This
article provides conclusive evidence that the U.S. stock market is
highly inefficient. Our results, spanning a 45 year period, indicate
dramatic, consistent, and negative payoffs to measures of risk, positive
payoffs to measures of current profitability, positive payoffs to
measures of cheapness, positive payoffs to momentum in stock return, and
negative payoffs to recent stock performance. Our comprehensive
expected return factor model successfully predicts future return, out of
sample, in each of the forty-five years covered by our study save one.
Stunningly, the ten percent of stocks with highest expected return, in
aggregate, are low risk and highly profitable, with positive trends in
profitability. They are cheap relative to current earnings, cash flow,
sales, and dividends. They have relatively large market capitalization
and positive price momentum over the previous year. The ten percent with
lowest expected return (decile 1) have exactly the opposite profile,
and we find a smooth transition in the profiles as we go from 1 through
10. We split the whole 45-year time period into five sub-periods, and
find that the relative profiles hold over all periods. Undeniably, the
highest expected return stocks are, collectively, highly attractive; the
lowest expected return stocks are very scary - results fatal to the
efficient market hypothesis. While this evidence is consistent with risk
loving in the cross-section, we also present strong evidence consistent
with risk aversion in the market aggregate's longitudinal behavior.
These behaviors cannot simultaneously exist in an efficient market.
There has been much historic discussion about the effectiveness, or otherwise, of technical trading strategies in the financial markets. The view, that ‘technicalanalysis’
(TA) may be of limited value in a market seemingly driven by economic
fundamentals, would seem to be supported by research showing that retail
Foreign Exchange (FX) traders as a whole are not achieving returns
above that of random trading. Despite this, technical
trading strategies and the search for the ‘holy grail’ system remains
ever popular with the Retail FX Trader. This paper examines three
popular technical trading
strategies and ‘best practices’ used by the retail FX trader, to try and
identify rules and approaches that might help such a trader achieve
‘better-than-random’ trading results. Using a non-optimised, computer
based trading simulation, results from over 175 million ‘random’ trades
across nine years of data were evaluated to try and establish if such
rules exist and to answer the question ‘can a Retail FX Trader ever
expect to use technicalanalysis to achieve net profitable outcomes?’ The results show that the use of TechnicalAnalysis
does seem to offer better-than-random results and that setting
significantly larger profit targets for trades, versus the maximum loss a
trader is prepared to accept, can produce profitable trading, even when
using no TA and entering trades randomly.
This study takes a novel approach to testing the efficacy of technicalanalysis.
Rather than testing specific trading rules as is typically done in the
literature, we rely on institutional portfolio managers’ statements
about whether and how intensely they use technicalanalysis,
irrespective of the form in which they implement it. In our sample of
more than 10,000 portfolios, about one-third of actively managed equity
and balanced funds use technicalanalysis. We compare the investment performance of funds that use technicalanalysis
versus those that do not using five metrics. Mean and median (3 and
4-factor) alpha values are generally slightly higher for a cross section
of funds using technicalanalysis,
but performance volatility is also higher. Benchmark-adjusted returns
are also higher, particularly when market prices are declining. The most
remarkable finding is that portfolios with greater reliance on technicalanalysis have elevated skewness and kurtosis levels relative to portfolios that do not use technicalanalysis. Funds using technicalanalysis appear to have provided a meaningful advantage to their investors, albeit in an unexpected way.
In virtually every decision they make, executives today consider
some kind of forecast. Sound predictions of demands and trends are no
longer luxury items, but a necessity, if managers are to cope with
seasonality, sudden changes in demand levels, price-cutting maneuvers of
the competition, strikes, and large swings of the economy. Forecasting
can help them deal with these troubles; but it can help them more, the
more they know about the general principles of forecasting, what it can
and cannot do for them currently, and which techniques are suited to
their needs of the moment. Here the authors try to explain the potential
of forecasting to managers, focusing special attention on sales
forecasting for products of Corning Glass Works as these have matured
through the product life cycle. Also included is a rundown of
forecasting techniques.
To handle the increasing variety and complexity of managerial
forecasting problems, many forecasting techniques have been developed in
recent years. Each has its special use, and care must be taken to
select the correct technique for a particular application. The manager
as well as the forecaster has a role to play in technique selection; and
the better they understand the range of forecasting possibilities, the
more likely it is that a company’s forecasting efforts will bear fruit.
The selection of a method depends on many factors—the context of the
forecast, the relevance and availability of historical data, the degree
of accuracy desirable, the time period to be forecast, the cost/ benefit
(or value) of the forecast to the company, and the time available for making the analysis.
These factors must be weighed constantly, and on a variety of levels.
In general, for example, the forecaster should choose a technique that
makes the best use of available data. If the forecaster can readily
apply one technique of acceptable accuracy, he or she should not try to
“gold plate” by using a more advanced technique that offers potentially
greater accuracy but that requires nonexistent information or
information that is costly to obtain. This kind of trade-off is
relatively easy to make, but others, as we shall see, require
considerably more thought.
Furthermore, where a company wishes to forecast with reference to a particular product, it must consider the stage of the product’s life cycle for which it is making the forecast.
The availability of data and the possibility of establishing
relationships between the factors depend directly on the maturity of a
product, and hence the life-cycle stage is a prime determinant of the
forecasting method to be used.
Our purpose here is to present an overview of this field by
discussing the way a company ought to approach a forecasting problem,
describing the methods available, and explaining how to match method to
problem. We shall illustrate the use of the various techniques from our
experience with them at Corning, and then close with our own forecast
for the future of forecasting.
Although we believe forecasting is still an art, we think that some
of the principles which we have learned through experience may be
helpful to others.
Manager, Forecaster & Choice of Methods
A manager generally assumes that when asking a forecaster to prepare a
specific projection, the request itself provides sufficient information
for the forecaster to go to work and do the job. This is almost never
true.
Successful forecasting begins with a collaboration between the
manager and the forecaster, in which they work out answers to the
following questions.
1. What is the purpose of the forecast—how is it to be used?
This determines the accuracy and power required of the techniques, and
hence governs selection. Deciding whether to enter a business may
require only a rather gross estimate of the size of the market, whereas a
forecast made for budgeting purposes should be quite accurate. The
appropriate techniques differ accordingly.
Again, if the forecast is to set a “standard” against which to
evaluate performance, the forecasting method should not take into
account special actions, such as promotions and other marketing devices,
since these are meant to change historical patterns and relationships
and hence form part of the “performance” to be evaluated.
Forecasts that simply sketch what the future will be like if a
company makes no significant changes in tactics and strategy are usually
not good enough for planning purposes. On the other hand, if management
wants a forecast of the effect that a certain marketing strategy under
debate will have on sales growth, then the technique must be
sophisticated enough to take explicit account of the special actions and
events the strategy entails.
Techniques vary in their costs, as well as in scope and accuracy. The
manager must fix the level of inaccuracy he or she can tolerate—in
other words, decide how his or her decision will vary, depending on the
range of accuracy of the forecast. This allows the forecaster to trade
off cost against the value of accuracy in choosing a technique.
For example, in production and inventory control, increased accuracy
is likely to lead to lower safety stocks. Here the manager and
forecaster must weigh the cost of a more sophisticated and more
expensive technique against potential savings in inventory costs.
Exhibit I shows how cost and accuracy increase with sophistication
and charts this against the corresponding cost of forecasting errors,
given some general assumptions. The most sophisticated technique that
can be economically justified is one that falls in the region where the
sum of the two costs is minimal.
Exhibit I Cost of Forecasting Versus Cost of Inaccuracy For a Medium-Range Forecast, Given Data Availability
Once the manager has defined the purpose of the forecast, the
forecaster can advise the manager on how often it could usefully be
produced. From a strategic point of view, they should discuss whether
the decision to be made on the basis of the forecast can be changed
later, if they find the forecast was inaccurate. If it can be
changed, they should then discuss the usefulness of installing a system
to track the accuracy of the forecast and the kind of tracking system
that is appropriate.
