Comments | EURUSD ecn | Buy Trading Robot (Expert Advisor) for MetaTrader 5

Sergey Porphiryev 2024.04.21 11:29 #1

On my broker (Roboforex), it still hasn't started...

Demo tests based on real ticks showed consistent losses. But darn it (or rather the advisor's price) tempted me to buy and try trading on demo.

As a result, opening signals were consistently executed. However, the management of open positions was clearly not well thought out by the author, or was designed for specific brokers or conditions... (for example, quotes with 4 digits after the decimal point...) In general, every open position immediately started moving the stop, and almost always the very first stop triggered due to volatility. Barely covering the cost of opening the position on an ECN account...

I wish the author would refine the advisor so that it shows profitability even in tests based on real ticks.

Maryna Kauzova 2024.04.22 22:41 #2

Sergey Porphiryev #:

On my broker (Roboforex), it still hasn't started...

Demo tests based on real ticks showed consistent losses. But darn it (or rather the advisor's price) tempted me to buy and try trading on demo.

As a result, opening signals were consistently executed. However, the management of open positions was clearly not well thought out by the author, or was designed for specific brokers or conditions... (for example, quotes with 4 digits after the decimal point...) In general, every open position immediately started moving the stop, and almost always the very first stop triggered due to volatility. Barely covering the cost of opening the position on an ECN account...

I wish the author would refine the advisor so that it shows profitability even in tests based on real ticks.

Good afternoon. Looking at your trading results. I see that in the end the trade was in the plus side. This is a scalping trading algorithm, so the life cycle of each order is quite short. The Expert Advisor uses a short stop loss, which makes it as safe as possible. There is almost no drawdown, as you can see both in the test results and in your trading results.

Yes, the EA is constantly improving and will continue to improve. This is one of the most important points of my work....

Sergey Porphiryev 2024.04.24 22:59 #3

Maryna Kauzova #:

Good afternoon. Looking at your trading results. I see that in the end the trade was in the plus side. This is a scalping trading algorithm, so the life cycle of each order is quite short. The Expert Advisor uses a short stop loss, which makes it as safe as possible. There is almost no drawdown, as you can see both in the test results and in your trading results.

Yes, the EA is constantly improving and will continue to improve. This is one of the most important points of my work....

Good afternoon. Yes, you're right, I apologize, I did indeed come across too harshly... I mentioned stable losses when there were none... It was more akin to treading water

On tests using "every tick" - it shows a stable income. On tests using "every tick based on real ticks" - it showed a stable loss. However, actual trading showed a microscopic profitability.

I'm confident it can be refined. Because if you look at the trade history, you can see that the signal itself was opening correctly. I'll keep an eye on it ;)
With all due respect and best wishes.

Maryna Kauzova 2024.04.25 21:29 #4

Sergey Porphiryev #:

Good afternoon. Yes, you're right, I apologize, I did indeed come across too harshly... I mentioned stable losses when there were none... It was more akin to treading water

On tests using "every tick" - it shows a stable income. On tests using "every tick based on real ticks" - it showed a stable loss. However, actual trading showed a microscopic profitability.

I'm confident it can be refined. Because if you look at the trade history, you can see that the signal itself was opening correctly. I'll keep an eye on it ;)
With all due respect and best wishes.

Yes, of course, the product is constantly being improved and refined. And we will continue to work on it, as its potential is really large and enormous.
The fact that it uses such a short stop loss and gives at least a small profit is already very good. In any case, the profit will grow over time.
You are right that it seems to be treading on the ground. Such times will be and have been in history. This can be traced even in the strategy tester. Trading is organised in such a way that the Expert Advisor, as you said, treads on the ground, and after a couple of trades with a high profit rate, significantly increasing the profit.
And I repeat once again that we have been working, are working and will work on further improvement of the product....
Thank you very much for your sincere feedback. It is very important for us to know the results of as many people as possible.
Have a good day and great trading....