2 different results in 2 MetaTrades from 2 brokers (version 4)

 

Hello

I first downloaded the data I wanted from the Tickstory software.

Then I imported the same data in MetaTrader 4 from icm broker and Alpari broker.

Then I started taking back tests (timeframe 5 minutes) from both MetaTrader 4.

But I got different results from each, while all the settings and data were exactly the same.

i attached screen shot.

what's the reason?

what should I do?

Is the MetaTrader test reliable? (Of course, I know that this test is from the past and has no guarantee for the future)

According to the topics of this link( https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/768940-how-to-get-999-modeling-quality-on-mt4 ), what is your suggestion? 


thank you

Files:
icm.PNG  22 kb
alpari.PNG  19 kb
 
masood cmpy:

Hello

I first downloaded the data I wanted from the Tickstory software.

Then I imported the same data in MetaTrader 4 from icm broker and Alpari broker.

Then I started taking back tests (timeframe 5 minutes) from both MetaTrader 4.

But I got different results from each, while all the settings and data were exactly the same.

i attached screen shot.

what's the reason?

what should I do?

Is the MetaTrader test reliable? (Of course, I know that this test is from the past and has no guarantee for the future)

According to the topics of this link( https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/768940-how-to-get-999-modeling-quality-on-mt4 ), what is your suggestion? 


thank you

Your backtest has different modelling quality (check your capture).

 
Sandi Purwo Krisnandri Widigdo:
Your backtest has different modelling quality (check your capture).



Thanks for answering my problem 

I'm sorry, but what does "check your capture" mean?

I do not understand what you mean!

Please explain a little more

thank you