Is making easy money out of thin air on the forex market immoral?

 
"Trading is essentially parasitising the economy, the people. Unproductive labour. Siphoning money out of nothing, or rather out of the productive sector of the economy, out of people-workers. And this is immoral. Because the easy income is provided at the expense of real labor. And this is a parasitic model.



The forex player is a parasite on society. And "trading" is essentially theft and idleness.
Stealing is embezzling the wallets of other "traders", as well as kitchens. And loafing - sitting in your pants in front of the monitor at home, clicking buoy-sells and making easy money! Which workers and toilers earn in the sweat of their brow!
 
webgopnik:
"Trading" is essentially parasitizing the economy, people. Unproductive labour. Siphoning money out of nothing, or rather out of the productive sector of the economy, people-workers. And this is immoral. Because an easy income is provided at the expense of real work. And this is a parasitic model.



Forex player is a parasite on society. And "trading" is essentially theft and idleness.
Stealing is embezzling the wallets of other "traders", as well as kitchens. And loafing - sitting in your pants in front of the monitor at home, clicking buyselves and making easy money! Which workers and toilers earn in the sweat of their brow!

Are you the patron saint of the poor? Who are you writing to?

 
webgopnik:
"Trading" is essentially parasitizing the economy, people. Unproductive labour. Siphoning money out of nothing, or rather out of the productive sector of the economy, people-workers. And this is immoral. Because the easy income is provided at the expense of real labor. And this is a parasitic model.



The forex player is a parasite on society. And "trading" is essentially theft and idleness.
Stealing is embezzling the wallets of other "traders", as well as kitchens. And loafing - sitting in your pants in front of the monitor at home, clicking buoy-sells and making easy money! Which workers and toilers earn in the sweat of their brow!

you should be banned - you're just a forum trash-talker

 
webgopnik:
"Trading" is essentially parasitizing the economy, people. Unproductive labour. Siphoning money out of nothing, or rather out of the productive sector of the economy, people-workers. And this is immoral. Because the easy income is provided at the expense of real labor. And this is a parasitic model.



The forex player is a parasite on society. And "trading" is essentially theft and idleness.
Stealing is embezzling the wallets of other "traders", as well as kitchens. And loafing - sitting in your pants in front of the monitor at home, clicking buyselves and making easy money! Which workers and toilers earn in the sweat of their brow!

Schumpeter Josef to the rescue. Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy) A good book. There are such thoughts and answers there too).

You could also say the strong has more rights than the weak and that is immoral. Williams has, I am lazy but law-abiding, so I am a trader.

And yet it is less immoral than stealing)

 
webgopnik:
"Trading" is essentially parasitizing the economy, people. Unproductive labor. Pumping money out of nothing, or rather out of the productive sector of the economy, people-workers. And this is immoral. Because the easy income is provided at the expense of real labor. And this is a parasitic model.



The forex player is a parasite on society. And "trading" is essentially theft and idleness.
Stealing is embezzling the wallets of other "traders", as well as kitchens. And loafing - sitting in your pants in front of the monitor at home, clicking buyselves and making easy money! Which workers and toilers earn in the sweat of their brow!

A fundamentally flawed judgement. Stealing is immoral, it is when tangible or intangible assets are borrowed without the owner's consent. But in the market everything is done by agreement of the parties: a broker (or other kind of intermediary) takes a commission and brings traders together, the traders' money is redistributed between themselves minus the commissions. Brokerage house owners go to the shops and spend the money on yachts and villas (stimulating civil and shipbuilding, etc.), the same is done by successful traders.

Also, brokers and traders pay taxes (where they don't, it's a regulatory problem in those countries).

Any legitimate movement of money in the economy is useful! As soon as the money starts to move, taxes start to be paid. Traders are like earthworms, you cannot see them and do not understand their usefulness, but without them the soil would turn to stone and all life on earth would stop, because plants cannot grow, herbivores would die and carnivores would follow.

Traders, traders, merchants are the life, prosperity of the economy! The more small and medium-sized businesses there are, the more stable and robust the economy is. The enlargement of big business and the extinction of small business leads to economic downturn and destabilization.

Therefore, to be a trader is an honour, be proud to be a trader!

 
Valeriy Yastremskiy:

Schumpeter Josef to the rescue. Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy) A good book. There are such thoughts and answers there too).

You could also say the strong has more rights than the weak and that's immoral. Williams has, I am lazy but law-abiding, so I am a trader.

And this is less immoral than stealing).

It is not shameful to be strong or weak as it is defined in motion. It is shameful to be an immovable vegetable with a head, legs and arms on your torso.

 
You're all speculators, parasites on the body of society, producing neither product nor added value, so it's like that, isn't it?
 

Look closely at individual economies - the easier it is to do business in a country, the more stable the economy (we are not talking now about the size of the economy, the economy can be large but not stable).

A great example is Singapore: a country with no minerals and a very limited area has the most stable economy in the world, and why? - Because registering and doing business in this microscopic country is the easiest compared to other countries. This also has a positive effect on the level of ordinary people, not business people.

 
Aleksey Semenov:
You are all speculators, parasites on the body of society, producing neither product nor added value, so it's like that, isn't it?

You don't have to produce a product, just pay taxes. if you don't pay taxes, you are a parasite no matter what you do.

 
Aleksey Semenov:
You're all speculators, parasites on the body of society, producing neither product nor added value, so it's like that, isn't it?
Well, that's the way it is.
 
webgopnik:
"Trading is essentially parasitising the economy, the people. Unproductive labour. Siphoning money out of nothing, or rather out of the productive sector of the economy, out of people-workers. And this is immoral. Because the easy income is provided at the expense of real labor. And this is a parasitic model.



The forex player is a parasite on society. And "trading" is essentially theft and idleness.
Stealing is embezzling the wallets of other "traders", as well as kitchens. And loafing - sitting in your pants in front of the monitor at home, clicking buyselves and making easy money! Which workers and toilers earn by the sweat of their brow!
If you don't like easy money, go to a factory to earn hard money :)
Reason: