Why do most EAs take so many bad trades… even when the logic seems correct?

New comment
 

 been testing different systems recently, and something keeps standing out. Most EAs aren’t necessarily bad at finding trade signals, they’re just not very good at avoiding bad conditions.

You’ll see things like:

  • indicators align open trade
  • conditions met open trade

But markets don’t really reward activity if anything, they punish it. I wondered

What if the problem isn’t signal detection…but the lack of restraint?

Instead of trying to make systems better at finding trades,

what if they were designed to be better at refusing them?

Not just filtering after the fact,
but being inherently biased toward not trading unless everything makes sense structurally.

I’m curious how others approach this. Do you think most EAs suffer more from overtrading…

or from poor signal quality?

 
Francis Nyoike Thumbi:

 been testing different systems recently, and something keeps standing out. Most EAs aren’t necessarily bad at finding trade signals, they’re just not very good at avoiding bad conditions.

You’ll see things like:

  • indicators align open trade
  • conditions met open trade

But markets don’t really reward activity if anything, they punish it. I wondered

What if the problem isn’t signal detection…but the lack of restraint?

Instead of trying to make systems better at finding trades,

what if they were designed to be better at refusing them?

Not just filtering after the fact,
but being inherently biased toward not trading unless everything makes sense structurally.

I’m curious how others approach this. Do you think most EAs suffer more from overtrading…

or from poor signal quality?

You seem to describe the difference between "Gambler" EA and "Casino" EA.

What are you aiming to achieve? Attract attention to your product?

 
Oleksandr Medviediev #:

You seem to describe the difference between "Gambler" EA and "Casino" EA.

What are you aiming to achieve? Attract attention to your product?

I'm aiming to shift the conversation toward 'Market Structure' and 'Refusal Logic.' Honestly If providing a more robust, structurally biased framework attracts attention to the product, that’s a secondary benefit but the primary goal is advocating for a more professional standard of automation that mimics how EA 'casinos' actually operate.
New comment