. Code that compiles and runs is no longer proof that the author understood what they built.
I'm curious how other developers and traders approach this. When you look at an EA or indicator, how do you check whether there is real logic behind it, and not just a set of conditions that happen to fit the backtest?
For example:
- Do you look for a clear reason why each entry and exit exists?
- Do you test out-of-sample or on other symbols before you trust it?
- Are there warning signs in the code or settings that tell you there is no real idea behind it?
I'd like to hear what methods you use.
I no longer use any executable file without its source code file. That ends the mystery.
Regarding AI tools, I don't believe that it matters whether AI was used or not. In other words, black box EA's were and continue to be black boxes with or without the advent of AI. To the extent that there is more junk software floating around due to the proliferation of AI, that pretty much goes for the whole shinternet.
With AI tools, it has become very easy to generate indicators and Expert Advisors. Code that compiles and runs is no longer proof that the author understood what they built.
I'm curious how other developers and traders approach this. When you look at an EA or indicator, how do you check whether there is real logic behind it, and not just a set of conditions that happen to fit the backtest?
For example:
I'd like to hear what methods you use.