Solo gli utenti che hanno acquistato o noleggiato il prodotto possono lasciare commenti
Kwok Fung Chan  
Thank you it is profitable in backtest, can you add risk% based on balance?
Anton Kilin  
Kwok Fung Chan:
Thank you it is profitable in backtest, can you add risk% based on balance?

Yes I can. I'll do it later.
Haifeng Liu  

Can I join the money management?

best regards !

Anton Kilin  
wslhf:

Can I join the money management?

best regards !


I'm doing this already. Coming soon.
Eric Ruvalcaba  

Absolutely gorgeous! 


Congrats on the great finding and your enourmous contribution to the community, really pleased with the results.


Could you add ECN accounts compatibility?


Thanks a lot in advance.

Anton Kilin  
Eric:

Absolutely gorgeous! 


Congrats on the great finding and your enourmous contribution to the community, really pleased with the results.


Could you add ECN accounts compatibility?


Thanks a lot in advance.


I will try to do. As soon as I have free time, I'll start work.
Sinisa Sinjori  

Hello Anton, 

This EA looks interesting, because I can optimize it very fast, and very well - it shows good results during optimization. Of course, that means one have to continue optimization, so EA can produce good results in future period too. But, that's not a problem, of course. What surprise me (positive), it opened exactly the same trades on two different brokers (which other EAs usually don't do). 
So, it seems EA has potential.

One thing I would suggest (except the % money management, as some trades already suggested) is including trailing stop. Now, EA has just take profit, but in some cases we could avoid some loosing trades and probably take some pips more in some situations - with trailing stop. EA is very fast during optimization, so trailing stop (with other combinations) won't be the problem.

After that, you can even charge money for it, because I believe EA will be profitable (but, that's just my current opinion, need more testing for real review) if one is willing to continue to optimize it for future periods. 
But, when you have good EA, that's not the problem then ;)

Best regards

Anton Kilin  
Sinisa Sinjori:

Hello Anton, 

This EA looks interesting, because I can optimize it very fast, and very well - it shows good results during optimization. Of course, that means one have to continue optimization, so EA can produce good results in future period too. But, that's not a problem, of course. What surprise me (positive), it opened exactly the same trades on two different brokers (which other EAs usually don't do). 
So, it seems EA has potential.

One thing I would suggest (except the % money management, as some trades already suggested) is including trailing stop. Now, EA has just take profit, but in some cases we could avoid some loosing trades and probably take some pips more in some situations - with trailing stop. EA is very fast during optimization, so trailing stop (with other combinations) won't be the problem.

After that, you can even charge money for it, because I believe EA will be profitable (but, that's just my current opinion, need more testing for real review) if one is willing to continue to optimize it for future periods. 
But, when you have good EA, that's not the problem then ;)

Best regards


Now I'm doing it. Soon there will be MM and Trailing Stop.

I also think that the strategy is interesting, although transactions do not appear so often, but, if used on several instruments, you can achieve better results.

Sinisa Sinjori  
Anton Kilin:


Now I'm doing it. Soon there will be MM and Trailing Stop.

I also think that the strategy is interesting, although transactions do not appear so often, but, if used on several instruments, you can achieve better results.


Thanks Anton. 
Have a great day!
nicktrader72  

Ciao, 

ho testato l'ea in backtest e i risultati sono ottimi.

Ho poi inserito l'ea in demo (su eurusd M5 e usdjpy M15, con i settaggi indicati)  ma in tre giorni non ha fatto nessuna operazione. 

E' normale?  

Lo sto utilizzando sulla stessa piattaforma su cui girano anche  altri ea, ma   ovviamente con magic number diversi.

Grazie per l'informazione

Sinisa Sinjori  
nicktrader72:

Hello,

I tested the ea in backtest and the results are great.

I then put the e in demo (on eurusd M5 and usdjpy M15, with the settings shown) but in three days did not do any operation.

It's normal?

I'm using it on the same platform on which others are also running, but obviously with different magic numbers.

Thanks for the information


Are you talking about default settings, or you did optimization?
I mean, which results are great - with standard settings? 
Which pairs? 
I am just curios, because I have found it's profitable just with good optimization. 
Thanks
nicktrader72  
Sinisa Sinjori:

Are you talking about default settings, or you did optimization?
I mean, which results are great - with standard settings? 
Which pairs? 
I am just curios, because I have found it's profitable just with good optimization. 
Thanks


Ciao, 

con impostazione standard su eurusd M5.

Lotto 0.1 su capitale di 500 euro.

Il problema è che in 4 giorni, in demo, non ha fatto nessuna operazione.

E' normale?

nicktrader72  

Allego report backtest

Vorrei provare a testarlo in demo, ma non capisco se non parte perche non ha ancora trovato le condizioni giuste o se c'è un problema.

Grazie

File:
Sinisa Sinjori  
nicktrader72:

Allego report backtest

Vorrei provare a testarlo in demo, ma non capisco se non parte perche non ha ancora trovato le condizioni giuste o se c'è un problema.

Grazie


According the backtest results - it's normal. If you look at your results you can see that you have tested it from 2014.01.01 - 2016.12.31 and during that whole period you had just 149 transactions. That's 3 whole Years with just 149 transactions. It means about 4 transactions per Month (average). 
However, you can do optimization (if you know how to do that properly - please, don't use 90% data quality as you did for backtest - you have to prepare data by TickStory or some other similar software), and you can find very interesting combinations (much more transactions during Month and much more profitability). But, in that case, you would have to do optimization regularly (every X weeks, depending on settings, profitability during Live preiod etc... - long story). 

Saluto ;)

Sinisa Sinjori  

Anton, thank you very much for new version. 
Have a great weekend!

P.S. I will play with optimization during weekend, and after some time will publish some real results. Let's see how it goes ;)

Anton Kilin  
Sinisa Sinjori:

Anton, thank you very much for new version. 
Have a great weekend!

P.S. I will play with optimization during weekend, and after some time will publish some real results. Let's see how it goes ;)


I continue to work on the product. Good luck with optimization.
Sinisa Sinjori  

Here it the one of the first results (optimization is still in progress) - gain a bit more then 100% in 3 Month
I have used 99% data quality (prepared with TickStory). 
There was so clean and strong growth that Profit factor can't be calculated. Looks amazing. Also I got one result with Profit factor 517 !

As I already sad, EA has big potential, but of course, we cave to confirm that in Live trading. 

P.S. The optimization result doesn't mean it will be like that in future period. But, there are some chance (good chance). That's why, if we wish good result in future, we have to do optimization regularly. 

Cheers

File:
Anton Kilin  
Sinisa Sinjori:

Here it the one of the first results (optimization is still in progress) - gain a bit more then 100% in 3 Month
I have used 99% data quality (prepared with TickStory). 
There was so clean and strong growth that Profit factor can't be calculated. Looks amazing. Also I got one result with Profit factor 517 !

As I already sad, EA has big potential, but of course, we cave to confirm that in Live trading. 

P.S. The optimization result doesn't mean it will be like that in future period. But, there are some chance (good chance). That's why, if we wish good result in future, we have to do optimization regularly. 

Cheers


This version is only for demo account. I have not yet completed the function for trading on a real account. Do not hurry, wait a bit and I'll do it. I do not have time to finish.
Руслан Кабиров  

Всем привет! Нашел для себя лучший вариант, может кому тоже пригодится.

Оптимизирован на М30 за период 01.01.16 - 30.06.16.

Успешный форвард тест с 01.07.16 по 02.06.17. Конечно не 99% но все же. Поставил на демо акк, посмотрим.

Общий отчет во вложении.

Anton Kilin  
Руслан Кабиров:

Всем привет! Нашел для себя лучший вариант, может кому тоже пригодится.

Оптимизирован на М30 за период 01.01.16 - 30.06.16.

Успешный форвард тест с 01.07.16 по 02.06.17. Конечно не 99% но все же. Поставил на демо акк, посмотрим.

Общий отчет во вложении.


Мало за 1 год. Оптимизируйте за 3-5 лет на м5-м30. Потом бек-тест на 1-2 года. Если бек-тест положительный, то можно ставить. Так можно настроить на несколько инструментов сразу с разными магиками!!! и тогда будет хороший результат. Обратите внимание, что сделки совершаются не так часто. Возможна раз в неделю и реже. Используйте трендовые инструменты, но заранее просмотрите историю инструмента вручную, чтобы убедиться что вы не попали как раз на трендовый участок и оптимизировали именно под него. Это получится подгонка, например, EURUSD за 2014, когда был тренд.
Solo gli utenti che hanno acquistato o noleggiato il prodotto possono lasciare commenti