2. What are the dynamics and components of the system for which the forecast will be made?
This clarifies the relationships of interacting variables. Generally,
the manager and the forecaster must review a flow chart that shows the
relative positions of the different elements of the distribution system,
sales system, production system, or whatever is being studied.
We propose a decomposition to distinguish between Knightian uncertainty (ambiguity) and risk, where the rst measures the uncertainty about the probability distribution generating the data, while the second measures uncertainty about the odds of the outcomes when the probability distribution is known. We use the Survey of Professional Forecasters (SPF) density forecasts to quantify overall uncertainty as well as the evolution of the di¤erent components of uncertainty over time and investigate their importance for macroeconomic uctuations. We also study the behavior and evolution of the various components of our decomposition in a model that features ambiguity and risk.
We
document strong persistence in the performance of trades of individual
investors. The correlation of the risk-adjusted performance of an
individual across sample periods is about 10 percent. Investors
classified in the top performance decile in the first half of our sample
subsequently outperform those in the bottom decile by about 8 percent
per year. Strategies long in firms purchased by previously successful
investors and short in firms purchased by previously unsuccessful
investors earn abnormal returns of 5 basis points per day. These returns
are not confined to small stocks nor to stocks in which the investors
are likely to have inside information. Our results suggest that skillful
individual investors exploit market
inefficiencies to earn abnormal profits, above and beyond any profits
available from well-known strategies based upon size, value, or
momentum.
In this paper I examine various extensions of the Nelson and Siegel (1987) model with the purpose of fitting and forecasting
the term structure of interest rates. As expected, I find that using
more flexible models leads to a better in-sample fit of the term
structure. However, I show that the out-of-sample
predictability improves as well. A four-factor model, which adds a
second slope factor to the three-factor Nelson-Siegel model, forecasts
particularly well. Especially with a one-step state-space estimation
approach the four-factor model produces accurate forecasts and
outperforms competitor models across maturities and forecast horizons.
Subsample analysis shows that this outperformance is also consistent
over time.
Using
stocks from a wide range of industry sectors on the Australian
Securities Exchange, this paper examines the conditional distribution of
intra-day stock prices and predicts the direction of the next price
change in an ordered-probit-GARCH framework that accounts for the
discreteness of prices. The analysis also incorporates the endogeneity
of the time between trades in an ACD framework. Other elements
considered include depth, trade imbalance, and volume. The results show
that trade imbalance has a positive effect on the probability of price
change. Durations have a negative effect. In-sample and out-of-sampleforecasting analyses reveal that in 71% of the cases the system successfully predicts the direction of the subsequent price change.
Allow the use of cookies to log in to the MQL5.com website.
Please enable the necessary setting in your browser, otherwise you will not be able to log in.
You are signed in. Two-factor authentication has been disabled. Set it up again and scan a new QR code, or continue with two-factor authentication disabled.
How to Choose the Right Forecasting Technique
In virtually every decision they make, executives today consider some kind of forecast. Sound predictions of demands and trends are no longer luxury items, but a necessity, if managers are to cope with seasonality, sudden changes in demand levels, price-cutting maneuvers of the competition, strikes, and large swings of the economy. Forecasting can help them deal with these troubles; but it can help them more, the more they know about the general principles of forecasting, what it can and cannot do for them currently, and which techniques are suited to their needs of the moment. Here the authors try to explain the potential of forecasting to managers, focusing special attention on sales forecasting for products of Corning Glass Works as these have matured through the product life cycle. Also included is a rundown of forecasting techniques.
To handle the increasing variety and complexity of managerial forecasting problems, many forecasting techniques have been developed in recent years. Each has its special use, and care must be taken to select the correct technique for a particular application. The manager as well as the forecaster has a role to play in technique selection; and the better they understand the range of forecasting possibilities, the more likely it is that a company’s forecasting efforts will bear fruit.
