Aroon Indicator - page 5

 
mladen:
tampa

Better to use this one : https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/173526

If you take a look at the low values of that arron indicator, you will notice that it never reaches 0 value (and it should). So, better to use the correct version (not a big difference, bu the difference exists)

Did not notice it before

Thanks for the heads up

 
mladen:
tampa

Better to use this one : https://www.mql5.com/en/forum/173526

If you take a look at the low values of that arron indicator, you will notice that it never reaches 0 value (and it should). So, better to use the correct version (not a big difference, bu the difference exists)

How is that all the metatrader versions have the same error? I mean, those are supposed t be made by different coders. If you found out the error, the others should too

 
nbtrading:
How is that all the metatrader versions have the same error? I mean, those are supposed t be made by different coders. If you found out the error, the others should too

Probably because coder inherit formulas and sometimes they simply do not examine the formula for errors

 
mladen:
Probably because coder inherit formulas and sometimes they simply do not examine the formula for errors

You mean when someone cries wolf and all the rest cry wolf too without making sure if a wolf is there OK, thanks for the answer

 

Aroon horn

aroon_horn.mq4

Files:
 

Aroon Filter

aroon_filter.mq4

Files:
 

Are these aroon indicators that aroon bug free?

 
nbtrading:
Are these aroon indicators that aroon bug free?

Easy to check : for length 10 minimum and maximum must be -100 and +100. If they are not, then it is not OK

 
mladen:
Easy to check : for length 10 minimum and maximum must be -100 and +100. If they are not, then it is not OK

Then it looks like it is not OK

 

Can it be corrected

Reason: