Integer: And you put yours out in the open - let the masses use it and learn by practice, not by facts and arguments
If you put out an EA, even openly, even the most profitable one, even if you take it for free... in my opinion it won't have any effect on the market. Just in some part of the world... in Russian-speaking territory, for example, there will be users. They will just use it. Perhaps a few forums will devote a topic or two to this Expert Advisor.
I don't need to explain to anyone why it is not so, if you like to think so, think so.
You had no need to reply, but you did reply. Maybe you could go on and explain (offer your own point of view on the matter)? Originally I also thought that a profitable Expert Advisor would make or break something on the market (it seems so obvious that you believe it without thinking), but arguments like the one brought by SK. made me think twice and now I no longer have a strong opinion on the matter.
Of course no market expert will move it, this is a delusion. ...
10363999
2007.04.30 02:25
buy
0.10
gbpjpy
238.00
0.00
238.25
2007.04.30 03:21
238.25
0.00
0.00
0.00
20.93
[tp]
10376243
2007.04.30 01:00
buy
0.10
gbpjpy
238.30
0.00
238.55
2007.04.30 05:27
238.55
0.00
0.00
0.00
20.92
[tp]
10389798
2007.04.27 20:50
sell
3.00
eurusd
1.3629
0.0000
1.3582
2007.04.30 09:07
1.3622
0.00
0.00
14.10
210.00
10389671
2007.04.27 20:43
sell
3.00
eurusd
1.3630
1.3629
1.3582
2007.04.30 09:45
1.3616
0.00
0.00
14.10
420.00
10389658
2007.04.27 20:42
sell
0.10
eurusd
1.3630
1.3629
1.3582
2007.04.30 09:45
1.3615
0.00
0.00
0.47
15.00
10379344
2007.04.27 17:03
sell
0.30
eurusd
1.3661
1.3653
1.3540
2007.04.30 09:45
1.3616
0.00
0.00
1.41
135.00
345
10397963
2007.04.30 09:21
buy
0.20
gbpjpy
238.19
0.00
238.64
2007.04.30 09:49
238.39
0.00
0.00
0.00
33.48
10389717
2007.04.27 20:45
buy
0.10
usdchf
1.2079
0.0000
1.2089
2007.04.30 10:00
1.2079
0.00
0.00
1.03
0.00
10401029
2007.04.30 10:25
buy
0.20
gbpjpy
238.19
0.00
238.29
2007.04.30 10:32
238.29
0.00
0.00
0.00
16.73
[tp]
10397962
2007.04.30 09:23
buy
0.20
gbpjpy
238.14
0.00
238.22
2007.04.30 12:20
238.22
0.00
0.00
0.00
13.37
[tp]
10397961
2007.04.30 09:26
buy
0.20
gbpjpy
238.09
0.00
238.23
2007.04.30 12:20
238.23
0.00
0.00
0.00
23.41
[tp]
10406245
2007.04.30 12:28
buy
0.20
gbpjpy
238.14
0.00
238.24
2007.04.30 12:32
238.24
0.00
0.00
0.00
16.71
[tp]
10402964
2007.04.30 11:22
buy
0.20
gbpjpy
238.19
0.00
238.27
2007.04.30 12:40
238.27
0.00
0.00
0.00
13.37
[tp]
10399482
2007.04.30 09:15
buy
1.00
usdjpy
119.53
119.54
119.88
2007.04.30 13:59
119.54
0.00
0.00
0.00
8.37
20050610
Phoenix3[sl]
10397958
2007.04.30 09:29
buy
0.20
gbpjpy
238.04
238.11
239.69
2007.04.30 14:00
238.44
0.00
0.00
0.00
66.92
0.00
0.00
31.11
1 014.21
Closed P/L:
1 045.32
this is for part day
i don't trade with the grail advisors are handled manually
Surprised me too, three lots of betting is thirty times what I'm betting!!!!! If you divide your profit commensurately. you raised thirty pips! - only thirty!!!!
ufkef: Surprised me too, three lots bet showed that's thirty times what I bet!!!!! If you divide your profit proportionately. you raised 30 pips! - only thirty!!!!
Well, 0.1 lot can do it too. I bet 1 - 6 lots to my own. 0.1 - that's a lot if you don't trust your system.
ufkef: Surprised me too, three lots bet showed that's thirty times what I bet!!!!! If you divide your profit proportionately. you raised thirty pips! - only thirty!!!!
Well, 0.1 lot can do it too. I bet 1 - 6 lots to my own. 0.1 - that's a lot if you don't trust your system.
0.00
0.00
-18.69
4 085.77
Closed P/L:
4 067.08
This is for the evening.
I'm interested purely in the mathematics of the matter, I do not care what lot, the main thing is the ratio of money invested and profit! If the investment is 10% a year. then it's easier to keep the money in the bank! If you invest 30-50%, then you can give it to a fund for management! If they invest 300-500 lots a year, they will have to draw in other people's capital and earn from them not by 1-6 lots, which is ridiculous in theory, but by dozens!
Well, for this period from September last year to April this year, what part was used to optimise the strategy (if at all) and what data was out of sample i.e. unknown strategies it ran on this story. Or was it optimised over the entire six-month period?
It is possible to show a clear run over such and such a period - the profit graph is so-and-so. From this period from so-and-so to so-and-so the data was used to optimise the rest out of sample. It seems to me that it would be better to show the overall performance of your system. And it would be possible to observe how the slope of profit curve changes after the data unknown to the system starts
Allow the use of cookies to log in to the MQL5.com website.
Please enable the necessary setting in your browser, otherwise you will not be able to log in.
You are signed in. Two-factor authentication has been disabled. Set it up again and scan a new QR code, or continue with two-factor authentication disabled.
And you put yours out in the open - let the masses use it and learn by practice, not by facts and arguments
If you put out an EA, even openly, even the most profitable one, even if you take it for free... in my opinion it won't have any effect on the market. Just in some part of the world... in Russian-speaking territory, for example, there will be users. They will just use it. Perhaps a few forums will devote a topic or two to this Expert Advisor.
Originally I also thought that a profitable Expert Advisor would make or break something on the market (it seems so obvious that you believe it without thinking), but arguments like the one brought by SK. made me think twice and now I no longer have a strong opinion on the matter.
Of course no market expert will move it, this is a delusion. ...
this is for part day
i don't trade with the grail
advisors are handled manually
If you divide your profit commensurately. you raised thirty pips! - only thirty!!!!
Surprised me too, three lots bet showed that's thirty times what I bet!!!!!
If you divide your profit proportionately. you raised 30 pips! - only thirty!!!!
Well, 0.1 lot can do it too.
I bet 1 - 6 lots to my own.
0.1 - that's a lot if you don't trust your system.
This is for the evening.
Surprised me too, three lots bet showed that's thirty times what I bet!!!!!
If you divide your profit proportionately. you raised thirty pips! - only thirty!!!!
Well, 0.1 lot can do it too.
I bet 1 - 6 lots to my own.
0.1 - that's a lot if you don't trust your system.
This is for the evening.
I'm interested purely in the mathematics of the matter,
I do not care what lot, the main thing is the ratio of money invested and profit!
If the investment is 10% a year. then it's easier to keep the money in the bank!
If you invest 30-50%, then you can give it to a fund for management!
If they invest 300-500 lots a year, they will have to draw in other people's capital and earn from them not by 1-6 lots, which is ridiculous in theory, but by dozens!
Can you share an idea in general terms? Or is the idea of the post to sell the black box without telling the idea?
Well, for this period from September last year to April this year, what part was used to optimise the strategy (if at all) and what data was out of sample i.e. unknown strategies it ran on this story. Or was it optimised over the entire six-month period?
It is possible to show a clear run over such and such a period - the profit graph is so-and-so. From this period from so-and-so to so-and-so the data was used to optimise the rest out of sample. It seems to me that it would be better to show the overall performance of your system.
And it would be possible to observe how the slope of profit curve changes after the data unknown to the system starts