The selection of a method depends on many factors—the context of the forecast, the relevance and availability of historical data, the degree of accuracy desirable, the time period to be forecast, the cost/ benefit (or value) of the forecast to the company, and the time available for making the analysis.
These factors must be weighed constantly, and on a variety of levels. In general, for example, the forecaster should choose a technique that makes the best use of available data. If the forecaster can readily apply one technique of acceptable accuracy, he or she should not try to “gold plate” by using a more advanced technique that offers potentially greater accuracy but that requires nonexistent information or information that is costly to obtain. This kind of trade-off is relatively easy to make, but others, as we shall see, require considerably more thought.
Furthermore, where a company wishes to forecast with reference to a particular product, it must consider the stage of the product’s life cycle for which it is making the forecast. The availability of data and the possibility of establishing relationships between the factors depend directly on the maturity of a product, and hence the life-cycle stage is a prime determinant of the forecasting method to be used.
Our purpose here is to present an overview of this field by discussing the way a company ought to approach a forecasting problem, describing the methods available, and explaining how to match method to problem. We shall illustrate the use of the various techniques from our experience with them at Corning, and then close with our own forecast for the future of forecasting.
Although we believe forecasting is still an art, we think that some of the principles which we have learned through experience may be helpful to others.
Manager, Forecaster & Choice of Methods
A manager generally assumes that when asking a forecaster to prepare a specific projection, the request itself provides sufficient information for the forecaster to go to work and do the job. This is almost never true.
Successful forecasting begins with a collaboration between the manager and the forecaster, in which they work out answers to the following questions.
1. What is the purpose of the forecast—how is it to be used? This determines the accuracy and power required of the techniques, and hence governs selection. Deciding whether to enter a business may require only a rather gross estimate of the size of the market, whereas a forecast made for budgeting purposes should be quite accurate. The appropriate techniques differ accordingly.
Again, if the forecast is to set a “standard” against which to evaluate performance, the forecasting method should not take into account special actions, such as promotions and other marketing devices, since these are meant to change historical patterns and relationships and hence form part of the “performance” to be evaluated.
Forecasts that simply sketch what the future will be like if a company makes no significant changes in tactics and strategy are usually not good enough for planning purposes. On the other hand, if management wants a forecast of the effect that a certain marketing strategy under debate will have on sales growth, then the technique must be sophisticated enough to take explicit account of the special actions and events the strategy entails.
Techniques vary in their costs, as well as in scope and accuracy. The manager must fix the level of inaccuracy he or she can tolerate—in other words, decide how his or her decision will vary, depending on the range of accuracy of the forecast. This allows the forecaster to trade off cost against the value of accuracy in choosing a technique.
For example, in production and inventory control, increased accuracy is likely to lead to lower safety stocks. Here the manager and forecaster must weigh the cost of a more sophisticated and more expensive technique against potential savings in inventory costs.
Exhibit I shows how cost and accuracy increase with sophistication and charts this against the corresponding cost of forecasting errors, given some general assumptions. The most sophisticated technique that can be economically justified is one that falls in the region where the sum of the two costs is minimal.
Exhibit I Cost of Forecasting Versus Cost of Inaccuracy For a Medium-Range Forecast, Given Data Availability
Once the manager has defined the purpose of the forecast, the forecaster can advise the manager on how often it could usefully be produced. From a strategic point of view, they should discuss whether the decision to be made on the basis of the forecast can be changed later, if they find the forecast was inaccurate. If it can be changed, they should then discuss the usefulness of installing a system to track the accuracy of the forecast and the kind of tracking system that is appropriate.
2. What are the dynamics and components of the system for which the forecast will be made? This clarifies the relationships of interacting variables. Generally, the manager and the forecaster must review a flow chart that shows the relative positions of the different elements of the distribution system, sales system, production system, or whatever is being studied.Very good book. Thanks
I am not sure that market efficiency can explain all what is going on now with forex, but it is good to see all these books here